Arm strength, #10 - His backup QB has a stronger arm.
Ball placement, #10: Depends on the opponent and month of the year.
Mechanics, #5 - see ball placement. Too inconsistent to be #5.
Pocket presence, #5 - Too high, but he does have good pocket presence for the most part
Decision making, #6 - Again, not when we need it most...I'd drop him down to #8
...and because I gotta be that guy...
Pay/Extortion #1 - Overpaid, heavily supported culture guy fresh off a breakup who is trying to psyche himself into a winning year by frontloading expectations.