Your Starting 5 (All-Time) Cowboys' O-Lineman

Jeffkills

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,125
Reaction score
2,749
For this exercise, let's assume these guys are all in their primes...

For me I can't help but learn upon my experience..

LT - Tyrone Smith
LG - LA
C - Fredbeard
RG - The President
RT - Big Cat!!

I hope most of us can't see how this wouldn't work...

Can't wait to see the old-timer's tell me I'm stupid! Lol!
 

Jeffkills

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,125
Reaction score
2,749

a03938aa-13b7-484c-8fdd-82e5d5248a9b_1.aa25e54cbe1d9403c8084714ad06ce56.jpeg

Then post in a Dak thread...
 

UncleOscar

Well-Known Member
Messages
756
Reaction score
1,303
While I loved Erik William's pre auto accident, he was never the same after stupidly running his car into that wall. His play deteriorated after he recovered. Thus, because of this I'm penciling in Rayfield Wright at RT.

In his third season in 1969, Wright got his first chance as a starter after Ralph Neely was sidelined by injury. His opponent in his first start was Los Angeles Rams future Hall of Fame defensive end Deacon Jones, who was in his prime. Wright's performance was so strong that he won a starting role as right tackle before the first day of training camp in 1970.

For thirteen seasons, Wright played more than 200 games, started at right tackle in six NFC Championship games, and played in five Super Bowls, winning two of them: (VI, XII). He earned his first of four All-Pro honors in 1971 and was voted that same year to the first of six straight Pro Bowls.

Wright was named first- or second-team All-Pro each season from 1971 through 1976, earned three All-NFC honors, and the Cowboys led the league for total offense five times (ranked 6th all-time at retirement in 1979). His blocking and leadership as the team's co-captain for seven years helped the Cowboys win 10 division titles and six conference crowns.

Williams slammed his Mercedes into a retaining wall on an LBJ exit ramp at 3 a.m. He suffered two torn knee ligaments, a ruptured muscle in his right knee, a broken rib, torn ligaments in his left thumb and facial cuts. His blood-alcohol level was almost double the legal limit.
 
Last edited:

Swanny

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,519
Reaction score
3,267
While I loved Erik William's pre auto accident, he was never the same after stupidly running his car into that wall. His play deteriorated after he recovered. Thus, because of this I'm penciling in Rayfield Wright at RT.

In his third season in 1969, Wright got his first chance as a starter after Ralph Neely was sidelined by injury. His opponent in his first start was Los Angeles Rams future Hall of Fame defensive end Deacon Jones, who was in his prime. Wright's performance was so strong that he won a starting role as right tackle before the first day of training camp in 1970.

For thirteen seasons, Wright played more than 200 games, started at right tackle in six NFC Championship games, and played in five Super Bowls, winning two of them: (VI, XII). He earned his first of four All-Pro honors in 1971 and was voted that same year to the first of six straight Pro Bowls.

Wright was named first- or second-team All-Pro each season from 1971 through 1976, earned three All-NFC honors, and the Cowboys led the league for total offense five times (ranked 6th all-time at retirement in 1979). His blocking and leadership as the team's co-captain for seven years helped the Cowboys win 10 division titles and six conference crowns.

Williams slammed his Mercedes into a retaining wall on an LBJ exit ramp at 3 a.m. He suffered two torn knee ligaments, a ruptured muscle in his right knee, a broken rib, torn ligaments in his left thumb and facial cuts. His blood-alcohol level was almost double the legal limit.
This is tough. I feel Big E was probably the best RT all time until his accident. He did not play long enough though. But before that accident he was the only person on the planet that could man handle Reggie White, who is the best all time DE.

Wright has the longevity and proven track record.

Since this is a hypothetical thread I'd pick Big E pre car accident to play 1 season. But if I'm building a franchise and years from now matter I would pick Wright.

I feel like this is pretty easy besides RT
 
Last edited:

MWH1967

The Cook
Messages
7,051
Reaction score
9,381
LT-Tyron Smith
LG- Larry Allen
C- Mark Stepnoski
RG-Zack Martin
RT- Erik Williams



I win
Even with his superior understanding of leverage I'm not sure Mark could hang with todays NFL. He dressed at 269 lbs.
 

jazzcat22

Staff member
Messages
77,366
Reaction score
96,027
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
Replace Stepnoski with Frederick and you really will win.

