Which of these QBs would you take Dak over?

[WillieBeamen]

Hurts
Jones
Howell

Love
Goff
Fields
Cousins

Carr
Mayfield
Young
Ridder

Purdy
Smith
Murray
Stafford

Jackson
Watson
Pickett
Burrow

Stroud
Lawerence
Tannehill
Richardson

Mahomes
Herbert
Wilson
Garropolo

Allen
Rodgers
Tua
Jones

 

[zerofill]

I read that wrong lol had to edit... thought you said take over dak lol

90% let's put it that way.

 

[Sydla]

Hurts
Jones
Howell

Love
Goff
Fields
Cousins

Carr
Mayfield
Young
Ridder

Purdy
Smith
Murray
Stafford

Jackson
Watson
Pickett
Burrow

Stroud
Lawerence
Tannehill
Richardson

Mahomes
Herbert
Wilson
Garropolo

Allen
Rodgers
Tua
Jones

That's 10. So Dak is in that 8-14 range which is fair. There are some I thought long and hard about such as Goff. Obviously I mean a healthy Rodgers over Dak not the broken down one. LOL.

 

[RonWashington]

Hurts
Jones
Howell

Love
Goff
Fields
Cousins

Carr
Mayfield
Young
Ridder

Purdy
Smith
Murray
Stafford

Jackson
Watson
Pickett
Burrow

Stroud
Lawerence
Tannehill
Richardson

Mahomes
Herbert
Wilson
Garropolo

Allen
Rodgers
Tua
Jones

To be honest an awful lot of spares on that list or at the least not much of an upgrade over Dak . Four names jump out . Allen Burrow Mahomes Herbert .

 

[MysteryIceGuro]

Hurts
Jones
Love
Goff
Cousins
Carr
Mayfield
Young
Purdy
Smith
Murray
Stafford
Jackson
Burrow
Stroud
Lawrence
Tannehill
Richardson
Mahomes
Herbert
Garappolo
Allen
Tua
Rodgers

So basically about 90% of the league’s QB’s (I would take OVER Dak. Not Dak over them. Dak is a backup QB playing dress up as a starter)

 

[RonWashington]

Stroud obviously the Texans should be delighted the Panthers passed on .

 

[WillieBeamen]

The only ones im taking Dak over is

Jimmy G
Ridder
Pickett
Fields
Mayfield
D.Jones
M. jones
Tannehill

 

[Jake]

Hurts
Jones
Love
Goff
Cousins
Carr
Mayfield
Young
Purdy
Smith
Murray
Stafford
Jackson
Burrow
Stroud
Lawrence
Tannehill
Richardson
Mahomes
Herbert
Garappolo
Allen
Tua
Rodgers

So basically about 90% of the league’s QB’s

I hadn't gotten the impression that you'd take Dak over 90% of the league's QBs.

Read the title again.

 

[bewp7]

with contract just qb that flat out stink or are a bad guy with a even worse contract

so i would take dak over fields, zach wilson, also deshaun watson

that is it

to me dak with his contract is bttom 4 qb in the nfl

every other qb i think would give cowboys a better chance to win

either they are a better qb or are way cheaper

 

[Gangsta Spanksta]

The only ones im taking Dak over is

Jimmy G
Ridder
Pickett
Fields
Mayfield
D.Jones
M. jones
Tannehill

You're a lot more generous than NFL.COM. They had Dak at #12 this week. I'm sure by Thursday he is going to fall on their rankings.

 

[MysteryIceGuro]

I hadn't gotten the impression that you'd take Dak over 90% of the league's QBs.

Read the title again.

Looks like I made a bad read just like our QB

 

[Chuck 54]

Hurts
Jones
Howell

Love
Goff
Fields
Cousins

Carr
Mayfield
Young
Ridder

Purdy
Smith
Murray
Stafford

Jackson
Watson
Pickett
Burrow

Stroud
Lawerence
Tannehill
Richardson

Mahomes
Herbert
Wilson
Garropolo

Allen
Rodgers
Tua
Jones

Why? What’s the point? Are they available? Maybe you should make a list of available QBs and ask the question.

 

[RonWashington]

The only ones im taking Dak over is

Jimmy G
Ridder
Pickett
Fields
Mayfield
D.Jones
M. jones
Tannehill

You take Sam Howell Kirk Cousins over Dak ? Boy you are down on him aren’t you .

 

[Adreme]

Hurts
Jones
Howell

Love
Goff
Fields
Cousins

Carr
Mayfield
Young
Ridder

Purdy
Smith
Murray
Stafford

Jackson
Watson
Pickett
Burrow

Stroud
Lawerence
Tannehill
Richardson

Mahomes
Herbert
Wilson
Garropolo

Allen
Rodgers
Tua
Jones

Throwing out rookies because they have both shown nothing and it has only been 3 games.

In the NFC basically just Hurts though I am curious about the upside of Jordan Love and Brock Purdy. They are younger so even if they are slightly worse that could be interesting to have. In the AFC: Mahomes, Allen, Jackson, Burrow, Lawrence, Herbert, Tua, and if it were only for 1 year Rodgers. So basically 10 total and 2 possible based on youth and upside and that is me being as aggressive as reasonably possible in taking other QBs.

 

[Shane612]

About half of them, but to be honest, I don't know who half of them are.

 

[Sydla]

You take Sam Howell Kirk Cousins over Dak ? Boy you are down on him aren’t you .

Not sure about Howell but definitely Cousins is not a crazy choice to take over Dak. For all the criticism that Cousins chokes, what exactly has Dak done?

 

[RonWashington]

Not sure about Howell but definitely Cousins is not a crazy choice to take over Dak. For all the criticism that Cousins chokes, what exactly has Dak done?

Cousins is like a lot of guys on that list not an upgrade over what’s already here . And Cousins when the pocket collapses is going down like Jerry Quarry from a right hook . Dak can at least use his legs .

 

[RonWashington]

Sam Howell might develop today 170 yards 4 picks against Buffalo . No not trading Prescott for a project .

 

[basel90]

Lawrence
Jimmy G
Ridder
Pickett
Mayfield
Murray
Tannehill
Purdy
Smith
Murray
Stafford
Jackson
Burrow
Stroud
Tannehill

 

[Pessimist_cowboy]

A lot of them.