Trade for OBJ?

J12B

J12B

Well-Known Member
Messages
7,872
Reaction score
23,556
The Giants are in a complete overhaul, just like the Raiders and any player (except Barkley) is not out of the question for a trade.

Would you trade Zack Martin and a 2019 2ndround draft pick for Odell Beckham Jr.?

Personally, I don’t want him in Dallas. I see it more of a benefit to the Cowboys to keep him on the Giants as they continue to crumble.

But, there is no denying OBJ is a specially talented receiver and if a trade is done with another team that has a good QB and at least an average oline, he could look even better. Which is crazy to think about. I would hate it if the Eagles somehow trade for him (maybe 2 first round draft picks) so that they could make another run for the Superbowl this year.

I’d say a trade to Dallas is 99% not happening since we traded for Cooper last week and since the NYG are a division rival. But, just for fun, would you trade for OBJ and what is something “realistic” Dallas would have to give up? Would you prefer never to see him playing in a Dallas uniform ever? Where would you not want to see him traded?

Edit: Trade now becomes a 2019 2nd rounder/OBJ for Zack Martin
 
Last edited:
no way is he traded within the division. If he is traded it would likely be to an AFC team that they would only play once every 4 years.
 
J12B said:
The Giants are in a complete overhaul, just like the Raiders and any player (except Barkley) is not out of the question for a trade.

Would you trade Zack Martin and a 2019 2ndround draft pick for Odell Beckham Jr.?

Personally, I don’t want him in Dallas. I see it more of a benefit to the Cowboys to keep him on the Giants as they continue to crumble.

But, there is no denying OBJ is a specially talented receiver and if a trade is done with another team that has a good QB and at least an average oline, he could look even better. Which is crazy to think about. I would hate it if the Eagles somehow trade for him (maybe 2 first round draft picks) so that they could make another run for the Superbowl this year.

I’d say a trade to Dallas is 99% not happening since we traded for Cooper last week and since the NYG are a division rival. But, just for fun, would you trade for OBJ and what is something “realistic” Dallas would have to give up? Would you prefer never to see him playing in a Dallas uniform ever? Where would you not want to see him traded?
Click to expand...
I think your CZ account is going to get revoked...
 
We already have issues with the OL and now you want to trade our best available OL for a receiver that wouldn't hello us win games....... Wow
 
J12B said:
The Giants are in a complete overhaul, just like the Raiders and any player (except Barkley) is not out of the question for a trade.

Would you trade Zack Martin and a 2019 2ndround draft pick for Odell Beckham Jr.?

Personally, I don’t want him in Dallas. I see it more of a benefit to the Cowboys to keep him on the Giants as they continue to crumble.

But, there is no denying OBJ is a specially talented receiver and if a trade is done with another team that has a good QB and at least an average oline, he could look even better. Which is crazy to think about. I would hate it if the Eagles somehow trade for him (maybe 2 first round draft picks) so that they could make another run for the Superbowl this year.

I’d say a trade to Dallas is 99% not happening since we traded for Cooper last week and since the NYG are a division rival. But, just for fun, would you trade for OBJ and what is something “realistic” Dallas would have to give up? Would you prefer never to see him playing in a Dallas uniform ever? Where would you not want to see him traded?
Click to expand...

There's no way Martin should be considered in any trade scenario ever.
 
J12B said:
The Giants are in a complete overhaul, just like the Raiders and any player (except Barkley) is not out of the question for a trade.

Would you trade Zack Martin and a 2019 2ndround draft pick for Odell Beckham Jr.?

Personally, I don’t want him in Dallas. I see it more of a benefit to the Cowboys to keep him on the Giants as they continue to crumble.

But, there is no denying OBJ is a specially talented receiver and if a trade is done with another team that has a good QB and at least an average oline, he could look even better. Which is crazy to think about. I would hate it if the Eagles somehow trade for him (maybe 2 first round draft picks) so that they could make another run for the Superbowl this year.

I’d say a trade to Dallas is 99% not happening since we traded for Cooper last week and since the NYG are a division rival. But, just for fun, would you trade for OBJ and what is something “realistic” Dallas would have to give up? Would you prefer never to see him playing in a Dallas uniform ever? Where would you not want to see him traded?

Edit: Trade now becomes a 2019 2nd rounder/OBJ for Zack Martin
Click to expand...

Not only would I not do the deal, neither would the Cowboys or Giants. Teams almost never trade within the division because they don't want to run the risk of helping a division opponent. Besides, with Cooper, Beasley and Gallup the Cowboys are already on track to have a strong receiver group, but the O-Line has struggled more this year than in the past.
 
foofighters said:
I think your CZ account is going to get revoked...
Click to expand...

I specifically said I wouldnt do it and was attempting to start a realistic trade based on what both teams are in need of. Giants desperately need oline help and Dallas needs
Irvin88_4life said:
We already have issues with the OL and now you want to trade our best available OL for a receiver that wouldn't hello us win games....... Wow
Click to expand...

I clearly said I wouldn't do it. I was attempting to create a "realistic" trade scenario based on the two teams needs for the sake of discussion.
 
J12B said:
I specifically said I wouldnt do it and was attempting to start a realistic trade based on what both teams are in need of. Giants desperately need oline help and Dallas needs


I clearly said I wouldn't do it. I was attempting to create a "realistic" trade scenario based on the two teams needs for the sake of discussion.
Click to expand...
It's not realistic though
 
Wow. That would be a horrible trade for the Boys. And would never happen.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Members online

... and 101 more.
Total: 1,406 (members: 201, guests: 1,205)

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
465,450
Messages
13,875,472
Members
23,791
Latest member
mashburn
Back
Top