NFC way too early optics

waving monkey

Well-Known Member
Messages
15,540
Reaction score
14,930
Don't need to hear about how things can change over the season. This thread is not a wait and see approach. So play along if you like.

Currently, I predict the top three teams as of now are Tampa Bay, Seattle, and Green Bay (as long as AR plays). My top grouping's ceiling is here with legitimate shots at the SB. Their floor is to finish average (unless injury or non availability of their QB or top three players).
I'd place Dallas in 2nd tier.
A top 5 QB with a top 8 offensive line and top 3 receiving core with some consistency at OC.
The defense will not be lost. Better coach the middle of the line will not be a seive
The second tier are teams that I can envision ending up challenging these top teams for their spots in my ranking but more likely are higher end playoff teams that just fall shy of the elite three. They are San Francisco, Los Angeles, and Minnesota. San Francisco is a team that I could envision making a dramatic turnaround with better health (their entire squad had injuries along with their QB).

My third tier is made up of teams that I predict are the rest of the middle tier (which is the largest group because of how closely I view these squads). Any have the potential of joining the second tier here but I just cannot envision any of these teams as tier one at this time. They are Arizona, Chicago, Dallas, New York, Washington, and New Orleans. Arizona is so odd with their moves and team setup (just difficult to predict their outcome).

Bottom tier teams are more in flux (coaching and of player movement) and much more difficult to envision even making the playoffs. Carolina, Detroit, Philadelphia, and Atlanta.

Since we are Cowboys fans, I will give you my thoughts on where I see the Cowboys' season and how they currently stack up. I can envision the Cowboys having a season record between 7 and 10 wins. I cannot really envision a much better or worse record.

Injuries aside from cowboys and opponents, I see them neck and neck with any of the tier 3 teams I mentioned. I would agree that the Cowboys offense is the best of the NFC East, but it almost entirely depends on the health of the offensive line. I predict some problems with availability along the line and play level from the top lineman when they actually play (with existing injuries).

I predict a better defensive unit, but one that has difficulties generating consistent pressure and consistent coverage units. A middle of the pack defense with a sometimes high flying offense is my prediction. If the Cowboys can get a 4-2 division record without being swept by anyone, then I can imagine a division title and playoff appearance.

That's pretty much it. Kinda just more sideways action though some here feel a division title is a major step up. I do not. The NFC East and NFC in general feels too oddball and not enough squads exist with the best run front offices and coaching staffs. There are no organizations like the Patriots, Ravens, Steelers, Chiefs in the conference.

I actually miss Andy Reid being in the same division. At least you could count on him making his squad a decent team for the most part.
 

DaBoys12

Well-Known Member
Messages
376
Reaction score
380
If this team can’t get 10 wins heads need to roll, I don’t care how bad the defense is, and I expect the D to be better this year. This offense has plenty of talent to win at least 10, if they don’t, the wrong coaching staff is here.
 

Techsass

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,396
Reaction score
5,947
I enjoyed your post, but think 7-10 wins is on the pessimistic side. Picturing 10 losses is a bit hard on me right now. The Bucs & KC are the only teams that scare me at this point & I'm not totally giving up on those games.
 

StarBoyz83

Well-Known Member
Messages
17,283
Reaction score
11,842
7-10 wins seems about right. But since the schedule is so weak I'm being optimistic and saying 9-11 wins
 

Blitzen

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,900
Reaction score
2,073
I enjoyed your post, but think 7-10 wins is on the pessimistic side. Picturing 10 losses is a bit hard on me right now. The Bucs & KC are the only teams that scare me at this point & I'm not totally giving up on those games.

It's definitely not on the overly optimistic side. 10 wins is four more than the team had last year and 2 more than the team had in 2019.

I can visualize the team improving from last season, but have to exercise immense amounts of liquid courage to go further than 10 wins. So many things would need to break the Cowboys' way.

If the team stumbles early and often, then it could carry through the entire season. I could envision a scenario where the squad only managed to win seven games (through an unhealthy offensive line and defensive malfunctions). I do not see fewer than seven wins
 

Fastpitch Dad

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,506
Reaction score
2,264
Don't need to hear about how things can change over the season. This thread is not a wait and see approach. So play along if you like.

Currently, I predict the top three teams as of now are Tampa Bay, Seattle, and Green Bay (as long as AR plays). My top grouping's ceiling is here with legitimate shots at the SB. Their floor is to finish average (unless injury or non availability of their QB or top three players).

