A familiar pattern has developed over the last seven years with Dak

OGSixshooter said:
How did it work out for the Chiefs? Bro...we need to draft a QB. Romo and Dak were not lightning striking us...that was a carpet burn.
Click to expand...
If I remember correctly, most were shocked that Mahomes went as early as he did and that the Chiefs traded up for him. They happened to be right but the draft is a crapshoot. Not defending how the cowboys have been managed
 
DarkVader33 said:
If I remember correctly, most were shocked that Mahomes went as early as he did and that the Chiefs traded up for him. They happened to be right but the draft is a crapshoot. Not defending how the cowboys have been managed
Click to expand...
"Real men make their own luck." - Jerk from the Titanic movie

It was 50/50. Obviously the Chiefs thought the world of him. It's key to remember in both GOAT stories - Mahomes and Brady- the org drafted them, invested in them, replaced the existing starter and then proceeded to pair the QB with all-time great coaches. It wasn't just that the Patriots were lucky to draft Brady, but also lucky that Brady went to the Patriots.

The overall lesson here is that if the org isn't primed to groom a new QB and replace the middling current starter you got no shot at finding that guy other than dumb pure luck. It was not dumb pure luck that created Mahomes or Brady. It was deliberate intentional investment. No risk it, no biscuit.
 
Cowboys5217 said:
Once again, as the largest slice of the salary cap pie, Dak is the most responsible player for the bad playoff record. He also directly choked the 49ers game away and was the worst player on the field for the first half of the GB playoff game.
Click to expand...
If only Dak's defense could hold the other team to under 3 points...then we can REALLY see what Dak can do with 2 all pro WRs and an intergalactic field goal kicker!
 
OGSixshooter said:
How did it work out for the Chiefs? Bro...we need to draft a QB. Romo and Dak were not lightning striking us...that was a carpet burn.
Click to expand...
He's trying to use outliers to disprove a general rule.

"Hey! Because the Browns can't find a QB it means the Cowboys should never spend high draft capital on QBs!" - midwit
 
OGSixshooter said:
"Real men make their own luck." - Jerk from the Titanic movie

It was 50/50. Obviously the Chiefs thought the world of him. It's key to remember in both GOAT stories - Mahomes and Brady- the org drafted them, invested in them, replaced the existing starter and then proceeded to pair the QB with all-time great coaches. It wasn't just that the Patriots were lucky to draft Brady, but also lucky that Brady went to the Patriots.

The overall lesson here is that if the org isn't primed to groom a new QB and replace the middling current starter you got no shot at finding that guy other than dumb pure luck. It was not dumb pure luck that created Mahomes or Brady. It was deliberate intentional investment. No risk it, no biscuit.
Click to expand...
I know you won’t agree but Dak, nor Romo for that matter, have had good team management. Dak has his warts but I’m not going to completely blame him. We’ve never had complete teams, or complete enough to actually compete for a championship. A couple came close though.

Brady and Mahomes went to much better situations and were great. But you don’t need a great QB to win SBs and there is plenty of proof of that. I’m not going to list all the other things that need to go right to win but I’m sure you know what they are.

Jerry deserves all the criticism he gets. Dak deserves some, maybe a lot. But do we have to hear it in every single thread? Even when it’s not about them? (I’m obviously not referring to this thread).

These boards are dominated by the negative, understandably so, and then complain about the few that are overly hopeful. Why can’t you let them be instead of making it your, not you specifically, job to make them see the light?

That’s all. Sorry about the book. Lol
 
GINeric said:
How did drafting quarterback after quarterback after quarterback work out for teams like the Browns, Vikings, Jets, etc??? I definitely can go on.....
Click to expand...
Geno Smith and Baker Mayfield look like completely different QB’s when actually given a good supporting cast with Seattle and Tampa Bay. It’s not about the QB chosen. It’s ownership and the decision to push reset so often and striking out with better coaches (along with poor and inconsistent scouting/drafting and zero team core identity). The 1-3 year ejector button on each team’s coaching staff and front office is the ticket to a perennial terrible franchise.

After the six year (utilizing one or more franchise tags) mark with a new QB-if the team has not made it to a CCG, then the team should pull the plug unless the QB is setting all time records for passing in lots of major categories. 6 years is plenty of sample size to take that step in the postseason. Partial or full rebuild at that point is best for the franchise in future years. One of Dallas’ biggest failures is the inability to move on from good players if they are not part of the solution to deep playoff runs.
 
