Gints on top of NFC east , who would have thunk?

[harris33]

Well, thanks to us faltering and Philadelphia a mash unit, Washington not being able to keep the quarterback on the field no other choice but Giants.

I said yesterday don't pick the Eagles to win. Rams are a strong team. Rams probably should've lost if not for a incompetent coach like ours last week. They were able to eke out a win against Philadelphia with this roster.

Sunday without DeVonta Smith (hamstring), Dallas Goedert (knee), Zack Baun (concussion), Marcus Epps (groin), Landon Dickerson (knee), Lane Johnson (personal reasons), Fred Johnson (knee) and Hollywood Brown (ankle), then lost Barkley, Quinyon Mitchell (knee) and Jonathan Greenard (ankle)

Giants problem is their QB isn't coming back. As Winston going to be there QB and can he win? I doubt it. If we can show we were a playoff team, we should win without much of a challenge from our injured foes.

Well I forgot about Hollywood, Fred and Greenard. Frankly I would rather see the younger WRs play over Hollywood Brown.

 

[Established1971]

Cant get to understand this ? Can this continue ?

two words

Jameiston
Winston

dude will win a few and lose more, every time
Giants will be 7-10 maybe 8-9

 

[JW82]

Shut up!

Prove me wrong Shoddy.

 

[Relayer]

I picked the Giants to win the division this year. Not now with losing their QB but I am still not surprised they are leading this bad division.

You look at the coaching in the east and we're definitely at a disadvantage.

 

[Relayer]

Prove me wrong Shoddy.

It's not about being right, it's your attitude!

 

[Relayer]

Based on the Giants opening weekend of play and the moves they made off season, I knew that the Giants would be much improved under Harbaugh. He’s a legit coach.

There's also much regression in the division.

 

[Relayer]

More proof coaching matters.

Another reason they have a win/loss record.

 

[Shotgun Dave]

I think I said at the time Harbaugh was hired on this forum that the Giants should not be underestimated or something like that. They have a strong core group of players and he’s a hell of a coach.

Isn’t there some simple way to search one’s posts?

 

[Wichitaleafs]

They got a good coach

 

[Relayer]

What does the calendar say today is?

/thread

I know. I'm still worried about Washington being better than us.

 

[JW82]

It's not about being right, it's your attitude!

Oh..Go chase yourself.

 

[Relayer]

Could’ve gotten Harbaugh to Dallas….
He’s going to be a problem for a long time

Could we have? I'm not so sure he would have accepted the job.

 

[Relayer]

Stink? Not even a little love or respect here?

You do realize you are telling me that a stinky team beat your boys. Based on your words then, wouldn’t that mean that your boys must stink more….at this point. Right?

But just to summarize….we have beaten Dallas, 2-2, Tenn, 0-4, and Cards, 1-3

You have beaten Washington, 1-3 and Houston, 0-4.

Looks to me like we are pretty much traveling down similar paths. I don’t think your boys stink.

But, I will make this agreement with you if you agree….i won’t say your team stinks if you don’t say my team stinks. And, By the way, you might be right…we might end up around .500, but don’t forget, we have lost two of our best players this year- Dart and Burns. Not easy to fill those huge voids.

Deal?
K

After we played I feared that the Giants weren't any better than projected. We were simply worse.

 

[Relayer]

Then there shouldn't be any surprise that they're in the lead.

If that was the determining reason, sure. But explain the Rams and Niners then?

 

[kskboys]

two words

Jameiston
Winston

dude will win a few and lose more, every time
Giants will be 7-10 maybe 8-9

McCarthy's not taking over as starter?

 

[Relayer]

I watched the Eagles/Rams game. The Eagles are horrible. The Rams were horrible for 54 minutes but still pulled it out.
You're right about Hurts. I know he's gone to 2 SB and won 1, but he is bad. He just seems reluctant to throw the ball and in this league you gotta let it fly fast. He has good receivers even today with Smith out. He's just bad.
Their OC is also horrible, just bad play calling.
And Siriani may be the worst of all.
They were up 10 with 6 minutes to play.
3rd and goal from the 2.
They got nothing on 3rd down and he goes for it on 4th down. He called 2 TOs on the drive so didn't have them at the end of the game when he needed them. Just horrible decision making.
I'm all for going for it on 4th down but sometimes you gotta be smart. These coaches like Quinn and Campbell and Siriani always go for it. Sometimes just take the points.
That stop sparked the Rams and gave them hope. They scored 2 TDs in the final 5 minutes and won the game.
Had Siriani kicked the FG, he'd be up 13 with 6 minutes left.
So even if the Rams did score twice (and they did), you'd be 1 point behind and a FG would win the game for you.
Instead he was down 4 with no time outs.
Just a clown show.
We can win this division, bad as we have been,

Tell us what you really think of Siriani, and don't hold back. (Music to my ears).

 

[Relayer]

Oh..Go chase yourself.

Lighten up Clarence.

 

[coult44]

Cant get to understand this ? Can this continue ?

It’s week 4, who cares? It’s like the pre season poll in college football, it doesn’t matter this early. No, they won’t continue it.

 

[Relayer]

If your QB succeeds by running then they'll be hurt. Dart is hurt, Daniels is hurt, and now Jackson is hurt. Yeah they hurt Dallas with QB runs but skrew 'em all. Eventually you'll pay the piper.

Most QB injuries happen getting blown up in the pocket because they can't read defenses or play hero ball.

 

[Bagman]

Stink? Not even a little love or respect here?

You do realize you are telling me that a stinky team beat your boys. Based on your words then, wouldn’t that mean that your boys must stink more….at this point. Right?

But just to summarize….we have beaten Dallas, 2-2, Tenn, 0-4, and Cards, 1-3

You have beaten Washington, 1-3 and Houston, 0-4.

Looks to me like we are pretty much traveling down similar paths. I don’t think your boys stink.

But, I will make this agreement with you if you agree….i won’t say your team stinks if you don’t say my team stinks. And, By the way, you might be right…we might end up around .500, but don’t forget, we have lost two of our best players this year- Dart and Burns. Not easy to fill those huge voids.

Deal?
K

Deal. I was arguing with my brother, a royal P.I.T.A., a Giant fan, and I took it out on the G-Men. Lol. I just think the entire division will struggle and even the winner won't be much of a threat come playoff time. Much respect to you, sir.