The second tier are teams that I can envision ending up challenging these top teams for their spots in my ranking but more likely are higher end playoff teams that just fall shy of the elite three. They are San Francisco, Los Angeles, and Minnesota. San Francisco is a team that I could envision making a dramatic turnaround with better health (their entire squad had injuries along with their QB).

My third tier is made up of teams that I predict are the rest of the middle tier (which is the largest group because of how closely I view these squads). Any have the potential of joining the second tier here but I just cannot envision any of these teams as tier one at this time. They are Arizona, Chicago, Dallas, New York, Washington, and New Orleans. Arizona is so odd with their moves and team setup (just difficult to predict their outcome).

Bottom tier teams are more in flux (coaching and of player movement) and much more difficult to envision even making the playoffs. Carolina, Detroit, Philadelphia, and Atlanta.

Since we are Cowboys fans, I will give you my thoughts on where I see the Cowboys' season and how they currently stack up. I can envision the Cowboys having a season record between 7 and 10 wins. I cannot really envision a much better or worse record.

Injuries aside from cowboys and opponents, I see them neck and neck with any of the tier 3 teams I mentioned. I would agree that the Cowboys offense is the best of the NFC East, but it almost entirely depends on the health of the offensive line. I predict some problems with availability along the line and play level from the top lineman when they actually play (with existing injuries).

I predict a better defensive unit, but one that has difficulties generating consistent pressure and consistent coverage units. A middle of the pack defense with a sometimes high flying offense is my prediction. If the Cowboys can get a 4-2 division record without being swept by anyone, then I can imagine a division title and playoff appearance.

That's pretty much it. Kinda just more sideways action though some here feel a division title is a major step up. I do not. The NFC East and NFC in general feels too oddball and not enough squads exist with the best run front offices and coaching staffs. There are no organizations like the Patriots, Ravens, Steelers, Chiefs in the conference.

I actually miss Andy Reid being in the same division. At least you could count on him making his squad a decent team for the most part.

Well thought out post, I don't agree with all of it but I do think overall it's pretty accurate imo.
 

McKDaddy

Well-Known Member
Messages
8,363
Reaction score
8,623
This place will implode if the Cowboys start 0-2 after facing Brady and Herbert on the road.
This could easily happen. Some extra time between the games is a benefit but still a dangerous early season test.
 

fivetwos

Well-Known Member
Messages
19,350
Reaction score
26,286
Consider this when trying to predict the outcome of an upcoming season....

Win total discussion is all wonky with the extra game....but how often has Dallas had a 10 or 11 win season lately?

They either surprise with 12 or 13 wins.....

Underachive at 8-8....

Or have a 4 or 5 win disaster with tons of excuses.

Doesn't mean it can't happen this year, but they seem to entirely avoid the cautious optimism level of being just a little better than mediocre.

Yes, there actually have been some very good seasons over the "25 year" drought, but the blown one seeds sting much more than 4-12 or 5-11 ever did IMO.
 

fivetwos

Well-Known Member
Messages
19,350
Reaction score
26,286
Don't need to hear about how things can change over the season. This thread is not a wait and see approach. So play along if you like.

Currently, I predict the top three teams as of now are Tampa Bay, Seattle, and Green Bay (as long as AR plays). My top grouping's ceiling is here with legitimate shots at the SB. Their floor is to finish average (unless injury or non availability of their QB or top three players).

The second tier are teams that I can envision ending up challenging these top teams for their spots in my ranking but more likely are higher end playoff teams that just fall shy of the elite three. They are San Francisco, Los Angeles, and Minnesota. San Francisco is a team that I could envision making a dramatic turnaround with better health (their entire squad had injuries along with their QB).

My third tier is made up of teams that I predict are the rest of the middle tier (which is the largest group because of how closely I view these squads). Any have the potential of joining the second tier here but I just cannot envision any of these teams as tier one at this time. They are Arizona, Chicago, Dallas, New York, Washington, and New Orleans. Arizona is so odd with their moves and team setup (just difficult to predict their outcome).

Bottom tier teams are more in flux (coaching and of player movement) and much more difficult to envision even making the playoffs. Carolina, Detroit, Philadelphia, and Atlanta.

Since we are Cowboys fans, I will give you my thoughts on where I see the Cowboys' season and how they currently stack up. I can envision the Cowboys having a season record between 7 and 10 wins. I cannot really envision a much better or worse record.

Injuries aside from cowboys and opponents, I see them neck and neck with any of the tier 3 teams I mentioned. I would agree that the Cowboys offense is the best of the NFC East, but it almost entirely depends on the health of the offensive line. I predict some problems with availability along the line and play level from the top lineman when they actually play (with existing injuries).

