Props to Jason Garrett

Bob-Lillys-War

Well-Known Member
Messages
27,679
Reaction score
24,793
I look at coaches and players differently. People said Aikman wasn’t a HOF QB because of his line, Emmitt etc but at QB you still have to make the plays. Troys accuracy was unreal, especially in the playoffs and in a league where guys ran hard press coverage. Dak is doing great snd making the throws now.

With a coach...JG..he was our OCoordinator and was hired as an offensive HC. Then we were told he needed his own guy and more of a leadership role so his guy was Linehan. Then he needed another coordinator to take the blah offense that was 90s based to a new level. So now he has a boy genius, a bevy of WRs, a QB, a top RB etc. All I’m asking is what is his main contribution? Every coach that wins a championship has a great team and players but they usually have a specialty. So I want to know what his is now? Is it the team plays for him? I just feel in order for Jerry to get his “told ya” he spent a decade having to insulate JG. Making the team JG proof

He is now known as a 'motivational speaker' ; & somehow (without making the playoffs) he is regarded as a good coach by a group of very few fans .

Even Jerrah said that his post season record is lacking .

9 years ago he was regarded as 'an offensive guru'; exactly as KEVIN is regarded today after 2 games .

The bar has gone so low ...
 

Idgit

Fattening up
Staff member
Messages
58,971
Reaction score
60,826
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
That’s because your definition of success and others are completely different. Winning the east is not the ultimate goal. How does other teams in the east winning the SB make the clapper a better coach. It just shows he can’t coach on the same level. You logic is out of whack!

No, you're making assumptions about things that I haven't said. For example, I didn't suggest at all that winning the East is the ultimate goal. I suggested it's a measure of how good the team is and a measure of the job Garrett's done.

Your logic is out of whack, because you make the mistake that everyone else makes to think that coaching is primarily how good teams advance in the playoffs. There are a ton of factors (coaching, matchups, injuries, refereeing, luck, etc.). If there were evidence we're losing playoff games primarily because of coaching, that would be one thing. But there really isn't.

I obviously reference other teams winning the Superbowl as a measure of how strong the NFCE has been during the period we're discussing. Because another person wrongly stated the East has been in shambles while Garrett's here. Another bad argument to try to prop up what he wanted to believe in the first place.
 

CowboysFaninHouston

CowboysFaninDC
Messages
31,715
Reaction score
17,987
Im just saying that your rankings are probably based off of yards which in reality, doenst mean much. Romo could wing the ball all over the field all by himself but we often stalled at the GL.

Everyone knew that Romo was the real brains behind that offense and the real reason it went up and down the field. Heck, Romo demanded that he be more involved in calling his own plays when he resigned. Which is a total slap in the face to Garrett.
The year we were 3rd. We were 2nd in scoring
 

CowboysFaninHouston

CowboysFaninDC
Messages
31,715
Reaction score
17,987
Which makes it even worse. Moore has taken Garretts offense and run it better than Garrett. He turned Garretts horrid offense into an unstoppable machine. What does that say about Garret? LOL

But you would be lying to yourself if you watched the last two weeks and you thought it looked anything like Garretts offense.
No arguing there. But there is some talent on this team.

According to Dak fanatics we had a top offense second half of the season after we acquired Cooper.

That was with linehan.


Don't forget we played to weak defenses. About to play a college team this week.
 

CowboyRoy

Well-Known Member
Messages
57,924
Reaction score
38,930
No arguing there. But there is some talent on this team.

According to Dak fanatics we had a top offense second half of the season after we acquired Cooper.

That was with linehan.


Don't forget we played to weak defenses. About to play a college team this week.

What Dak fans? LOL

So you are a big fan of Garrett, but you dont like Dak? This is hilarious.
 

Idgit

Fattening up
Staff member
Messages
58,971
Reaction score
60,826
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
So all of them you deny? Or are some true?

What you’ve done there is a step above making farting noises and asking me which ones sound true.

Put some thought into your criticisms, and I’ll give them the consideration they deserve.
 

Alexander

What's it going to be then, eh?
Messages
62,463
Reaction score
67,274
I think it is awesome we can have a Garrett appreciation thread like this.

