Giants only had 1 holding penalty

ConstantReboot

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,231
Reaction score
9,891
We sacked Jones 5 times and had more than 20 pressures against him. Yet they were only called for 1 holding penalty.

While We kept Cooper Rush clean with no sacks, and no pressure, and had a total of 3 holding penalties.

The film doesn't lie. Many times Parsons was held but there was no call. Noah Brown was mugged and there was no call.

Yet we get called for ticky tack fouls like a Tyler Smith's call and the personal foul on Wilson.

What is up with these refs calling everything one sided? It's obvious that they aren't giving us any leeway when it comes to penalties.
 

glimmerman

Well-Known Member
Messages
30,041
Reaction score
29,902
They held Parsons all night. If you have the game recorded. Watch the 2nd quarter with 7:40 left it’s a 3rd down. He wasn’t held but 3 people blocking and he runs one guy over and just a split second late. Was a incomplete but blew jones up..
 

Kingofholland

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,921
Reaction score
6,331
We sacked Jones 5 times and had more than 20 pressures against him. Yet they were only called for 1 holding penalty.

While We kept Cooper Rush clean with no sacks, and no pressure, and had a total of 3 holding penalties.

The film doesn't lie. Many times Parsons was held but there was no call. Noah Brown was mugged and there was no call.

Yet we get called for ticky tack fouls like a Tyler Smith's call and the personal foul on Wilson.

What is up with these refs calling everything one sided? It's obvious that they aren't giving us any leeway when it comes to penalties.

There's holding on almost every play. We got away with a few no calls, but the holding on the Giants defense was so blatant it makes you wonder how they missed it. Hopefully we don't see that crew again.
 

glimmerman

Well-Known Member
Messages
30,041
Reaction score
29,902
We had so many penalties. Including presnap. We need to get rid of our O-Line coach.. After a while it comes back on coaching..
 

ConstantReboot

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,231
Reaction score
9,891
There's holding on almost every play. We got away with a few no calls, but the holding on the Giants defense was so blatant it makes you wonder how they missed it. Hopefully we don't see that crew again.

That's true. But if they call holding on us, then there should also be a significant amount of holding penalties on the other team as well. Parsons was mugged several times on the way to the QB. Yet there was no calls.

When you compare that to Tyler Smith and Farniok them seem very ticky tack, which other teams consistently get away with.

I don't think Farniok's penalty was a hold.
 

KJJ

You Have an Axe to Grind
Messages
57,103
Reaction score
35,169
We sacked Jones 5 times and had more than 20 pressures against him. Yet they were only called for 1 holding penalty.

While We kept Cooper Rush clean with no sacks, and no pressure, and had a total of 3 holding penalties.

The film doesn't lie. Many times Parsons was held but there was no call. Noah Brown was mugged and there was no call.

Yet we get called for ticky tack fouls like a Tyler Smith's call and the personal foul on Wilson.

What is up with these refs calling everything one sided? It's obvious that they aren't giving us any leeway when it comes to penalties.

There has to be some holding if your QB isn’t being pressured or sacked.
 

baltcowboy

Well-Known Member
Messages
15,148
Reaction score
16,901
We sacked Jones 5 times and had more than 20 pressures against him. Yet they were only called for 1 holding penalty.

While We kept Cooper Rush clean with no sacks, and no pressure, and had a total of 3 holding penalties.

The film doesn't lie. Many times Parsons was held but there was no call. Noah Brown was mugged and there was no call.

Yet we get called for ticky tack fouls like a Tyler Smith's call and the personal foul on Wilson.

What is up with these refs calling everything one sided? It's obvious that they aren't giving us any leeway when it comes to penalties.
The job of the referees sometimes is to keep the games close for viewing purposes unfortunately.
 

Fizziksman

BanditHiro
Messages
5,109
Reaction score
3,503
There has to be some holding if your QB isn’t being pressured or sacked.

not necessarily. Holding usually are a product of a player being beat or a Quarter feeling the pressure and moving a different direction. Holding at the line of scrimmage are usually bad hand placement errors.
 