I predict a better defensive unit, but one that has difficulties generating consistent pressure and consistent coverage units. A middle of the pack defense with a sometimes high flying offense is my prediction. If the Cowboys can get a 4-2 division record without being swept by anyone, then I can imagine a division title and playoff appearance.

That's pretty much it. Kinda just more sideways action though some here feel a division title is a major step up. I do not. The NFC East and NFC in general feels too oddball and not enough squads exist with the best run front offices and coaching staffs. There are no organizations like the Patriots, Ravens, Steelers, Chiefs in the conference.

I actually miss Andy Reid being in the same division. At least you could count on him making his squad a decent team for the most part.
I'm having a tough time agreeing on the NFC East.

We should be very happy that it's weak. Been that way for a while. It kept Garrett here way longer than he should have been, but it also allows a team like ours to think playoffs in June.

How'd you like to be Vegas right now with Mahomes likely in KC for a lifetime and Denver maybe getting Rodgers? Not to mention Herbert. Oooof.

I also enjoy going against the clown show leaders in Philly now much more than when Reid was there.

Not trying to argue, just saying. The shame of it all is the inability to truly take advantage of a weak division for about a decade now.
 

fivetwos

Well-Known Member
Messages
19,350
Reaction score
26,286
Did we forget about what Seattle was for the second half of last season? They flat out stunk, and they haven't gotten better this offseason. You could pretty much say the same thing about the Rams.

If everyone's healthy, the only teams you can consider putting in a tier above Dallas are Tampa and GB.
Seattle isn't a good team at all....but, they have the coach and QB with the hardware, and people are going to look toward that.
 

75boyz

Well-Known Member
Messages
8,081
Reaction score
9,746
Don't need to hear about how things can change over the season. This thread is not a wait and see approach. So play along if you like.

Currently, I predict the top three teams as of now are Tampa Bay, Seattle, and Green Bay (as long as AR plays). My top grouping's ceiling is here with legitimate shots at the SB. Their floor is to finish average (unless injury or non availability of their QB or top three players).

The second tier are teams that I can envision ending up challenging these top teams for their spots in my ranking but more likely are higher end playoff teams that just fall shy of the elite three. They are San Francisco, Los Angeles, and Minnesota. San Francisco is a team that I could envision making a dramatic turnaround with better health (their entire squad had injuries along with their QB).

My third tier is made up of teams that I predict are the rest of the middle tier (which is the largest group because of how closely I view these squads). Any have the potential of joining the second tier here but I just cannot envision any of these teams as tier one at this time. They are Arizona, Chicago, Dallas, New York, Washington, and New Orleans. Arizona is so odd with their moves and team setup (just difficult to predict their outcome).

Bottom tier teams are more in flux (coaching and of player movement) and much more difficult to envision even making the playoffs. Carolina, Detroit, Philadelphia, and Atlanta.

Since we are Cowboys fans, I will give you my thoughts on where I see the Cowboys' season and how they currently stack up. I can envision the Cowboys having a season record between 7 and 10 wins. I cannot really envision a much better or worse record.

Injuries aside from cowboys and opponents, I see them neck and neck with any of the tier 3 teams I mentioned. I would agree that the Cowboys offense is the best of the NFC East, but it almost entirely depends on the health of the offensive line. I predict some problems with availability along the line and play level from the top lineman when they actually play (with existing injuries).

I predict a better defensive unit, but one that has difficulties generating consistent pressure and consistent coverage units. A middle of the pack defense with a sometimes high flying offense is my prediction. If the Cowboys can get a 4-2 division record without being swept by anyone, then I can imagine a division title and playoff appearance.

That's pretty much it. Kinda just more sideways action though some here feel a division title is a major step up. I do not. The NFC East and NFC in general feels too oddball and not enough squads exist with the best run front offices and coaching staffs. There are no organizations like the Patriots, Ravens, Steelers, Chiefs in the conference.

I actually miss Andy Reid being in the same division. At least you could count on him making his squad a decent team for the most part.

I watch pro football with an extremely similar optics prescription as you. Outstanding post.
 

Blitzen

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,900
Reaction score
2,073
I'm having a tough time agreeing on the NFC East.

We should be very happy that it's weak. Been that way for a while. It kept Garrett here way longer than he should have been, but it also allows a team like ours to think playoffs in June.

How'd you like to be Vegas right now with Mahomes likely in KC for a lifetime and Denver maybe getting Rodgers? Not to mention Herbert. Oooof.

