Is Noah Brown the 1 WR?

mattjames2010 · Sep 27, 2022

blueblood70 said:
No hes Rushes blankie LOL there were at least 4 bombs, 1 missed in cinci game overthrew and 2 early on in the Gnats game where Lamb was wide open deep for big play and he dumps it down to Brown. thats the why it is sometimes like Dak looking for lamb over cooper etc Romo with Witten.

Lambs been open more than you think the last 2 games. rush isn't looking for him as much as brown, they have a rapport..

Yeah, well, it would help if Lamb wasn't inconsistent when Rush throws to him as well. Lamb hasn't helped himself.

JIMMYBUFFETT · Sep 27, 2022

This looked like such a disappointing unit at the start of the season. I scoffed at the idea of Lamb, Gallup, and Brown as your 1,2,3. Now I can't wait to see Lamb, Gallup, and Brown as their 1,2,3! I'm even mildly excited to see what Washington and Tolbert can bring.

AsthmaField · Sep 27, 2022

quickccc said:
I don't want him as a No.2. i'd still like to have a person who can present dangerous matchup problems, take the top off of a defense and threaten the entire field.
But if it's about a No. 3 and slot person, then maybe we can talk A Noah Brown then. .

Yeah, IMO his skill set is very nice to have in a 3rd/4th receiver. He’s perfect for that because he can come in and block like another TE in the run game.

He has turned into a real asset for Dallas… particularly considering what kind of rough and tumble run game they want.

Tyler Smith and Peters are just brutalizing defenders and having Brown over there blocking for the run game is really a plus.

By the 4th quarter, the Giants had seen enough of that Dallas OL.

blueblood70 · Sep 27, 2022

john van brocklin said:
Ceedee makes the circus catch then drops an easy one.
Brown is more consistent.
Give me Brown.

how about as a DC fan you take them all both , Gallups and wash coming back this Offense has not been 100% yet and will.. no need to choose

this gets old pollard and zeke , now Brown and CD, rush vs Dak, give it a rest, they are all part of the TEAM..we need them ALL.
cant wit to see

Dak with ALL them all Lamb, Schultz, Brown, CD, Gallup, & Washington..that was the pan and vison and i expect iot to be solid group. if brown stole snaps from anyone it will be Washington., might be leaving him longer on the IR for roster flex

NotForLong · Sep 27, 2022

xwalker said:
Brown has more yards on less targets with higher catch rate than CeeDee.

Season
Stat …. Brown ... CeeDee
Tgt ......... 21 ......... 34
Rec ....... 15 ......... 17
Yds ....... 213 ....... 191
TD ........... 1 ........... 1
Ctch% .. 71.40% ... 50.00%
Y/Tgt .... 10.1 ........ 5.6
Y/R ....... 14.2 ....... 11.2

Giants Game
Stat …. Brown ... CeeDee
Tgt ......... 7 ......... 12
Rec ....... 5 ......... 8
Yds ....... 54 ....... 87
TD ......... 0 ......... 1
Ctch% .. 71.40% ... 66.70%
Y/Tgt .... 7.71 ........ 7.25
Y/R ...... 10.8 ........ 10.88

No . . . bit he will make a great number #3

ChuckA1 · Sep 27, 2022

He's an excellent receiver and whether #1, 2 or 3, he seems to always get open and make the catch. Plus, he's a great blocker and has excelled on ST. He's my favorite receiver

nightrain · Sep 27, 2022

No, but he is a reliable guy you can depend upon to make a play.

tyke1doe · Sep 27, 2022

He's getting the job done, but he is in no way a No. 1 receiver.
But he doesn't have to be if everyone else is doing their jobs.

guag · Sep 27, 2022

youngjerryjones said:
dude trade for what lol... you have no one behind him... let him keep developing and getting better

Exactly it's not like we have an embarrassment of riches at the WR position lol. We need Noah.

MWH1967 · Sep 27, 2022

who cares? Really, it don't matter as long as they contribute.

I would rather have 3 #2's than a #1 and Jags

Why is it important to have a called #1?

Jarntt · Sep 27, 2022

Are we seriously asking if Brown is the #1 receiver over CeeDee because he’s got a few more yards through 3 games? Come on. Let’s start acting like we’ve watched an NFL season before. And the targets while being used incorrectly here should in fact make it crystal clear who the #1 is as should the coverage both have faced.

Doomsday101 · Sep 27, 2022

Frankly all I ask out of any of our WR, run the correct rout and make the play when the ball comes your way. Thus far Brown has done that, all he needs to do is keep it up.

CowboyRoy · Sep 27, 2022

xwalker said:
Brown has more yards on less targets with higher catch rate than CeeDee.

Season
Stat …. Brown ... CeeDee
Tgt ......... 21 ......... 34
Rec ....... 15 ......... 17
Yds ....... 213 ....... 191
TD ........... 1 ........... 1
Ctch% .. 71.40% ... 50.00%
Y/Tgt .... 10.1 ........ 5.6
Y/R ....... 14.2 ....... 11.2

Giants Game
Stat …. Brown ... CeeDee
Tgt ......... 7 ......... 12
Rec ....... 5 ......... 8
Yds ....... 54 ....... 87
TD ......... 0 ......... 1
Ctch% .. 71.40% ... 66.70%
Y/Tgt .... 7.71 ........ 7.25
Y/R ...... 10.8 ........ 10.88

Are you truly confused?

Daillest88 · Sep 27, 2022

He’s got them hands

Typhus · Sep 27, 2022

xwalker said:
Brown has more yards on less targets with higher catch rate than CeeDee.

Season
Stat …. Brown ... CeeDee
Tgt ......... 21 ......... 34
Rec ....... 15 ......... 17
Yds ....... 213 ....... 191
TD ........... 1 ........... 1
Ctch% .. 71.40% ... 50.00%
Y/Tgt .... 10.1 ........ 5.6
Y/R ....... 14.2 ....... 11.2

Giants Game
Stat …. Brown ... CeeDee
Tgt ......... 7 ......... 12
Rec ....... 5 ......... 8
Yds ....... 54 ....... 87
TD ......... 0 ......... 1
Ctch% .. 71.40% ... 66.70%
Y/Tgt .... 7.71 ........ 7.25
Y/R ...... 10.8 ........ 10.88

Noah is our Mohamed Sanu.

Typhus · Sep 27, 2022

mattjames2010 said:
Yeah, well, it would help if Lamb wasn't inconsistent when Rush throws to him as well. Lamb hasn't helped himself.

Lamb made up for it,, but quit smiling about mistakes CD,,

Reid1boys · Sep 27, 2022

I dont really care who is the "#1 WR." Make zero difference to me. I care about winning games and I dont care which players do the most to help the team accomplish that goal. I have zero loyalty to any player. I root for the team. Do I like certain players more than others? Yep... I like the players that do more than others.

G2 · Sep 27, 2022

Rush makes him better

Is Noah Brown the 1 WR?

mattjames2010

Well-Known Member

JIMMYBUFFETT

Skinwalker

AsthmaField

Outta bounds

blueblood70

Well-Known Member

NotForLong

Well-Known Member

ChuckA1

Well-Known Member

nightrain

Since 1971

tyke1doe

Well-Known Member

guag

Tertiary Adjunct of Unimatrix 01

MWH1967

The Cook

Jarntt

Well-Known Member

Doomsday101

Well-Known Member

CowboyRoy

Well-Known Member

Daillest88

Well-Known Member

Typhus

Captain Catfish

Typhus

Captain Catfish

Reid1boys

Well-Known Member

G2

Taco Engineer