Draft grades spreadsheet

[Risen Star]

 

[unionjack8]

, pretty much what most of us thought. B-/C+

 

[cityochamps]

Speaking of Mel Kipper, gives all teams but 4 a Grade with a B in it. Weird

 

[Risen Star]

Speaking of Mel Kipper, gives all teams but 4 a Grade with a B in it. Weird

Yeah that's just the sissy society we live in today where you're not supposed to offend anyone. So the grading scale is basically A to C. He doesn't even do winners and losers anymore. It's winners and question marks instead. People have feelings. We can't risk hurting them.

He's far from the only one doing it.

It's the same reason why people are calling the team in Washington that abortion of a name and their actual name is suddenly a curse word.

 

[Pass2Run]

Means absolutely nothing.

I generally agree that the Eagles had a good draft.

I don't like the Waletzko pick, like at all. I think there were better tackles to be had, but I see why they did it.

Other than that, our draft was relatively solid. We only had so much to work with. I expect us to sign enough FAs soon to complete our roster.

 

[cnuball21]

Yup, no surprise here.

 

[RS12]

Even the homers at Blogging the Boys were meh on this draft.

https://www.bloggingtheboys.com/202...undrafted-free-agents-tyler-smith-de-williams

 

[Pass2Run]

It's going to be an OK year personnel-wise, because we did find some players.

Thing is, some of our UDFA guys are as good as the guys we drafted.

It was deep this year. So we added talent to an already-talented team. Other teams in our division are just now adding talent.

Can Nakobe Dean compete with Parsons?

Nope.

If Ridgeway pans out, it's going to be an especially interesting draft.

The more I look at Waletzko, the more I see what others may have seen in the war room.

 

[Acceptablename]

Yeah that's just the sissy society we live in today where you're not supposed to offend anyone. So the grading scale is basically A to C. He doesn't even do winners and losers anymore. It's winners and question marks instead. People have feelings. We can't risk hurting them.

He's far from the only one doing it.

It's the same reason why people are calling the team in Washington that abortion of a name and their actual name is suddenly a curse word.

Exhibit A

 

[MonsterD]

Mine is a C+ they did some nice value picks but weighted for that first pick, not great. Also this chart is close to my own anecdotal thoughts the last few days, Jets and Ravens destroyed it and Eagles definitely better than Cowboys, Commanders worse.

One huge anomaly is the Steelers with their being 9th or 10th best, no way, I liked Pickens, but that draft is very blah.

I would also switch the Giants and Colts placement. Colts had a very sneaky good draft.

 

[Acceptablename]

It's going to be an OK year personnel-wise, because we did find some players.

Thing is, some of our UDFA guys are as good as the guys we drafted.

It was deep this year. So we added talent to an already-talented team. Other teams in our division are just now adding talent.

Can Nakobe Dean compete with Parsons?

Nope.

If Ridgeway pans out, it's going to be an especially interesting draft.

The more I look at Waletzko, the more I see what others may have seen in the war room.

Dean had injury problems at Georgia he’ll have em in the pros

 

[Pass2Run]

I give them a solid B.