Fire Mccarthy

cowboyskid29

Well-Known Member
Messages
406
Reaction score
487
What exactly are you in disagreement with? Dak is the QB and we need a playmaker at LB. Other pieces will hopefully be upgraded.

My point is Dak is not a difference maker! They were on there way to 1-4 with him and a Watermelon kick from 0-5! McCarthy is maybe the worst coach Dallas could have hired and wasting another year will not prove otherwise!
 

The Quest for Six

Well-Known Member
Messages
19,837
Reaction score
19,287
Sure the defense is bad and needs improvement. I'd draft defense if I had a say. But I really think if we have a healthy Dak we score enough points to win several of those games. The defense is going to give up some but at least it wasn't a sieve. That's how it is going to be under McCarthy so we might as well see what next season has to offer.

The defense was a sieve, they need to fire Nolan and hire a 4-3 defensive coach and stop with the hybrid, 3-4 nonsense, this isn't a 3-4 team.......this defense gave up 13 and 15 play drives to Cincy before they fumbled the ball away and a rookie QB offense put up 477 yards for Philly last week....they're not a bad defense, they're a dreadful defense, worst in cowboy history....
 

The Quest for Six

Well-Known Member
Messages
19,837
Reaction score
19,287
I hope next year the NFL schedule makers put the Cowboys on a lot of noon games and stop featuring them as game of the week or in prime time...
 

JBond

Well-Known Member
Messages
10,022
Reaction score
3,487
My point is Dak is not a difference maker! They were on there way to 1-4 with him and a Watermelon kick from 0-5! McCarthy is maybe the worst coach Dallas could have hired and wasting another year will not prove otherwise!
Reality will knock you upside the head at some point. Not sure how old you are. Reality and age will catch up to you. The Cowboys have wasted decades of amazing players.

Dak is fine for now. We have studs on offense. We need speed and intelligence on defense.
 

cowboyskid29

Well-Known Member
Messages
406
Reaction score
487
Reality will knock you upside the head at some point. Not sure how old you are. Reality and age will catch up to you. The Cowboys have wasted decades of amazing players.

Dak is fine for now. We have studs on offense. We need speed and intelligence on defense.

Im old enough to see poor coaching and wasted talent! Which I guess is the point you’re trying to make. My issue isn’t with Dak it’s with McCarty who the entire NFL avoided until Jerry couldn’t coddle JG anymore! McCarthy is literally the only coach he could have hired that was worse than Garret!

Again, remember, Parcells took Hambrick and Quincy Carter to 10 wins.

Maybe youre too young to remember? And maybe too young to remember how bad the end of his tenure was in GB
 

Kingofholland

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,898
Reaction score
6,315
My take 100% ......even if it wasn't clear, you gotta challenge it under the circumstances.

Yep, if it's close and it takes points away you have to do it. McCarthy likely got some bad Intel from upstairs. Hard to see on the video monitor and I'm sure they weren't playing it in slow motion. Regardless worth a challenge.
 

HotDog37

Well-Known Member
Messages
917
Reaction score
1,150
McCarthy looks about as lost out there as Garrett was maybe more so. What would it take for Jerry to hire a known good coach again instead of touting the line "we want someone with NFL experience?" It appears to me that we can't build a good football roster mostly on the D side, and the roster we do get we can't even coach well, and we don't properly develop players we put them in bad spots out of position and badly coached (not coached up not with a regimen). Coaches can't clock manage and don't know basic football time management strategy. We did hit on Dak Prescott he's a good player. Zeke was good for a few years.

I would tear the entire thing down and rebuild with very high quality coaches, better drafting, look to insert a better football culture. I know I'm in the minority and the Dallas Cowboys have essentially become more or less like Pro Wrestling where it's about the show not the go. We need to return to go.
 
Last edited:
Top