I am still thinking on the rest of the names, but my 1st thought was Stepnoski at C.
As one can't ignore SB wins over just solid play from recent players.

Way too many that could be produce the "best" OL.
Beside Larry Allen hands down. Way too many to consider.
 

joseephuss

Well-Known Member
Messages
27,904
Reaction score
6,806
I am still thinking on the rest of the names, but my 1st thought was Stepnoski at C.
As one can't ignore SB wins over just solid play from recent players.

Way too many that could be produce the "best" OL.
Beside Larry Allen hands down. Way too many to consider.

The NFL is the ultimate team sport. Evidence of just how good those 90s teams are and how much the whole team matters is that there was a different starting center in each Super Bowl win from the 1990s. Stepnoski started SBXXVII, Gesek started SBXXVIII and Kennard started SBXXX. Stepnoski was a very good center and played on better teams, but he is not the best center in Cowboys history. It is a close battle, but I'd give it to Frederick.
 

jazzcat22

Staff member
Messages
77,366
Reaction score
96,027
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
The NFL is the ultimate team sport. Evidence of just how good those 90s teams are and how much the whole team matters is that there was a different starting center in each Super Bowl win from the 1990s. Stepnoski started SBXXVII, Gesek started SBXXVIII and Kennard started SBXXX. Stepnoski was a very good center and played on better teams, but he is not the best center in Cowboys history. It is a close battle, but I'd give it to Frederick.

Thanks for pointing that out, I completely forgot about that. They had Ray Donaldson too at C, but he got injured I think. Then Kennard took over?
 

OmerV

Well-Known Member
Messages
25,916
Reaction score
22,440
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
For this exercise, let's assume these guys are all in their primes...

For me I can't help but learn upon my experience..

LT - Tyrone Smith
LG - LA
C - Fredbeard
RG - The President
RT - Big Cat!!

I hope most of us can't see how this wouldn't work...

Can't wait to see the old-timer's tell me I'm stupid! Lol!
I assume "The President" is Zack Martin?

I suppose I'm an old timer, but I don't find fault in this. A person could substitute Rayfield Wright in at OT - I would - but the OT's you listed are worthy candidates as well.
 

gimmesix

Fat, drunk and stupid is no way to go through life
Messages
37,667
Reaction score
34,712
While I loved Erik William's pre auto accident, he was never the same after stupidly running his car into that wall. His play deteriorated after he recovered. Thus, because of this I'm penciling in Rayfield Wright at RT.

In his third season in 1969, Wright got his first chance as a starter after Ralph Neely was sidelined by injury. His opponent in his first start was Los Angeles Rams future Hall of Fame defensive end Deacon Jones, who was in his prime. Wright's performance was so strong that he won a starting role as right tackle before the first day of training camp in 1970.

For thirteen seasons, Wright played more than 200 games, started at right tackle in six NFC Championship games, and played in five Super Bowls, winning two of them: (VI, XII). He earned his first of four All-Pro honors in 1971 and was voted that same year to the first of six straight Pro Bowls.

Wright was named first- or second-team All-Pro each season from 1971 through 1976, earned three All-NFC honors, and the Cowboys led the league for total offense five times (ranked 6th all-time at retirement in 1979). His blocking and leadership as the team's co-captain for seven years helped the Cowboys win 10 division titles and six conference crowns.

Williams slammed his Mercedes into a retaining wall on an LBJ exit ramp at 3 a.m. He suffered two torn knee ligaments, a ruptured muscle in his right knee, a broken rib, torn ligaments in his left thumb and facial cuts. His blood-alcohol level was almost double the legal limit.

I agree with this and almost wanted to not have Frederick as the top center since his career was relatively short, but even though we've had some good ones, I don't think any of them individually quite matches Frederick.
 

UncleOscar

Well-Known Member
Messages
756
Reaction score
1,303
I agree with this and almost wanted to not have Frederick as the top center since his career was relatively short, but even though we've had some good ones, I don't think any of them individually quite matches Frederick.

Hey Gimmesix, were you one of the posters on the old Fort Worth Star Cowboys board?
 
Top