Who gets you more back in a trade, Lamb or Pickens?

Coogiguy03

Coogiguy03

Well-Known Member
Messages
45,955
Reaction score
39,081
In a trade at this point in their careers, Pickens obviously younger, who would get you more back in a trade? Lamb has made a name for himself, he's been doing great since he entered the league, is he a diva at times, yes! Pickens had a decent career in Pitt, and had a stellar season in his first year as a Cowboy, was it a fluke, or is he mentally there to help a team win even when things aren't going his way??? Please give your thoughts!
 
Lamb.
He was a consensus blue chip player, expected to go in the top 10. Though for some reason he slipped in the draft.
He has been consistent in his play every year.

Pickens is a 2nd round pick, which I think he slipped in the draft. I think he was considered a late 1st round pick by some.
He has produced each year, because though he had lousy QB’s. But this past year showed why he could have been a first round pick.
 
Really, lets see you have a guy that I perennially top 3 in the league, no real threat opposite to him. His first year:935 and 1102 second season with amari opposite side. Don't forget his rookie year Dak went down and entire O line was destroyed by injuries, that's what got Dalton injured. Most likely would have been much higher if he had a QB and that QB had time to pass. 2022(first without Amari)1359, 2023:1749, 2024 1194(missed two games and played 6 of those 15 with a separated shoulder) and Rush was QB. Point is Pickens just had his first 1000 yard season(no evidence that sustainable) make all the excuses about Pittsburgh not having QB, the system, etc. Ceedee has played with a backup QB 24 games of his 6 year career and put up better numbers w/o a true #2 for the past 3 years.
 
Personally just cant understand the talk about trading pickens to get better on D. At this point now id have him over lamb but ideally I want both here to give us that offensive threat. We have 1st round picks to trade we dont need to weaken the offence to better the D, that just switches the problem ‍♂️ keep both & build around them by being clever in FA & the draft.
 
Coogiguy03 said:
In a trade at this point in their careers, Pickens obviously younger, who would get you more back in a trade? Lamb has made a name for himself, he's been doing great since he entered the league, is he a diva at times, yes! Pickens had a decent career in Pitt, and had a stellar season in his first year as a Cowboy, was it a fluke, or is he mentally there to help a team win even when things aren't going his way??? Please give your thoughts!
Click to expand...

CD we be result in large dead cap hit.
 
Nowhere did I mention that we should trade him, just was asking who gets more value. Everyone seems to think Lamb, I can see why. Pickens just seems to be a game changer even though his routes seem to be limited
 
Coogiguy03 said:
Nowhere did I mention that we should trade him, just was asking who gets more value. Everyone seems to think Lamb, I can see why. Pickens just seems to be a game changer even though his routes seem to be limited
Click to expand...
CD balled out in 2023 without Pickens. Pickens played well with CD, but both are extremely talented.
 
Coogiguy03 said:
Nowhere did I mention that we should trade him, just was asking who gets more value. Everyone seems to think Lamb
Click to expand...
I didn't say anything about a trade.

The answer is Lamb. Just as I said.

You should have just asked instead of starting yet another thread.
 
big dog cowboy said:
I didn't say anything about a trade.

The answer is Lamb. Just as I said.

You should have just asked instead of starting yet another thread.
Click to expand...
Easily you thought you were that important that I was talking to you, it was a general statement, PLEASE take your chill pills 100MG
 
Coogiguy03 said:
In a trade at this point in their careers, Pickens obviously younger, who would get you more back in a trade? Lamb has made a name for himself, he's been doing great since he entered the league, is he a diva at times, yes! Pickens had a decent career in Pitt, and had a stellar season in his first year as a Cowboy, was it a fluke, or is he mentally there to help a team win even when things aren't going his way??? Please give your thoughts!
Click to expand...

CD will get you more. He is a proven #1 WR. Where Pickens has some great traits but also some questionmarks.


I think Pickens will get you a very low first rounder or a high 2nd.

CD will get you a top 10 pick at least. Maybe paired with a high 2nd rounder.
 
TwentyOne said:
CD will get you more. He is a proven #1 WR. Where Pickens has some great traits but also some questionmarks.


I think Pickens will get you a very low first rounder or a high 2nd.

CD will get you a top 10 pick at least. Maybe paired with a high 2nd rounder.
Click to expand...
sweet!!!!
 
Lamb.

He's a bit of a choke artist with the drops...and he's a stat hoo-er like 4, but teams will value him over a haracter red flag like GP who just decided to put it together for a contract year.
 
Coogiguy03 said:
In a trade at this point in their careers, Pickens obviously younger, who would get you more back in a trade? Lamb has made a name for himself, he's been doing great since he entered the league, is he a diva at times, yes! Pickens had a decent career in Pitt, and had a stellar season in his first year as a Cowboy, was it a fluke, or is he mentally there to help a team win even when things aren't going his way??? Please give your thoughts!
Click to expand...
Lamb, Broaddus’s gang of seven said the Cowboys could get a Parsons type package for him..
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Staff online

Members online

... and 110 more.
Total: 14,996 (members: 210, guests: 14,786)
Robots: 1,408

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
474,578
Messages
14,546,383
Members
24,212
Latest member
JerryJonesSupporter
Back
Top