Then the likes of @Idgit can frolic.

I suggest a sticky so all can see.
 

CowboyRoy

Well-Known Member
Messages
57,924
Reaction score
38,930
What you’ve done there is a step above making farting noises and asking me which ones sound true.

Put some thought into your criticisms, and I’ll give them the consideration they deserve.

I just asking you simple questions. And you cant seem to answer other than saying the opposite of whatever I say.

So you think Garrett is a

-great play caller?
-great clock manager?
-Great coordinator?
-Great at in game adjustments?

ect.....ect......? The rest of the known world thinks Garrett is horrible at them.

Yet Garrett used to be the OC and play caller here in Dallas, and no longer does any of it. Which you cant explain either.
 

CowboyRoy

Well-Known Member
Messages
57,924
Reaction score
38,930
I think it is awesome we can have a Garrett appreciation thread like this.

Then the likes of @Idgit can frolic.

I suggest a sticky so all can see.

And frolic he is doing.

He is now claiming that Garrett is a great play caller, in game manager, clock manager, ect.....ect....
 

morat1959

Well-Known Member
Messages
7,673
Reaction score
8,078
No, you're making assumptions about things that I haven't said. For example, I didn't suggest at all that winning the East is the ultimate goal. I suggested it's a measure of how good the team is and a measure of the job Garrett's done.

Your logic is out of whack, because you make the mistake that everyone else makes to think that coaching is primarily how good teams advance in the playoffs. There are a ton of factors (coaching, matchups, injuries, refereeing, luck, etc.). If there were evidence we're losing playoff games primarily because of coaching, that would be one thing. But there really isn't.

I obviously reference other teams winning the Superbowl as a measure of how strong the NFCE has been during the period we're discussing. Because another person wrongly stated the East has been in shambles while Garrett's here. Another bad argument to try to prop up what he wanted to believe in the first place.

So that’s all we want as fans? A coach who can win the east 3 out of 10 years on the job. Fail Garrett.

No matter how strong the other teams have been in the east or any other division, we have how many playoff wins during Garrett’s tenure? Fail Garrett.

What does Garrett add to this team? He’s had responsibilities taken from him every few years as he fails miserably at everything he does. Fail Garrett.

We just see things from a totally different side. I want SB wins. Your logic isn’t geared in that direction.
 

Idgit

Fattening up
Staff member
Messages
58,971
Reaction score
60,826
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
So that’s all we want as fans? A coach who can win the east 3 out of 10 years on the job. Fail Garrett.

No matter how strong the other teams have been in the east or any other division, we have how many playoff wins during Garrett’s tenure? Fail Garrett.

What does Garrett add to this team? He’s had responsibilities taken from him every few years as he fails miserably at everything he does. Fail Garrett.

We just see things from a totally different side. I want SB wins. Your logic isn’t geared in that direction.

We both want Superbowl wins. You’re just blaming the wrong factors for why we haven’t gotten them recently.
 

Idgit

Fattening up
Staff member
Messages
58,971
Reaction score
60,826
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
I think it is awesome we can have a Garrett appreciation thread like this.

Then the likes of @Idgit can frolic.

I suggest a sticky so all can see.

I do tend to frolic when I’m obviously right.

Go ahead and sticky it, chief.
 

CowboyRoy

Well-Known Member
Messages
57,924
Reaction score
38,930
So that’s all we want as fans? A coach who can win the east 3 out of 10 years on the job. Fail Garrett.

No matter how strong the other teams have been in the east or any other division, we have how many playoff wins during Garrett’s tenure? Fail Garrett.

What does Garrett add to this team? He’s had responsibilities taken from him every few years as he fails miserably at everything he does. Fail Garrett.

We just see things from a totally different side. I want SB wins. Your logic isn’t geared in that direction.
:lmao::lmao::lmao::lmao2::lmao2::lmao2::lmao2:

According to Idgit, its Garrett that is the victim here, not the Cowboys. It has been Garrett that has been burdened with a woeful lack of talent here in Dallas.

If Garrett is given enough talent, he is capable of winning a SB as HC.

True story!!!! :flagwave::flagwave:
 
Top