I also enjoy going against the clown show leaders in Philly now much more than when Reid was there.

Not trying to argue, just saying. The shame of it all is the inability to truly take advantage of a weak division for about a decade now.

Yeah, I'm not happy about a weak division. Weak divisions do not put pressure on the Cowboys front office. If the Cowboys had two top notch organizations in the division that always built solid or exceptional clubs, it would pressure the Cowboys to do the same. Currently, the Cowboys and all the other NFC East clubs can bank on upheaval and disorganization from their opponents from year to year.
 

Techsass

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,396
Reaction score
5,947
It's definitely not on the overly optimistic side. 10 wins is four more than the team had last year and 2 more than the team had in 2019.

I can visualize the team improving from last season, but have to exercise immense amounts of liquid courage to go further than 10 wins. So many things would need to break the Cowboys' way.

If the team stumbles early and often, then it could carry through the entire season. I could envision a scenario where the squad only managed to win seven games (through an unhealthy offensive line and defensive malfunctions). I do not see fewer than seven wins
Granted I'm basing a lot of my optimism on 3rd & 4th rounders fulfilling their hype. BUT...last season we got 6 wins with 1/2 of the starters missing & a DC that had some major issues getting it together. I'll also add that I really believe McCarthy thought we were supposed to tank for a couple of games before somebody told him otherwise.
 

rambo2

Well-Known Member
Messages
17,866
Reaction score
13,367
Don't need to hear about how things can change over the season. This thread is not a wait and see approach. So play along if you like.

Currently, I predict the top three teams as of now are Tampa Bay, Seattle, and Green Bay (as long as AR plays). My top grouping's ceiling is here with legitimate shots at the SB. Their floor is to finish average (unless injury or non availability of their QB or top three players).

The second tier are teams that I can envision ending up challenging these top teams for their spots in my ranking but more likely are higher end playoff teams that just fall shy of the elite three. They are San Francisco, Los Angeles, and Minnesota. San Francisco is a team that I could envision making a dramatic turnaround with better health (their entire squad had injuries along with their QB).

My third tier is made up of teams that I predict are the rest of the middle tier (which is the largest group because of how closely I view these squads). Any have the potential of joining the second tier here but I just cannot envision any of these teams as tier one at this time. They are Arizona, Chicago, Dallas, New York, Washington, and New Orleans. Arizona is so odd with their moves and team setup (just difficult to predict their outcome).

Bottom tier teams are more in flux (coaching and of player movement) and much more difficult to envision even making the playoffs. Carolina, Detroit, Philadelphia, and Atlanta.

Since we are Cowboys fans, I will give you my thoughts on where I see the Cowboys' season and how they currently stack up. I can envision the Cowboys having a season record between 7 and 10 wins. I cannot really envision a much better or worse record.

Injuries aside from cowboys and opponents, I see them neck and neck with any of the tier 3 teams I mentioned. I would agree that the Cowboys offense is the best of the NFC East, but it almost entirely depends on the health of the offensive line. I predict some problems with availability along the line and play level from the top lineman when they actually play (with existing injuries).

I predict a better defensive unit, but one that has difficulties generating consistent pressure and consistent coverage units. A middle of the pack defense with a sometimes high flying offense is my prediction. If the Cowboys can get a 4-2 division record without being swept by anyone, then I can imagine a division title and playoff appearance.

That's pretty much it. Kinda just more sideways action though some here feel a division title is a major step up. I do not. The NFC East and NFC in general feels too oddball and not enough squads exist with the best run front offices and coaching staffs. There are no organizations like the Patriots, Ravens, Steelers, Chiefs in the conference.

I actually miss Andy Reid being in the same division. At least you could count on him making his squad a decent team for the most part.
You lost me at Seattle and Green Bay. It doesn't look good for those teams.
 

T-RO

Well-Known Member
Messages
14,824
Reaction score
16,341
Aaron Rogers and Russell Wilson have put themselves into positions where it will be *very* difficult to lead their team. On top of that GB and SEA did next to nothing to improve themselves this offseason.

TB, SF and maybe the Rams will be class of conference.

Aside from that I think Blitzen has the optics generally in focus.

NFC East will be slightly improved and I suspect WFT wins it--this time w/a winning record.
 

Fmart322

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,869
Reaction score
5,010
Cowboys will go 14-3.
Win the NFC east.
Get a bye.
Win the NFC.
win the super bowl.
Forget about their past underachieving ways. This team is for real.







Now wake up.
 
Top