KJJ

You Have an Axe to Grind
Messages
57,103
Reaction score
35,169
not necessarily. Holding usually are a product of a player being beat or a Quarter feeling the pressure and moving a different direction. Holding at the line of scrimmage are usually bad hand placement errors.

Holding is a judgment call. I remember last season they were talking to one of the former officials in the booth and he said there’s some holding on a lot of plays. He said you try and avoid calling it unless it’s flagrant.
 

gimmesix

Fat, drunk and stupid is no way to go through life
Messages
37,937
Reaction score
34,955
We sacked Jones 5 times and had more than 20 pressures against him. Yet they were only called for 1 holding penalty.

While We kept Cooper Rush clean with no sacks, and no pressure, and had a total of 3 holding penalties.

The film doesn't lie. Many times Parsons was held but there was no call. Noah Brown was mugged and there was no call.

Yet we get called for ticky tack fouls like a Tyler Smith's call and the personal foul on Wilson.

What is up with these refs calling everything one sided? It's obvious that they aren't giving us any leeway when it comes to penalties.

Maybe our guys need to learn the art of the flail. It's the same thing with some quarterbacks and their ability to draw attention to roughing. Our QBs have always taken the shots without any drama. Romo would get nailed but be so focused on the play that he made it look like it was no big deal. Then, you have QBs like Brady who fall down with their arms flailing if a defender breezes past them.
 

slick325

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,130
Reaction score
8,814
That's absurd. They dropped back to pass so many times and the rush was so relentless, there had to be more than 1 hold. I saw a few just watching the game on TV.

Add to that, Jones scrambled so much that I'm sure there were holds that could have brought plenty of those gains back.

The refs were horrible last night. Everyone has an off night. The League needs to address it with the crew though.
 

conner01

Well-Known Member
Messages
28,055
Reaction score
25,976
I s
We sacked Jones 5 times and had more than 20 pressures against him. Yet they were only called for 1 holding penalty.

While We kept Cooper Rush clean with no sacks, and no pressure, and had a total of 3 holding penalties.

The film doesn't lie. Many times Parsons was held but there was no call. Noah Brown was mugged and there was no call.

Yet we get called for ticky tack fouls like a Tyler Smith's call and the personal foul on Wilson.

What is up with these refs calling everything one sided? It's obvious that they aren't giving us any leeway when it comes to penalties.
I seen two extremely obvious ones on their defense
Noah Brown was used like a tackling dummy but no calls
 

nightrain

Since 1971
Messages
14,539
Reaction score
24,399
Did you notice the Refs seemed to hold court every time a flag was thrown against the Giants? It as if they were voting on the penalty and looking for a majority vote to not pick up the flag.
 

Motorola

Well-Known Member
Messages
10,560
Reaction score
9,238
We sacked Jones 5 times and had more than 20 pressures against him. Yet they were only called for 1 holding penalty.

While We kept Cooper Rush clean with no sacks, and no pressure, and had a total of 3 holding penalties.

The film doesn't lie. Many times Parsons was held but there was no call. Noah Brown was mugged and there was no call.

Yet we get called for ticky tack fouls like a Tyler Smith's call and the personal foul on Wilson.

What is up with these refs calling everything one sided? It's obvious that they aren't giving us any leeway when it comes to penalties.
Until Jerry Jones confronts the other 31 franchise owners- specifically the Maras the McCaskeys, the Rooneys, the Fords, the Hunts, Mark Davis, Robert Kraft, Woody Johnson, Gayle Benson, Jeffrey Lurie, Daniel Synder, Arthur Blank, etc. THE NFL IS THE ULTIMATE PROFITABLE SPORTS LEAGUE DUE TO MY INGENUITY THAT STARTED 25 YEARS AGO - AND CONTINUES THROUGH TODAY.
Stop putting roadblocks to my team winning and maybe succeeding = contrived calls against my team by the officials.
 
Top