Should Jason Witten Retire?

timb2 · Jan 22, 2018

It has been obvious for atleast 3 seasons that Witten has slowed down considerably. He will be 36 years old next season and a big contract and we have several free agents we could use that money on instead of TE holding on and on fumes and glory of his past. Rico Gathers I believed was held back this year because Garrett's love of and loyalty to Witten. just like Romo needed to get out of the way of the future ,Witten needs to hang up the cleats.

PJTHEDOORS · Jan 22, 2018

He can come off the bench. Retire, no.

Idgit · Jan 22, 2018

It hasn't been obvious to me.

What's obvious to me is that fans want him gone because they do the math and know he's on the back end of a great career. What's not obvious is the drop-off people like to refer to. He looks as slow as he ever was to me, and still blocks effectively. Catches anything that gets near him. False starts inexplicably when you don't want him to. Pretty much business-as-usual for him.

John813 · Jan 22, 2018

Need to get a replacement first.
Unless you think Rico/Hanna/Swaim can do what he does on the field.
IMO, draft a TE this year to learn the game behind Witten.

zrinkill · Jan 22, 2018

What a stupid thread.

nightrain · Jan 22, 2018

They have not found anyone to replace him yet. Spent plenty to do so. Can't let go of your most productive player at a position without a contingency. They do need to get younger and more athletic at the TE position.

Verdammung · Jan 22, 2018

In other news, Jason Witten has been named as an alternate to the pro-bowl today...

Pants · Jan 22, 2018

If they didn’t force-feed him on 95% of offensive snaps I would say he has no business retiring. I could see 60% snap count for him or at least less than “all” and then he needs to suit up. But, if the expectation is near “all”, then time to go

Northern_Cowboy · Jan 23, 2018

At this point who could we sign an a FA or draft with a high enough pick who could possibly beat him out next training camp? JW can still start in the league and will until he proves that he can't anymore or decides on his own to retire

zrinkill · Jan 23, 2018

timb2 said:
Should 2018 Pro Bowler Jason Witten Retire?

Fixed that for you.

big dog cowboy · Jan 23, 2018

timb2 said:
It has been obvious for atleast 3 seasons that Witten has slowed down considerably.

Yea because his first 12 years in the league he was known as a speed demon.

atlantacowboy · Jan 23, 2018

Yeah, lets retire our pro bowl TE. That should improve the offense.

fairviewfarmer · Jan 23, 2018

timb2 said:
It has been obvious for atleast 3 seasons that Witten has slowed down considerably. He will be 36 years old next season and a big contract and we have several free agents we could use that money on instead of TE holding on and on fumes and glory of his past. Rico Gathers I believed was held back this year because Garrett's love of and loyalty to Witten. just like Romo needed to get out of the way of the future ,Witten needs to hang up the cleats.

In a word, Yes.

timb2 · Jan 23, 2018

If you guys could not see that Witten's BFF was going to make sure Witten never got replaced. 3 TEs drafted in the 2nd round Fasano I can understand,but Martellus Bennett never got a ball thrown to him because of Romo,and I remember Escobar at one point had more TDs than Witten in the season and then the last 9 games never saw a pass thrown his way from Romo.. Rico Gathers has to sit out all year because of a concussion??? No team politics were playing a part. When the Cowboys want to win a Superbowl the politics have to stop. Witten will be 36 years old and you have a TE in Gathers than can stretch the field and be a very special TE and he is getting held back because of POLITICS.

timb2 · Jan 23, 2018

Jerrah would still be playing Romo if Dak hadn't just been such a breath of fresh air in 2016.Prescott was not suppose to be pushing Romo for that spot and Jerrah wanted so bad to bench Prescott for Romo but knew the team would revolt againist it.

cowboy_ron · Jan 24, 2018

I know he has no speed but he currently has the best hands on offense......let that soak in.

jsb357 · Jan 24, 2018

Unless he'll take a pay cut...

CF74 · Jan 25, 2018

At least cut the reps by 40-60%. We need somebody with a bit more speed but at least he still catches the ball before he goes down...

zrinkill · Jan 25, 2018

timb2 said:
he is getting held back because of POLITICS.

What a stupid post

CATCH17 · Jan 25, 2018

I don't think he needs to retire but we need someone more dynamic then him to get down the seems and make plays downfield.

Should Jason Witten Retire?

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Fattening up

Well-Known Member

Cowboy Fan

Since 1971

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Cowboy Fan

THE BIG DOG

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

You Can't Fix Stupid

Well-Known Member

Vet Min Plus

Cowboy Fan

1st Round Pick