2008 NFC East Comparison of QB Ratings, Home/Away & in the 4th QTR

[Gryphon]

NFC Leaders QB Rating, Home
(3.125 Att/Game)

Rank Name Team Games Rating
6 Tony Romo DAL 13 101.5
8 Donovan McNabb PHI 16 98.9
12 Eli Manning NYG 16 86.4
14 Jason Campbell WAS 16 80.2

NFC Leaders QB Rating, Away
(3.125 Att/Game)

Rank Name Team Games Rating
3 Jason Campbell WAS 16 88.8
5 Eli Manning NYG 16 86.5
12 Tony Romo DAL 13 79.1
16 Donovan McNabb PHI 16 75.9

NFC Leaders QB Rating, 4th Quarter
(3.125 Att/Game)

Rank Name Team Games Rating
1 Tony Romo DAL 13 114.7
7 Eli Manning NYG 16 93.8
8 Donovan McNabb PHI 16 93.2
13 Jason Campbell WAS 16 84.1

 

[NextGenBoys]

Boy that quarterback of ours sure is terrible

 

[dadymat]

Boy that quarterback of ours sure is terrible

yeah he sux......

dont look now....here come the "he aint won in December crowd"...........:bang2:

 

[CATCH17]

If Jaq Reeves didn't suck so bad and Patrick Crayton didn't have the all time blunder we wouldn't even be questioning Romo's post season play.

 

[Yakuza Rich]

Whether any of us like it or not, Romo is going to generally be known as a choke artist/can't win come December until he wins at least a few playoff games and doesn't play poorly. If he learns to protect the ball, not only from an interception standpoint, but a fumbling standpoint, he'll get those playoff victories. But if he continues to be careless, he'll wind up with that choker label. His choice, IMO.



3JACK

 

[CATCH17]

Whether any of us like it or not, Romo is going to generally be known as a choke artist/can't win come December until he wins at least a few playoff games and doesn't play poorly. If he learns to protect the ball, not only from an interception standpoint, but a fumbling standpoint, he'll get those playoff victories. But if he continues to be careless, he'll wind up with that choker label. His choice, IMO.


3JACK

Its not that easy.

He isn't the single reason we are losing these games and in many cases he is the single reason we even are in those games to begin with.

The only game that I can put completely on him off the top of my head is the Pitt game this past year.

But all quarterbacks are going to do single handedly lose games in this league.

 

[Idgit]

Whether any of us like it or not, Romo is going to generally be known as a choke artist/can't win come December until he wins at least a few playoff games and doesn't play poorly. If he learns to protect the ball, not only from an interception standpoint, but a fumbling standpoint, he'll get those playoff victories. But if he continues to be careless, he'll wind up with that choker label. His choice, IMO.

3JACK

Please. You get a label when enough people believe something. It doesn't mean the label fits. He has no choice in the matter, either way. I'd also dispute that he's generally viewed as a choke artist. He's generally viewed as a very good QB, there's a minority of the Dallas fanbase who thinks he's a choker.

In any event, Romo doesn't play poorly in big games, and his TD/Int ratio is ok. Fumbles were a problem last year, but so was the broken hand.

 

[jobberone]

In the end people forget who lost the SuperBowl. They forget who had and didn't have a bad or good game.

And they may remember the big plays and comebacks.

What they remember is did you win.

In the end it's as Idgit said. It's the perception.

 

[Idgit]

In the end people forget who lost the SuperBowl. They forget who had and didn't have a bad or good game.

And they may remember the big plays and comebacks.

What they remember is did you win.

In the end it's as Idgit said. It's the perception.

There was a perception that Kurt Warner was washed up, not too long ago, too. And that Jason Campbell was going to be a good QB in this league.