Yes, Jason Garrett has won enough regular season games to qualify for the playoffs 3 times in 9 seasons and has 2 Wildcard wins to show for it. Is that record satisfactory for a 9th year head coach in the NFL?
I would say no, that record on its on is not good enough for a new contract, he needs to show me more.
Jerry and Stephen apparently agree or else Garrett would have a new extension by now. I mean, the Saints just gave Sean Payton a new 5 year extension, but I dont see Jerry or Stephen lining up to give Garrett a new extension yet. They obviously want to see how Garrett finishes the season, meaning how far in the playoffs does Garrett take this team. He needs to get the team over the hump, I dont think that is being unreasonable, do you?