Coaching Matters

[GimmeTheBall!]

A good coach based on what?

The nebulous "good coach" passed down from urban legend.

 

[GimmeTheBall!]

Is he a good coach because he came from a team with a good DC? What convinced you that he will be good?

I have never gotten the hype about Parker. He's never been a DC, so from where did this urban legend come?

 

[CowboyoWales]

Unprepared, out physicaled and out coached. Giants were well coached and prepared Their players came ready to play.

Agree, uncooked and we still play Plan A. Schotty must have learnt that Dak is not a comeback QB, especially when we struggle to stop the run.
The 4th and 1 was the worst Strategic play....we have to be more adventurous (and aggressive) early on, to offset our inability (still) to stop the run and putting Dak in an uncomfortable situation.

 

[Johannes44]

Is he a good coach because he came from a team with a good DC? What convinced you that he will be good?

That would be the Cowboys PR team.

 

[Deionindahood]

I have never gotten the hype about Parker. He's never been a DC, so from where did this urban legend come?

It's a Jerry thing.

 

[Acceptablename]

I've made this post multiple times I think over the past 10-15 years.

You saw it tonight. The giants finally got a coach and it mattered. We keep hiring retreads nobody wants. No toughness, no discipline, mistake after mistake. Just hype The Dallas cowboys are once again a massively overrated team. 30 years of this BS all because the stubborn owner has to win with his hand picked guy.

You call this coaching staff retreads

 

[Parcells4Life]

I’m hoping Jerry sees this and thinks about it on the flight home. A less talented team (on paper) with a proven HC beat a more talented team (on paper) with a hopeful project of a coach. I hope this resonates with Jerry and FO.

I think for me this loss sucks because it was Garrett 2.0. The punt on 4th and inches is such a Garrett move. I was having flashbacks. Schotty was starting to win me over but this loss sent him back a few notches. We came out flatter than a preseason game and seemed uninterested. We came out with more intensity for the preseason game against the Cardinals.

Coaching definitely matters and we can talk about Dak, Micah, Romo and all the other things we have tonight in all the other threads but the reality is when Jimmy walked out that door we are 2 Neil O’Donnell interceptions away from never winning a Super Bowl since ‘93.

Less talented at the QB, WR CB and DT positions aka most of the GLAMOR positions.

DE - Giants are better
LB - Giants are better
S - Talent wise a toss up but Giants were better tonight
OL - Giants are better with Tyler Smith out.
RB - Giants are better
TE - Giants are better

Cowboys media focuses on the flashy. Giants have a team that has a strategy for how they want to move the ball and stop you. The Cowboys want to just throw it to the two big WRs and think that’ll be enough. Giants operate efficiently.

 

[Acceptablename]

It's not the middle trenches personal. They were out physicaled. That surprised me.

 

[atlantacowboy]

It's pretty clear CP needs some time to get the defense ready.

He's a good coach. The defense just won't be what we expected as quickly as we all hoped.

He is a good coach. Whether or not he's going to be a good DC remains to be seen. He had a really embarrassing game. There were no in-game defensive adjustments and his unit couldn't make a stop. The Giants were 10 of 11 on 3rd down. Either he doesn't know how to make adjustments in-game or just doesn't know what adjustments to make. Either way, it's concerning.

 

[Acceptablename]

Less talented at the QB, WR CB and DT positions aka most of the GLAMOR positions.

DE - Giants are better
LB - Giants are better
S - Talent wise a toss up but Giants were better tonight
OL - Giants are better with Tyler Smith out.
RB - Giants are better
TE - Giants are better

Cowboys media focuses on the flashy. Giants have a team that has a strategy for how they want to move the ball and stop you. The Cowboys want to just throw it to the two big WRs and think that’ll be enough. Giants operate efficiently.

DT isn't flashy.