CFZ 2022 Post Wk 14: QB Combined Statistical Ranking

DFWJC

DFWJC

Well-Known Member
Messages
59,342
Reaction score
48,190
I'll repeat the intro from previous weeks....
I did this the last few years.
It pretty much delivers the league MVP every year.

Don't get too worked up over this. Just data.

Combine and average the QBs' rank of the following two categories and tally.
  1. Differential: Total TDs (Passing/Rushing TDs ) - Total Turnovers ....This reduces bus-driving a little bit
  2. Standard NFL Passer Rating

This is where we stand after 14 weeks (13 games)

  1. Hurts (MVP candidate.....his plus 27 Differential is great)
  2. Mahomes (MVP candidate.)
  3. Tagovailoa (MVP candidate??)
  4. Burrow
  5. G Smith
  6. Garoppolo ( I may remove him in a week or two)
  7. Allen
  8. Goff (rising)
  9. Herbert
  10. Lawrence (rising up the charts...hopefully we bring him down to earth this week)
  11. Cousins (rising)
  12. Jackson
  13. Brady
  14. Rodgers
  15. Dalton
  16. Tannehill
  17. D Jones
  18. Carr
  19. Prescott
  20. Fields
  21. Mariotta
  22. Murray
  23. Brissett
  24. Heinike
  25. R Wilson
  26. Stafford
  27. M Jones
  28. Rush
  29. Mayfield
  30. Z Wilson
  31. Mills
  32. Ryan
  33. Pickett
Players not included due to not of enough games played:
Darnold, Purdy, White, K Allen, Huntley, Rypien, Trubisky, Watson, McCoy.
 
GoldenR

GoldenR

Well-Known Member
Messages
3,639
Reaction score
2,711
DFWJC said:
I'll repeat the intro from previous weeks....
I did this the last few years.
It pretty much delivers the league MVP every year.

Don't get too worked up over this. Just data.

Combine and average the QBs' rank of the following two categories and tally.
  1. Differential: Total TDs (Passing/Rushing TDs ) - Total Turnovers ....This reduces bus-driving a little bit
  2. Standard NFL Passer Rating

This is where we stand after 14 weeks (13 games)

  1. Hurts (MVP candidate.....his plus 27 Differential is great)
  2. Mahomes (MVP candidate.)
  3. Tagovailoa (MVP candidate??)
  4. Burrow
  5. G Smith
  6. Garoppolo ( I may remove him in a week or two)
  7. Allen
  8. Goff (rising)
  9. Herbert
  10. Lawrence (rising up the charts...hopefully we bring him down to earth this week)
  11. Cousins (rising)
  12. Jackson
  13. Brady
  14. Rodgers
  15. Dalton
  16. Tannehill
  17. D Jones
  18. Carr
  19. Prescott
  20. Fields
  21. Mariotta
  22. Murray
  23. Brissett
  24. Heinike
  25. R Wilson
  26. Stafford
  27. M Jones
  28. Rush
  29. Mayfield
  30. Z Wilson
  31. Mills
  32. Ryan
  33. Pickett
Players not included due to not of enough games played:
Darnold, Purdy, White, K Allen, Huntley, Rypien, Trubisky, Watson, McCoy.
Click to expand...
Perfect definition of mediocre, and look at the teams he has played against. All under 500 I believe. oh yeah the Vikings. sorry.
 
DFWJC

DFWJC

Well-Known Member
Messages
59,342
Reaction score
48,190
We have an opportunity to halt Trevor Lawrence's 5 game streak of no ints this week.
The dude appears to have turned the corner. I think he had 4 TDs and no turnovers last week
Hopefully, we make him regress some this week
:flagwave:
 
DFWJC

DFWJC

Well-Known Member
Messages
59,342
Reaction score
48,190
GoldenR said:
Perfect definition of mediocre, and look at the teams he has played against. All under 500 I believe. oh yeah the Vikings. sorry.
Click to expand...
Still 4 games to go, but if he finishes this low ( I honestly assume he will not) it would be the lowest a legit Cowboy starting QB (not backup due to injury) has finished since Quincy Carter in 2003.
:omg:

