Start, Bench, Cut

[Whirlwin]

They all had their own skill set
How did Troy do without an offensive line?
I’m going with Tony, Prescott, Troy

 

[Whirlwin]

I really feel some of these guys were too young to remember that era of football, and how good Troy was.

He had all day to throw the football, do you remember that, the best offensive line in the entire NFL for how many years?

 

[Whirlwin]

I really feel some of these guys were too young to remember that era of football, and how good Troy was.

I grew up with Bart star, Roger Staubach

 

[Whirlwin]

He knew this is going to lead nothing but arguments& debates and here we go again..

this is easy

start Romo with troys peak teams Bench dak cut troy

Dak with Troys peak team etc etc...

You might find out in the long run that Sam Darnold with a very similar team won a Super Bowl about Nick Foles I can talk about quarterbacks like Trent Dilfer and Brad Johnson and shall we go on you want to go look their team very similar choice teams That means Troy wasn't needed at all I mean troy was just a bus driver Yep I said..

Romo and Dak are better...come at me..

rosters, teams and coaches matter...

People forget, Troy had all day to throw the football, only the best offensive line in football how many years

 

[CWR]

I think maybe the idea comes from the fact that Tony ran to be able to throw he didn't really want to go past the line of scrimmage much.
Where Dak would run to get the first downs and run for touchdowns on occasion.

Tony was elusive in the pocket until he wasn't and then he became very vulnerable and a liability.
Every time he got tackled my heart was in my mouth hoping he would get up from it.

Dak is a much sturdier player and better condition to take the punishment of being tackled in the NFL.

Yes Dak has a suit of armor. Tony had more of a suit of a dude who plays golf during the week.

 

[Whirlwin]

If Tony played in Troy's teams he ins three Super Bowls, maybe four.

If Troy played on Tony's teams, he would have been killed. His career would have been very short.

Troy failed under a poor offensive line
People forget he had all day to throw the football

 

[DarkVader33]

He knew this is going to lead nothing but arguments& debates and here we go again..

this is easy

start Romo with troys peak teams Bench dak cut troy

Dak with Troys peak team etc etc...

You might find out in the long run that Sam Darnold with a very similar team won a Super Bowl about Nick Foles I can talk about quarterbacks like Trent Dilfer and Brad Johnson and shall we go on you want to go look their team very similar choice teams That means Troy wasn't needed at all I mean troy was just a bus driver Yep I said..

Romo and Dak are better...come at me..

rosters, teams and coaches matter...

Blue, I wish you had written one of your novels so I didn’t have to read your post. Lol

You’ve lost it if you think Dak or Tony are better than Troy. I hope you were being sarcastic cause otherwise I’d think you’re on something. And not water. lol

 

[blueblood70]

People forget, Troy had all day to throw the football, only the best offensive line in football how many years

This being real I'm just being real I'm not trying to take anything away from Troy but a lot of quarterbacks that are just good to above average we've seen it with a team like that called the Super Team Just don't mess it up Yes you still need a good quarterback but you don't need Hall of Fame quarterback.

Troy was a really good quarterback but he never had carried the team so how do we know he could have imagine if social media was alive and ticking in full peak what Troy would have been called a bus driver for all those 200 yard games or less he scored one touchdown sometimes Maybe 2 in the game..

He had a lot of seasons 20 to 25 Tds around 15 to 18 ints and now it is he will be torn apart all the bus driver and call just above average quarterback really good quarterback but a beat Hall of Fame quarterback, i'm just being real about how social media beats as you put up numbers like that..


Jalen Hurts is getting that right now.. Probably doesn't deserve to criticism but hey if Dak is open season so everyone else.. I'm not saying Troy could have been the type to be coined elite, I never saw I saw really good quarterback they had a really really great team..

Being sarcastic here in a little facetious I don't like people doing these kind of things because they think we're all gonna take Troy and at the fight over Prescott and Tony.. That's what they're doing this is another Romo versus Dak thread. i thought that I throw in the direction.

 

[DarkVader33]

He had all day to throw the football, do you remember that, the best offensive line in the entire NFL for how many years?

And when Tony and Dak have plenty of time to throw, they can’t hold a candle to his processing and accuracy.

Also, have you forgotten the pounding Troy took early on? Neither of the other two would have survived.

