Rank your Top 5 QB's

CATCH17

CATCH17

1st Round Pick
Messages
69,515
Reaction score
91,046
I know we aren't in the QB market but i'd like to know who your top 5 is.


For me..

1. Josh Allen

I know the completion percentage puts the odds of him being a bust at a higher rate but I wouldn't care. I'm taking Josh Allen.

2. Josh Rosen

I do not like this guy but he doesn't have a lot of holes in his game. I think he's a better Jared Goff.

3. Sam Darnold

He is a solid talent but I don't see him as the #1 guy like so many do. He left school way too early as well. Kinda really crushes PArcells golden rule about wanting a Senior QB.

4. Mason Rudolph

It won't be a popular opinion but Lamar, and Baker both played in spread offenses and out of the 3 spread offensive QB's I think Rudolphs games transitions best to the Pro's.

5. Lamar Jackson

I would take him over Baker. I just don't think Baker is a success in the Pro's and if he is then he'll be Jeff Garcia at best which isn't a bad thing.

Lamar Jackson could be the next Michael Vick type. I think he'll be productive when he's on the field but his frame will keep him sidelined a lot.

He's got a big arm and if you give him a stout run game he could really be good if he stays healthy.. I think Lamar Jackson has Pittsburgh Steeler written all over him but word is the Patriots really like him.
 
Rosen
Darnold
Mayfield
Jackson
Rudolph


Name for me a QB in the last 20 or so years when passing in the NFL became even more vital to a team's success that had a completion percentage of 56% that went on to be a stud QB?

Allen has bust written all over him. Big time bust.
 
Sydla said:
Rosen
Darnold
Mayfield
Jackson
Rudolph


Name for me a QB in the last 20 or so years when passing in the NFL became even more vital to a team's success that had a completion percentage of 56% that went on to be a stud QB?

Allen has bust written all over him. Big time bust.
Click to expand...
I agree, I left him off my list also
 
Sydla said:
Rosen
Darnold
Mayfield
Jackson
Rudolph


Name for me a QB in the last 20 or so years when passing in the NFL became even more vital to a team's success that had a completion percentage of 56% that went on to be a stud QB?

Allen has bust written all over him. Big time bust.
Click to expand...

And you have Jackson with 57% as your number 4 QB?
 
CATCH17 said:
I know we aren't in the QB market but i'd like to know who your top 5 is.


For me..

1. Josh Allen

I know the completion percentage puts the odds of him being a bust at a higher rate but I wouldn't care. I'm taking Josh Allen.

2. Josh Rosen

I do not like this guy but he doesn't have a lot of holes in his game. I think he's a better Jared Goff.

3. Sam Darnold

He is a solid talent but I don't see him as the #1 guy like so many do. He left school way too early as well. Kinda really crushes PArcells golden rule about wanting a Senior QB.

4. Mason Rudolph

It won't be a popular opinion but Lamar, and Baker both played in spread offenses and out of the 3 spread offensive QB's I think Rudolphs games transitions best to the Pro's.

5. Lamar Jackson

I would take him over Baker. I just don't think Baker is a success in the Pro's and if he is then he'll be Jeff Garcia at best which isn't a bad thing.

Lamar Jackson could be the next Michael Vick type. I think he'll be productive when he's on the field but his frame will keep him sidelined a lot.

He's got a big arm and if you give him a stout run game he could really be good if he stays healthy.. I think Lamar Jackson has Pittsburgh Steeler written all over him but word is the Patriots really like him.
Click to expand...
Agreed except taking Mayfield at 4.
 
Cattle_Rancher said:
And you have Jackson with 57% as your number 4 QB?
Click to expand...

Jackson has a unique skill set Allen doesn't. So you might be able to Michael Vick an offense around him. You can't do that with Allen.

Frankly, I think there are really only 2 QBs in this draft - Rosen and Darnold - and I am not even a big fan of Darnold, who strikes me a kind of dumb on the field in that he makes some really bad throws.

So if you wanted me to do a real list of QBs, I would have stopped after Darnold.
 
Sydla said:
Jackson has a unique skill set Allen doesn't. So you might be able to Michael Vick an offense around him. You can't do that with Allen.

Frankly, I think there are really only 2 QBs in this draft - Rosen and Darnold - and I am not even a big fan of Darnold, who strikes me a kind of dumb on the field in that he makes some really bad throws.

So if you wanted me to do a real list of QBs, I would have stopped after Darnold.
Click to expand...

Jackson ain’t as fast and mobile as Vick was. Looking at Vick’s career I wouldn’t want to build an offense like that got coaches fired and never really won anything meaningful. I also think DCs are better prepared now days for a QB like that and will be able to get hits on him then he will be injured like RG3, Watson, and the Titans QB. To be a successful mobile QB you have to be built like Cam where you can take the hits. Jackson is small and would be better switching to WR.

Darnold and Rosen needed another year of college. I think if either one starts week one it could be a major disaster. Darnold has to lear to take care of the ball turnovers lose games.

I think Mayfield will surprise people I think he is the guy most ready to start day 1. He may not have the most long term success but I think he will short term.

Allen has the weapons but his accuracy is a big question maybe the right coach can fix it.

Rudolph will struggle with his WRs not being open by a mile and with faster DB the INTs will pile up.

I think Falk and Lauletta are a pair of dark horses that someone may find true value in.

People like this QB class and hype it up a lot I am not that wild about it I like the 2016 class a lot better. There are QBs from 16 we haven’t seen play or very little of that I like better than some of these guys.
 
I don't see the debate.

1. Mayfield
2. Rosen
3. Darnold
4. Jackson
5. Allen

Check back with me in five years.
 
Rosen
Darnold
Jackson
Mayfield(only for off the field stuff).
Rudolph.

I would not draft Allen In the first RD at all.
 
Sydla said:
Jackson has a unique skill set Allen doesn't. So you might be able to Michael Vick an offense around him. You can't do that with Allen.

Frankly, I think there are really only 2 QBs in this draft - Rosen and Darnold - and I am not even a big fan of Darnold, who strikes me a kind of dumb on the field in that he makes some really bad throws.

So if you wanted me to do a real list of QBs, I would have stopped after Darnold.
Click to expand...


Of course Allen is not on Lamar Jacksons level of being able to run but he can move and buy time.
 
1. Rosen
2. Mayfield
3. Jackson
4. Darnold
5. Lauletta

I'm not a fan of Josh Allen. He's got the bad completion percentage without the same level of talent to run it like Jackson. But this is all JMO.
 
Sort of like Montgomery Brewster.

None of the above

This QB class stinks
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Staff online

Members online

... and 57 more.
Total: 22,543 (members: 157, guests: 22,386)
Robots: 954

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
474,111
Messages
14,513,578
Members
24,208
Latest member
CowboysQC
Back
Top