Dak Top 5. Let's talk argument against it

[Relayer]

Nice debate.... Got your brain cooking today I see

A picture's worth a thousand words. How about stat wise, you like stats right, Dak was outplayed today by his opponent's counterpart. And I know Dak fans only share the blame and not credit, but what about Ceedee? There were more QBs that can do what Dak did today than there are receivers who can do what Ceedee did.

On a side note, I never noticed your Avatar before today. I didn't know you were a female fan. If I've ever been rude, i'm sorry. Although you don't appear to be overly sensitive.

 

[cowboys5xsbs]

Helmet to Helmet on KC

 

[shabazz]

And when did Dak do those things

He did it in Madden 23, tough guy.

 

[Redsfan_83]

you post it and stop being weird and lame lol. jesus christ.

another clown comment in here...lots of them today I see

 

[Relayer]

There's not a list this week that had him lower than 7. He's gonna move up this week, even...probably up to everyone's Top 5. He had 350 yards and a clutch last minute touchdown pass.

We're in season 11, one game doesn't move an overall ranking one way or the other. This reminds me of Nick Wright, and he's not even a football fan.

 

[Yobwocs]

A picture's worth a thousand words. How about stat wise, you like stats right, Dak was outplayed today by his opponent's counterpart. And I know Dak fans only share the blame and not credit, but what about Ceedee? There were more QBs that can do what Dak did today than there are receivers who can do what Ceedee did.

On a side note, I never noticed your Avatar before today. I didn't know you were a female fan. If I've ever been rude, i'm sorry. Although you don't appear to be overly sensitive.

Im far from being overly sensitive.

And it doesn't matter if there are more QBs who can do what Dak did than receivers that can do what CD did. Dak and CD are not in competition with each other. Even if Lamb is a rarer commodity, it doesn't say anything about Dak as a Quarterback.

Dont think there are more than 5 or 6 QBs who is looking as strong as Dak in all 4 games this year. Everyone else has had a game where they were at the mercy of the defense. Dak has not yet been under the mercy of the defense, and not since the Broncos game last year.

 

[DFWJC]

Mahomes is praised for the win when he doesn't play

 

[Relayer]

Y'all can never just enjoy a great win.

Who's not enjoying it?

 

[irishline]

Look it up, Genius. Dak leads Jalen in many.

Here, I will help your lazy butt...

Dak Prescott has 26 career game-winning drives compared to 15 for Jalen Hurts.

Dak Prescott leads Jalen Hurts 19 to 11 in career fourth-quarter comebacks, while they are locked in a 2–2 tie in direct head-to-head starting matchups.

Dak has also played in 50+ more games than Hurts as a starting QB. I believe Dak is the better QB, but come on, man. You want to talk about lazy? This is the epitome of it.

 

[America's Cowboy]

Dak has also played in 50 more games than Hurts. I believe Dak is the better QB, but come on, man. This is weak.

Weak is watching them play, knowing easily Dak is the better passer and QB, yet not having the knads to admit it just because you don't personally like him.

 

[Yobwocs]

We're in season 11, one game doesn't move an overall ranking one way or the other. This reminds me of Nick Wright, and he's not even a football fan.

One game doesn't move much, but Dak was in the Top 7 at the beginning of the year, and he hasn't done anything to lose his spot. Gain ground rather than lose any.

 

[Aerolithe_Lion]

Look it up, Genius. Dak leads Jalen in many.

Here, I will help your lazy butt...

Dak Prescott has 26 career game-winning drives compared to 15 for Jalen Hurts.

Dak Prescott leads Jalen Hurts 19 to 11 in career fourth-quarter comebacks, while they are locked in a 2–2 tie in direct head-to-head starting matchups.

Dak has also played twice as long as Jalen, so that checks out. He also has way more than Fernando Mendoza. Imagine that! A #1 overall pick

At its core, it seems to be that Youre trying to say he’s better than another non top 5 QB, I’m trying to understand why that means Dak is top 5. Unless you’re arguing this is why Dak isn’t top 5?

 

[TrailBlazer]

This is the list:

Allen
Mahomes
Lamar

Burrow
stafford

Caleb Williams
Dak
lawrence
Purdy
Goff

Maye
Daniels
Herbert
Mayfield
Darnold

Dart
Stroud
Love
Nix
Young

Rodgers
Watson
Daniel Jones
Cousins
Geno Smith

shough
Young
Penix
Willis
Brissett

Murray
Ward

 

[GINeric]

Nothing says elite more than beating an 0-3 team with a 16th ranked defense

Someone said the same thing about us beating Washington. They said that Washington was a "bottom feeder". But Washington beat the reigning Superbowl champions last week with a backup quarterback.

So what should I take from that, a bottom feeder is better than a Superbowl team?

 

[Yobwocs]

This is the list:

Allen
Mahomes
Lamar

Burrow
stafford

Caleb Williams
Dak
lawrence
Purdy

Maye
Daniels
Herbert
Mayfield
Darnold

Stroud
Love
Nix
Young
Rodgers

Daniel Jones
Cousins
Geno Smith
shough
Young
Penix
Willis
Brissett
Murray

Not a bad list, but Caleb..... where is this guy? waaait... he's nowhere to be found.

So Dak > the guy who's MIA

 

[TrailBlazer]

Not a bad list, but Caleb..... where is this guy? waaait... he's nowhere to be found.

So Dak > the guy who's MIA

I’m projecting a little bit. He benefits from a really good coach as well

 

[Relayer]

Look it up, Genius. Dak leads Jalen in many.

Here, I will help your lazy butt...

Dak Prescott has 26 career game-winning drives compared to 15 for Jalen Hurts.

Dak Prescott leads Jalen Hurts 19 to 11 in career fourth-quarter comebacks, while they are locked in a 2–2 tie in direct head-to-head starting matchups.

Dak's been playing 4 years longer.

 

[shabazz]

Someone said the same thing about us beating Washington. They said that Washington was a "bottom feeder". But Washington beat the reigning Superbowl champions last week with a backup quarterback.

So what should I take from that, a bottom feeder is better than a Superbowl team?

Nothing new just happened.

This 2nd half against the Texans shouldn't bring on a manufactured epiphany

Hes still the same quarterback but if you get delirious about a Qb that was shutout the entire 1st half of a game by the 16th ranked defense, have at it, hoss.

 

[Relayer]

Im far from being overly sensitive.

And it doesn't matter if there are more QBs who can do what Dak did than receivers that can do what CD did. Dak and CD are not in competition with each other. Even if Lamb is a rarer commodity, it doesn't say anything about Dak as a Quarterback.

Dont think there are more than 5 or 6 QBs who is looking as strong as Dak in all 4 games this year. Everyone else has had a game where they were at the mercy of the defense. Dak has not yet been under the mercy of the defense, and not since the Broncos game last year.

Again, not giving credit. Without Ceedee today we lose. Dak played well but wasn't special. But elevate Dak because of today's game? And when we're ranking it does matter how many people you are better than.

 

[America's Cowboy]

Dak's been playing 4 years longer.

And? Doesn't change the fact Dak is by far a better passer and overall QB.