 

[blueblood70]

Blue, I wish you had written one of your novels so I didn’t have to read your post. Lol

You’ve lost it if you think Dak or Tony are better than Troy. I hope you were being sarcastic cause otherwise I’d think you’re on something. And not water. lol

It's both Get both a little facetious & sarcasm,

but at the same time we never saw Troy carry the TEAM,


one of the best ever assembled, He never had to do more than he need to do Emmitt Smith was the heart of this team, offensive line was the heart of the team, The Defense, coaching staff, just like Roger.. Roger had defenses that were called doomsday defenses he had coaches that were considered some of the most creative ahead of their time He had some of the best special teams some of the best rockers offline and run backs ever assembled and you're trying to tell me they ever carry the team by themselves..

In the world do you think even I like Danny White was able to three straight or wherever it was Championship Games he would reason they didn't get to the Super Bowl and people are like oh no but he played in three NFC championship Prescott have you took look at those teams.. Danny White was the reason they didn't go further, That is why he is so far down on my list as the most overrated quarterback we've had He was nothing more than lucky he played those games because of the team now we could keep in mind how great these teams were if you don't so look at Hall of Fame The point was only in Hall of Farmers Are you trying to tell me we need to debate chicken before the egg was it the quarterback or was it everything else I'll stick with everything else but the order backs really good as well..

But it's why maybe Marino never won one..


I am telling you whatever you think you saw you will never be able to prove because Troy was never asked to harry the team ever it always went through that were being chess when everybody else was playing chairs..

I'm just saying this because Sam Darnold this year had a team just like that he last just messed it up and he didn't go look at his number in the playoffs and in the Super Bowl did have a turnover I mean now we didn't throw many interceptions if that's 0 show me Troys.

You all are getting blinded by the shine of those Lombards are your real glasses and realized I bet if you inserted Tony or Dak on those teams and ain't no other changes everything went exactly the same they still won those trophies I guarantee it..

 

[blueblood70]

And when Tony and Dak have plenty of time to throw, they can’t hold a candle to his processing and accuracy.

Also, have you forgotten the pounding Troy took early on? Neither of the other two would have survived.

I knew you guys were gonna clap me I don't care I said what I said I elaborated now leave it here that is the original poster wanted and now we got it..

Putting my foot in it and it's all the way down to the floor...

Let me elaborate further, I remember the Buffalo Super Bowls whether his hat was terrible for the office trade couldn't hit any receivers turned all over once they were done by 10 and in the second half our defense got ball back and even scored and we ran the ball and kept running the ball and Oh my God we won the game It was like Cooper rush just put the foreground oh I mean Troy..lol

If you don't remember the Super Bowl Troy playing so bad in the first half, how can you play that without a game that cooking stuff and that defense along with special teams.

I'm trying to wake up your memory Remember all the games that were 150 to 200 yards make a touchdown maybe interception yes that was Troy and it was a different era, was it..LOL If he played like that now he would be roasted because our other guy are being roasted for the same thing Oh that's not yards you didn't do nothing the game you were carried like Bus driver..yups

 

[blueblood70]

Blue, I wish you had written one of your novels so I didn’t have to read your post. Lol

You’ve lost it if you think Dak or Tony are better than Troy. I hope you were being sarcastic cause otherwise I’d think you’re on something. And not water. lol

Now I'm gonna write about 7 that will turn to a novel,

but show me the games the playoffs these big game that you say Tony and Prescott can't play because they can carry the team when everything else around them was garbage; that they were supposed to pick the team up that would have quarterbacks supposed to do and I don't remember a single game where Roger Or troy had to do by themselves, you know where their o-line had 11 penaltys . cant block, the run game was non existent, defense was below average, or terrible, noones getting open!!?

show me the games when they were winning just like that ,and you say yeah Troy& Roger was put them on their back, right they didn't..

Look I know I'm older but I pretty good memory, I was my mid to late 20s for most troys are and I watch a lot of games from Rogers I'm remembering names where they were asked to do any of that so how can you help me they could have how can you tell me they're really better?

 

[DarkVader33]

It's both Get both a little facetious & sarcasm,

but at the same time we never saw Troy carry the TEAM,


one of the best ever assembled, He never had to do more than he need to do Emmitt Smith was the heart of this team, offensive line was the heart of the team, The Defense, coaching staff, just like Roger.. Roger had defenses that were called doomsday defenses he had coaches that were considered some of the most creative ahead of their time He had some of the best special teams some of the best rockers offline and run backs ever assembled and you're trying to tell me they ever carry the team by themselves..

