2014 vs 2015 Plus/Minus

xwalker

Well-Known Member
Messages
57,202
Reaction score
64,709
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
I was just thinking about what the team as lost and gained this offseason. Some gains were very small, incremental gains and other are big obvious gains.

If I look at the Green Bay playoff loss, then I see 1 big loss (Murray) and 2 big additions (Hardy and Jones). The lack of pass rush and Sterling Moore were the primary reasons for that loss other than the officiating.

Negative:
Murray gone – This is negative, but he did have over 800 yards before first contact.
Parnell gone – They’ve added depth on OL, but RT could take a step back with Free gimpy and no experienced backups.
Carter – Not really a negative. Hitchens had already surpassed him on the roster.
Durant – Lee more than offsets Durant who had as many injury issues as Lee.
Selvie - Not really a loss, IMO.
Spencer - Didn't do much in 2014 while returning from major injury issue.

Positive:
Add Hardy – A top 3 and possibly the #1 4-3 DE in the NFL.
Add Jones – Replacing Sterling Moore with Jones is big.
Add Gregory – Incredible talent to be the #4 DE.
Add Collins – Bonus depth.
Add Green – Maybe depending on recover from surgery.
Add Wilson - Similar to Hitchens.
Add Russell
Add redshirt Gardner
Add redshirt Whaley.
Add Weems (IR in 2014)
Add White – Could be a big upgrade at the 4th CB position of 3rd Safety position.
Add three 7th round picks. – Could add depth.
Add Brinkley – Legit NFL backup. Rarely injured.
Add Gachkar – Legit NFL backup. Rarely injured.
Add McFadden – At a minimum he is a terrific pass blocking RB. His ypc jumped significantly in the games in 2014 when he was the backup so that should be a good role for him this year.

Romo much healthier. He could barely function at the beginning of 2014.
Martin in his 2nd year
Fred in his 3rd year
Leary in his 3rd year starting
Wilcox in his 2nd year as a full time starter.
Lee is back.
Hitchens in his 2nd year after 11 starts as a rookie and out-playing Carter.
RoMc with experience in the scheme and more off-season time with the team.
Legit depth at LB with Brinkley, Gachkar, Rivers over Cam Lawrence and Keith Smith.
Mincey in his 2nd year in the scheme.
T. Crawford is in his 2nd year at the 3tech DT position.
Carr was much better at the end of the season. Maybe they figured out his issues.
Escobar reported to be much bigger.
D. Lawrence reported to be much bigger and is healthy. In his 2nd season.
T. McClain healthy.
Bishop now has NFL experience.
Backup QB – Can’t be worse. More experience in the scheme for both backups.
Ryan Willliams – A year practicing the scheme and was coached up on pass blocking.
Randle – Was getting into minor trouble twice last year actually a good thing for him?
Multiple other players got experience in the scheme that are competing for the final spot on the DL (J. Crawford, Edwards, Coleman, etc.).

Linehan in his 2nd season with the team as OC.
Marinelli in his 2nd season as the DC.


Recap:
Yes, Losing Murray is a concern, but considering that he had over 800 yards before contact would indicate that other RBs should have success behind this OL.

Hardy is a huge addition. Yes, he’ll miss the first 4 games, but last season it was the playoffs where the pass rush the most needed. With Hardy on the team, the Cowboys likely win the GB game when the 1 legged Rodgers was rarely touched.

Jones is also a huge addition when you consider that he is replacing Sterling Moore who got torched in the GB playoff game. If Jones and Hardy had both been on the team for the GB playoff game, then the probably of a win would have dramatically increased.

The 2014 team had many very young players like Martin, Wilcox, etc. playing key roles. All of those players got a year of experience plus the experience of 2 playoffs games. This could be a bigger upgrade than the new additions.
 

perrykemp

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,503
Reaction score
9,274
If I look at the Green Bay playoff loss, then I see 1 big loss (Murray) and 2 big additions (Hardy and Jones). The lack of pass rush and Sterling Moore were the primary reasons for that loss other than the officiating.