Risen Star said:
Click to expand...

omg i said that the other day. he’s due for a season long injury. i am praying not as i think this defense can get us to the playoffs if it all comes together. but if he gets hurt for 5 or more games, NYJ get a top 10 pic. and we get the 25+ of the packers.
 
Blitzen said:
Geno Smith and Baker Mayfield look like completely different QB’s when actually given a good supporting cast with Seattle and Tampa Bay. It’s not about the QB chosen. It’s ownership and the decision to push reset so often and striking out with better coaches (along with poor and inconsistent scouting/drafting and zero team core identity). The 1-3 year ejector button on each team’s coaching staff and front office is the ticket to a perennial terrible franchise.

After the six year (utilizing one or more franchise tags) mark with a new QB-if the team has not made it to a CCG, then the team should pull the plug unless the QB is setting all time records for passing in lots of major categories. 6 years is plenty of sample size to take that step in the postseason. Partial or full rebuild at that point is best for the franchise in future years. One of Dallas’ biggest failures is the inability to move on from good players if they are not part of the solution to deep playoff runs.
Click to expand...

Great post, but there are alot of quarterbacks who didn't get to a CCG in their first 6 seasons and that includes elite quarterbacks as well.
 
DarkVader33 said:
I know you won’t agree but Dak, nor Romo for that matter, have had good team management. Dak has his warts but I’m not going to completely blame him. We’ve never had complete teams, or complete enough to actually compete for a championship. A couple came close though.

Brady and Mahomes went to much better situations and were great. But you don’t need a great QB to win SBs and there is plenty of proof of that. I’m not going to list all the other things that need to go right to win but I’m sure you know what they are.

Jerry deserves all the criticism he gets. Dak deserves some, maybe a lot. But do we have to hear it in every single thread? Even when it’s not about them? (I’m obviously not referring to this thread).

These boards are dominated by the negative, understandably so, and then complain about the few that are overly hopeful. Why can’t you let them be instead of making it your, not you specifically, job to make them see the light?

That’s all. Sorry about the book. Lol
Click to expand...
We never had a complete team? 10-13 pro bowlers isn't complete? Please describe what a "complete" team looks like.

Mind you, here are the teams that Mahomes won with:

Kansas City Chiefs (2019–2024)
  • 2019 (Super Bowl LIV)
    • Offense: 5th (451 points)
    • Defense: 7th (308 points)
  • 2020 (Super Bowl LV)
    • Offense: 6th (473 points)
    • Defense: 10th (362 points)
  • 2022 (Super Bowl LVII)
    • Offense: 1st (496 points)
    • Defense: 16th (369 points)
  • 2023 (Super Bowl LVIII)
    • Offense: 15th (371 points)
    • Defense: 2nd (294 points)
  • 2024 (Super Bowl LIX)
    • Offense: 14th (372 points)
    • Defense: 5th (304 points)
Bottom line is that if you have a "good enough" team and you make THAT MUCH MONEY...IT'S YOUR FAULT.
 
OGSixshooter said:
We never had a complete team? 10-13 pro bowlers isn't complete? Please describe what a "complete" team looks like.

Mind you, here are the teams that Mahomes won with:

Kansas City Chiefs (2019–2024)
  • 2019 (Super Bowl LIV)
    • Offense: 5th (451 points)
    • Defense: 7th (308 points)
  • 2020 (Super Bowl LV)
    • Offense: 6th (473 points)
    • Defense: 10th (362 points)
  • 2022 (Super Bowl LVII)
    • Offense: 1st (496 points)
    • Defense: 16th (369 points)
  • 2023 (Super Bowl LVIII)
    • Offense: 15th (371 points)
    • Defense: 2nd (294 points)
  • 2024 (Super Bowl LIX)
    • Offense: 14th (372 points)
    • Defense: 5th (304 points)
Bottom line is that if you have a "good enough" team and you make THAT MUCH MONEY...IT'S YOUR FAULT.
Click to expand...
That’s as close to complete as you can get. Thanks for proving my point. And no, Dak didn’t pay himself. Someone had to had given it to him. I actually liked Dak but I would have let him walk, although I don’t think he would have. Can you guess who the dummy was that gave it to him? Let me know if you need a clue. Lol
 
I thought this thread would mention the chronic "We/I have to do better" script after every key game that slipped away.
 
DarkVader33 said:
That’s as close to complete as you can get. Thanks for proving my point. And no, Dak didn’t pay himself. Someone had to had given it to him. I actually liked Dak but I would have let him walk, although I don’t think he would have. Can you guess who the dummy was that gave it to him? Let me know if you need a clue. Lol
Click to expand...
??? Mahomes took middling defenses to the SB.