In the world do you think even I like Danny White was able to three straight or wherever it was Championship Games he would reason they didn't get to the Super Bowl and people are like oh no but he played in three NFC championship Prescott have you took look at those teams.. Danny White was the reason they didn't go further, That is why he is so far down on my list as the most overrated quarterback we've had He was nothing more than lucky he played those games because of the team now we could keep in mind how great these teams were if you don't so look at Hall of Fame The point was only in Hall of Farmers Are you trying to tell me we need to debate chicken before the egg was it the quarterback or was it everything else I'll stick with everything else but the order backs really good as well..

But it's why maybe Marino never won one..


I am telling you whatever you think you saw you will never be able to prove because Troy was never asked to harry the team ever it always went through that were being chess when everybody else was playing chairs..

I'm just saying this because Sam Darnold this year had a team just like that he last just messed it up and he didn't go look at his number in the playoffs and in the Super Bowl did have a turnover I mean now we didn't throw many interceptions if that's 0 show me Troys.

You all are getting blinded by the shine of those Lombards are your real glasses and realized I bet if you inserted Tony or Dak on those teams and ain't no other changes everything went exactly the same they still won those trophies I guarantee it..

Sorry but I don’t go by the Lombardi. My eyes tell me that Troy was better. Period . He did carry the team at times but didn’t have to very often.

 

[pitt33]

If Tony had had Troy’s surrounding talent he’d have 3-4 rings too.

lol.

Cmon man.

Romo choked.

So does Prescott.

Aikman had ice in veins and a rock solid constitution.

 

[Blackrain]

lol.

Cmon man.

Romo choked.

So does Prescott.

Aikman had ice in veins and a rock solid constitution.

It's really pretty simple aikman ran that gauntlet not once not twice three times one all those playoff games and Super bowls.

A man is what he does Troy aikman is a winner because that's what he did.

Unfortunately Tony Romo and Dak Prescott are losers because they lose playoff games they don't make a run they don't even get close no matter what talent is on the team.
They don't rise above they don't elevate their teams they don't set themselves apart. that's what they've done up to now.

 

[Rockport]

Troy, Tony, Dak.

Assume all in their prime and playing in today's NFL...and you can only carry 2 QB's...

I have them in that order...what you got?

I’ll have to go with Dak. Troy’s too old and Tony’s in rehab.

 

[nate dizzle]

I’ll have to go with Dak. Troy’s too old and Tony’s in rehab.

Should maybe read the OP again.

 

[pitt33]

It's really pretty simple aikman ran that gauntlet not once not twice three times one all those playoff games and Super bowls.

A man is what he does Troy aikman is a winner because that's what he did.

Unfortunately Tony Romo and Dak Prescott are losers because they lose playoff games they don't make a run they don't even get close no matter what talent is on the team.
They don't rise above they don't elevate their teams they don't set themselves apart. that's what they've done up to now.

Tony was a good FA quarterback. But there was a reason he wasn’t drafted. The same can be said for Prescott. He was drafted where he was supposed to go. Guys like that will only take a team so far. People will argue but they didn’t have this.. they didn’t have that. The bottom line is they lack championship pedigree.

Until they get true pedigree at that position I’m afraid this franchise is going to be stuck in a perpetual cycle of not good enough to win a big one.

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

]

It's really pretty simple aikman ran that gauntlet not once not twice three times one all those playoff games and Super bowls.

A man is what he does Troy aikman is a winner because that's what he did.

Unfortunately Tony Romo and Dak Prescott are losers because they lose playoff games they don't make a run they don't even get close no matter what talent is on the team.
They don't rise above they don't elevate their teams they don't set themselves apart. that's what they've done up to now.

If Romo and Dak played in the non salary cap
Era they probably have more success. To put things in perspective this era of the Cowboys had Mazi Smith and Trysten Hill as defensive tackles. Troy had Russell Maryland and Leon Lett….its levels.

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

Come on now. I’m not a Romo defender or revisionist, and you know it. And the giants being just as good, if not better, than the cowboys has nothing to do with Romo. They won two super bowls in that time and the cowboys didn’t. Not much else you can say.

Cowboys was 13-3….Giants 10-6…..