Question for you xwalker -- did Sterling Moore all of sudden suck in that game OR was it that he happened to be a decent #3 CB who was forced to match up with a emerging stud #3 WR in Davante Adams who I've seen all sorts of articles this off-season speculating that Adams might be the <best> WR the Packer's roster (ahead of Nelson and Cobb) by the time all is said and done this season.

I do think that drafting of Jones, bringing in White, and even the return of Claiborne as CB4 or CB5 does dramatically improve the backfield and should go a long way to balancing out the Packers passing attack <IF> it comes to another Cowboys/Packers playoff game.
 

perrykemp

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,503
Reaction score
9,274
Positive:
Add Hardy – A top 3 and possibly the #1 4-3 DE in the NFL.
Add Jones – Replacing Sterling Moore with Jones is big.
Add Gregory – Incredible talent to be the #4 DE.
Add Collins – Bonus depth.
Add Green – Maybe depending on recover from surgery.
Add Wilson - Similar to Hitchens.
Add Russell
Add redshirt Gardner
Add redshirt Whaley.
Add Weems (IR in 2014)
Add White – Could be a big upgrade at the 4th CB position of 3rd Safety position.
Add three 7th round picks. – Could add depth.
Add Brinkley – Legit NFL backup. Rarely injured.
Add Gachkar – Legit NFL backup. Rarely injured.
Add McFadden – At a minimum he is a terrific pass blocking RB. His ypc jumped significantly in the games in 2014 when he was the backup so that should be a good role for him this year.

This is a tremendous set of additions -- on paper easily in the NFL this offseason.
 

StarBoyz83

Well-Known Member
Messages
17,434
Reaction score
11,978
As a whole team I think we are better. Randle and McFadden should get 1800 yards. We were close last year but I felt that Seattle and green bay were better.
 

Fontaine

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,645
Reaction score
3,644
At this point last year, I wasn't a fan of our team on paper (mainly the defense). But I was glad I had missed that prediction. Looking at 2015, I really like what the was assembled this off season and think we can do some damage. Hopefully I get this prediction right this year.
 

xwalker

Well-Known Member
Messages
57,202
Reaction score
64,709
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
Question for you xwalker -- did Sterling Moore all of sudden suck in that game OR was it that he happened to be a decent #3 CB who was forced to match up with a emerging stud #3 WR in Davante Adams who I've seen all sorts of articles this off-season speculating that Adams might be the <best> WR the Packer's roster (ahead of Nelson and Cobb) by the time all is said and done this season.

I do think that drafting of Jones, bringing in White, and even the return of Claiborne as CB4 or CB5 does dramatically improve the backfield and should go a long way to balancing out the Packers passing attack <IF> it comes to another Cowboys/Packers playoff game.

I think a big part of it was Adams. The Cowboys had been trying to keep Moore on the #3 WR each week. Most #3 WRs have limitations, but Adams looks like he could have been a #2 on most teams as a rookie.

It also helps Adams having Rodgers as his QB.

Sterling Moore over achieved in most games. He is 5'9-1/2 and is not fast (4.54 forty). Normally, a CB is either big or really fast. When they are neither big or fast, it's probably going to be a struggle for them to play in the NFL.

It also didn't help that the pass rush failed. Despite barely being able to walk, Rodgers was not getting much pressure.
 

waving monkey

Well-Known Member
Messages
15,540
Reaction score
14,930
It's kinda a cliche to say we will play better the second half of the season
But there are some real additions as starters and back ups
rookie getting it together
I like thinking that Rod's keep it simple defense will really click it all together after the first half.
Going 4/4 at minium the first half then building that long stretch of wins at the right time.
 

jazzcat22

Staff member
Messages
81,310
Reaction score
102,240
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
Great write up.