Now, here's what Dak had:

2016 Season
  • Offense (Points): 5th
  • Offense (Yards): 5th
  • Defense (Points): 5th
  • Defense (Yards): 14th
  • Result: Lost Divisional Round to the Green Bay Packers.

2018 Season
  • Offense (Points): 22nd
  • Offense (Yards): 22nd
  • Defense (Points): 6th
  • Defense (Yards): 7th
  • Result: Won Wild Card Round against the Seattle Seahawks, lost Divisional Round to the Los Angeles Rams.

2021 Season
  • Offense (Points): 1st
  • Offense (Yards): 1st
  • Defense (Points): 7th
  • Defense (Yards): 19th
  • Result: Lost Wild Card Round to the San Francisco 49ers.

2022 Season
  • Offense (Points): 4th
  • Offense (Yards): 11th
  • Defense (Points): 5th
  • Defense (Yards): 12th
  • Result: Won Wild Card Round against the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, lost Divisional Round to the San Francisco 49ers.

2023 Season
  • Offense (Points): 1st
  • Offense (Yards): 5th
  • Defense (Points): 5th
  • Defense (Yards): 5th
  • Result: Lost Wild Card Round to the Green Bay Packers.

NOTHING about this "proves your point". Swwwinnng and a miss
 
OGSixshooter said:
??? Mahomes took middling defenses to the SB.

Now, here's what Dak had:

2016 Season
  • Offense (Points): 5th
  • Offense (Yards): 5th
  • Defense (Points): 5th
  • Defense (Yards): 14th
  • Result: Lost Divisional Round to the Green Bay Packers.

2018 Season
  • Offense (Points): 22nd
  • Offense (Yards): 22nd
  • Defense (Points): 6th
  • Defense (Yards): 7th
  • Result: Won Wild Card Round against the Seattle Seahawks, lost Divisional Round to the Los Angeles Rams.

2021 Season
  • Offense (Points): 1st
  • Offense (Yards): 1st
  • Defense (Points): 7th
  • Defense (Yards): 19th
  • Result: Lost Wild Card Round to the San Francisco 49ers.

2022 Season
  • Offense (Points): 4th
  • Offense (Yards): 11th
  • Defense (Points): 5th
  • Defense (Yards): 12th
  • Result: Won Wild Card Round against the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, lost Divisional Round to the San Francisco 49ers.

2023 Season
  • Offense (Points): 1st
  • Offense (Yards): 5th
  • Defense (Points): 5th
  • Defense (Yards): 5th
  • Result: Lost Wild Card Round to the Green Bay Packers.

NOTHING about this "proves your point". Swwwinnng and a miss
Click to expand...
I don’t think so. I said complete teams. You’re looking at one aspect and not the whole picture. Were the coaches any good? What about the playcalling both on offense and defense, etc, etc especially when the games were important. Quinn’s Ds fell apart against any decent team and feasted on the crappy ones. Strike three, you’re out! Lol
 
ChronicCowboy said:
Once the news came out that he has a knee issue I considered the same thing. OT is an obvious weakness on this team and Dak is going to get hit quite a bit this season. If he misses significant time due to injury, finding his replacement is going to become the primary goal for next offseason.
Click to expand...
Pathetically, I believe that think they already have him.
 
Risen Star said:
Click to expand...

I knew he missed games every other year but I didn't know the trend was that similar every other year.

Knowing that and especially with an older vet at QB the backup QB is so crucial.

Imagine we're 9-4 and Dak gets injured and has to miss 5 games. We're cooked. It'll just be another season where we had a lot of the pieces but just couldn't get it done. I certainly don't see Joe Milton getting it done.
 
DarkVader33 said:
I don’t think so. I said complete teams. You’re looking at one aspect and not the whole picture. Were the coaches any good? What about the playcalling both on offense and defense, etc, etc especially when the games were important. Quinn’s Ds fell apart against any decent team and feasted on the crappy ones. Strike three, you’re out! Lol
Click to expand...
You said complete teams as if you made your point clear. You haven't. What constitutes a "complete team"? To me, if you have a top 10 offense/defense - relative to the league - and you made the playoffs, your team is complete ENOUGH. If you have at least one top unit, that's the best you can do.

Do you think being the highest paid ever and continuously jerking Jerry back to the negotiating table is going to help "complete" the team?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Staff online

Members online

Total: 13,250 (members: 99, guests: 13,151)
Robots: 1,875

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
474,565
Messages
14,545,815
Members
24,212
Latest member
JerryJonesSupporter
Back
Top