Yahoo Troy Aikman Article

Miller

ARTIST FORMERLY KNOWN AS TEXASFROG
Messages
11,874
Reaction score
13,460
https://www.yahoo.com/sports/heres-...sity-joke-country-music-career-035843961.html

My favorite quote and why I’ve always said Troy is better than Romo and underrated

“Players, like Woodson, saw their quarterback arrive every day at 6:30 a.m. and adjusted their routines accordingly. They also respected his ability.

“We wanted Troy’s stamp of approval,” Johnston said.

“I used to call him ‘Cool Whip’ back in the day, cause he could whip the ball,” Woodson said of the former Super Bowl MVP and six-time Pro Bowl selection, who finished his career with 32,942 career passing yards and 165 career touchdowns. “We used to call him all kinds of names. ‘Cool Whip.’ ‘Eight Ball.’ You name it. He threw the perfect pass. He’s the best quarterback I’ve been around.

“You can’t tell me Tony Romo was a better quarterback than Troy. I don’t even think that’s a close comparison. Troy, with a wide-open offense, with his ability to deliver the football, at a young age, and be able to lead the way he did, he would put up astronomical numbers.”
 

rnr_honeybadger

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,297
Reaction score
17,053
There have been some epic threads here intimating as much!
Tony Romo was a classic underachiever. He worked at his craft but honestly the vibe I got from Romo was that if he was cut the next day he'd be fine about it. Football was never his life, it was just a means for him to earn a living and got him to bang a few famous women.
 

nightrain

Since 1971
Messages
14,527
Reaction score
24,375
https://www.yahoo.com/sports/heres-...sity-joke-country-music-career-035843961.html

My favorite quote and why I’ve always said Troy is better than Romo and underrated

“Players, like Woodson, saw their quarterback arrive every day at 6:30 a.m. and adjusted their routines accordingly. They also respected his ability.

“We wanted Troy’s stamp of approval,” Johnston said.

“I used to call him ‘Cool Whip’ back in the day, cause he could whip the ball,” Woodson said of the former Super Bowl MVP and six-time Pro Bowl selection, who finished his career with 32,942 career passing yards and 165 career touchdowns. “We used to call him all kinds of names. ‘Cool Whip.’ ‘Eight Ball.’ You name it. He threw the perfect pass. He’s the best quarterback I’ve been around.

“You can’t tell me Tony Romo was a better quarterback than Troy. I don’t even think that’s a close comparison. Troy, with a wide-open offense, with his ability to deliver the football, at a young age, and be able to lead the way he did, he would put up astronomical numbers.”
As good as Romo was at times, he couldn't hold Aikman's jock.
 

rnr_honeybadger

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,297
Reaction score
17,053

Super_Kazuya

Well-Known Member
Messages
7,074
Reaction score
9,113
On the field, Tony Romo was better than Troy Aikman using the information we have available. Troy was great as long as he had pre-free agency superteams that he could bus drive. As soon as they needed more from Troy (after 1996) he and the team both went into the can. Sure, Troy could have had gaudier numbers when he was younger... but he also might have hit 70 homers if he started playing baseball instead. Neither happened so I don’t really care about it.
 

CowboyRoy

Well-Known Member
Messages
57,924
Reaction score
38,930
https://www.yahoo.com/sports/heres-...sity-joke-country-music-career-035843961.html

My favorite quote and why I’ve always said Troy is better than Romo and underrated

“Players, like Woodson, saw their quarterback arrive every day at 6:30 a.m. and adjusted their routines accordingly. They also respected his ability.

“We wanted Troy’s stamp of approval,” Johnston said.

“I used to call him ‘Cool Whip’ back in the day, cause he could whip the ball,” Woodson said of the former Super Bowl MVP and six-time Pro Bowl selection, who finished his career with 32,942 career passing yards and 165 career touchdowns. “We used to call him all kinds of names. ‘Cool Whip.’ ‘Eight Ball.’ You name it. He threw the perfect pass. He’s the best quarterback I’ve been around.

“You can’t tell me Tony Romo was a better quarterback than Troy. I don’t even think that’s a close comparison. Troy, with a wide-open offense, with his ability to deliver the football, at a young age, and be able to lead the way he did, he would put up astronomical numbers.”

Loved Troy and Jimmy said the same thing. But for the life of him he couldn't throw the deep ball. He also didn't real have burners on a regular basis.
 

Miller

ARTIST FORMERLY KNOWN AS TEXASFROG
Messages
11,874
Reaction score
13,460
On the field, Tony Romo was better than Troy Aikman using the information we have available. Troy was great as long as he had pre-free agency superteams that he could bus drive. As soon as they needed more from Troy (after 1996) he and the team both went into the can. Sure, Troy could have had gaudier numbers when he was younger... but he also might have hit 70 homers if he started playing baseball instead. Neither happened so I don’t really care about it.

Disagree. You can’t take numbers from two completely different eras and say “this is the answer” I’ll take Woodson’s take. Troy played in an era with press coverage where guys mauled WRs and was one of the most accurate passers in playoff history. Romo played in a playground era that was wide open. If I told you the QBs would switch eras would you trust Aikman in a wide open league or Romo...who already had interception issues..in a game where there was only so much space to throw? It’s easy
 
Last edited:

Fla Cowpoke

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,965
Reaction score
11,986
It is such a hard comparison....I don't think Troy would have been that good with the crappy O lines that Romo had the great part of his career. I don't know that Troy would have worked well with Dez....but maybe Troy would have snapped him into shape. I think there is no doubt that Troy had more athletic ability, especially as a young QB....but Tony could do much more with a less structured offense. Troy's resume says he is better, but I really think it isn't as far apart as a lot apparently do.
 
Top