Along with Hardy missing the 1st 4 games, add Ro Mac being suspended those 4 games also as a minus. But game 5, this turns into a big plus.
I think we will be fine at RB. McFadden will be a pleasant surprise. I equate this with Ro at this point last year. Just about everyone was dogging him. Not as many dogging on DMC, but seems quite a few. This is a plus IMO. I predict he becomes the starter, and does very well. May not put up the numbers Murray did, but Murray himself would have a hard time repeating that performance.

KR / PR replacement is yet to be seen. someone needs to emerge. I am not concerned as much on losing Harris here, as I am losing him on ST's. But isn't that is why Gachkar was brought in.
Harris dropped off in his returns last year, so can anyone be any worse? Possibly but TC will soon show us something, plus or minus.

A lot of optimism with all the players from IR returning as well as rookies for some much needed competition in TC. The biggest plus is we haven't had this deep of a roster since the 90's.

11 days, including today until 1st practice....getting closer fellow fans....
 

itsaboat

Well-Known Member
Messages
497
Reaction score
1,956
Question for you xwalker -- did Sterling Moore all of sudden suck in that game OR was it that he happened to be a decent #3 CB who was forced to match up with a emerging stud #3 WR in Davante Adams who I've seen all sorts of articles this off-season speculating that Adams might be the <best> WR the Packer's roster (ahead of Nelson and Cobb) by the time all is said and done this season..

Rodgers was complementing Scandrick and saying things about Carr in a pre playoff game interview. When GB did their game planning I'm sure they guessed Scandrick would take Cobb and Carr would take Nelson leaving Moore to cover Adams. Moore is 5'9.5" ~200 vs Adams 6'1" and ~220. They knew Adams was bigger and stronger than Moore so Rodgers took advantage of that match up. Most teams don't have a #3 WR of that size and quality which helped Moore have a great season (didn't give up a TD). Having Jones who can match Adams size (any bigger WR) or even White and Claiborne as #3 CBs should improve the match up when we play GB this season.
 

xwalker

Well-Known Member
Messages
57,202
Reaction score
64,709
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
Great write up.

Along with Hardy missing the 1st 4 games, add Ro Mac being suspended those 4 games also as a minus. But game 5, this turns into a big plus.
I think we will be fine at RB. McFadden will be a pleasant surprise. I equate this with Ro at this point last year. Just about everyone was dogging him. Not as many dogging on DMC, but seems quite a few. This is a plus IMO. I predict he becomes the starter, and does very well. May not put up the numbers Murray did, but Murray himself would have a hard time repeating that performance.

KR / PR replacement is yet to be seen. someone needs to emerge. I am not concerned as much on losing Harris here, as I am losing him on ST's. But isn't that is why Gachkar was brought in.
Harris dropped off in his returns last year, so can anyone be any worse? Possibly but TC will soon show us something, plus or minus.

A lot of optimism with all the players from IR returning as well as rookies for some much needed competition in TC. The biggest plus is we haven't had this deep of a roster since the 90's.

11 days, including today until 1st practice....getting closer fellow fans....

Yes, guys like Gachkar can replace Harris on coverage teams. The big benefit of Harris was that his ability to both be the returner and play coverage teams made it easier to put together the 46 man game day roster. If they have a dedicated returner that does nothing else, it will put a strain on the 46.

Lucky Whitehead might be the best returner, but he probably can't play on coverage teams or as a WR this year. PR is a bigger issue than KR, IMO. They need somebody that will not fumble on PR. Beasley could probably do it, but they might not want to risk him getting injured. Dunbar has done some KR and they reported he was fielding punts in OTAs. He also plays other positions on ST and would have a role on offense.

I didn't put RoMc on the negative list because he missed 4 games last season which would be a wash if he just missed the 1st four this season.

In regards to the starting RB, I have no idea if it will be McFadden or Randle. I think both have the physical ability to do it.
 
Top