To be fair, he's only played 8 games. If you have a positive differential you should move up. Not sure about the passer rating though. Quantity doesn't necessarily help or hurt that.
He's 22nd in differential and 14th in passer rating. (19th in QBR if anyone follows that stat)
 
noshame

noshame

I'm not dead yet......
Messages
13,713
Reaction score
11,844
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
I don't really care about Lawrence, I'm sure Quinn and the lads will challenge him.
What we need to do is figure out where we get a QB next year. I think we need to grab a 1st rounder. Let him challenge the Dakster.
Nobody can seriously support a QB who has failed against sub par compilation.
You can blame KM, but he IS LIMITED in what he can do.
I had Daks jersey as my avatar for 2 years. Then the flaws began to show.
Thec cat is out of the proverbial bag.
Every defense in the nfl sees Dak's weaknesses, I'm afraid as the competition stiffens in the coming weeks it will become obvious.
Our only hope is to move Dak around in an effort to give receivers 5-6 seconds to get WIDE open. Even then, he still has to make throws.
Good luck to us.
 
DFWJC

DFWJC

Well-Known Member
Messages
59,342
Reaction score
48,190
So I looked at th last 20 years and how well this Combined Stat thing predicts the legue MVPs

I list the year and the winner of the Combines stat. Then yes or no if they won MVP
Year__Combined Stat Winner (MVP?)
2021__Rodgers (Yes MVP)
2020__Rodgers (Yes MVP)
2019__Jackson (Yes MVP)
2018__Mahomes (Yes MVP)
2017__Brady (Yes MVP)
2016__Ryan (Yes MVP)
2015__Wilson/Brady tied (NO...Newton got MVP but had great year too)
2014__Rodgers/Romo tied (Yes Rodgers MVP)
2013__P Manning (Yes MVP)
2012__Rodgers (RB Peterson MVP, so n/a)
2011__Rodgers (Yes MVP)
2010__Brady (Yes MVP)
2009__Brees/Favre tie (NO Manning)
2008__Rivers (NO Manning)...River FAR better..Manning bias...lol
2007__Brady (Yes MVP)
2006__P Manning (RB Thomlinson MVP..so n/a)
2005__P Manning/Palmer (RB Alexander MVP..so n/a)
2004__P Manning (Yes MVP)
2003__McNair/Manning (Yes co MVPs)
2002__Gannon (Yes MVP)
 
Cowboys0988

Cowboys0988

Well-Known Member
Messages
390
Reaction score
477
The Good news... All the best QBs or most are in the AFC.. Mahomes...Burrow.. Herbert... Allen....Jackson... Lawrence...Tua is one hit away from his head falling off... Burrow & Herbert are gonna be special though.
 

Swagger

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,979
Reaction score
7,706
DFWJC said:
So I looked at th last 20 years and how well this Combined Stat thing predicts the legue MVPs

I list the year and the winner of the Combines stat. Then yes or no if they won MVP
Year__Combined Stat Winner (MVP?)
2021__Rodgers (Yes MVP)
2020__Rodgers (Yes MVP)
2019__Jackson (Yes MVP)
2018__Mahomes (Yes MVP)
2017__Brady (Yes MVP)
2016__Ryan (Yes MVP)
2015__Wilson/Brady tied (NO...Newton got MVP but had great year too)
2014__Rodgers/Romo tied (Yes Rodgers MVP)
2013__P Manning (Yes MVP)
2012__Rodgers (RB Peterson MVP, so n/a)
2011__Rodgers (Yes MVP)
2010__Brady (Yes MVP)
2009__Brees/Favre tie (NO Manning)
2008__Rivers (NO Manning)...River FAR better..Manning bias...lol
2007__Brady (Yes MVP)
2006__P Manning (RB Thomlinson MVP..so n/a)
2005__P Manning/Palmer (RB Alexander MVP..so n/a)
2004__P Manning (Yes MVP)
2003__McNair/Manning (Yes co MVPs)
2002__Gannon (Yes MVP)
Click to expand...
Wilson really should have been MVP in 2015. Cam played on a better team and that's what won it for him but Wilson played lights out.
Shout out to Romo in 2014
 

pansophy

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,006
Reaction score
4,113
You could save yourself the trouble and just look at QBR. Dak is 19th in QBR as well, though the top guys are in a slightly different order
 
FVSTONE

FVSTONE

Well-Known Member
Messages
3,578
Reaction score
2,681
DFWJC said:
We have an opportunity to halt Trevor Lawrence's 5 game streak of no ints this week.
The dude appears to have turned the corner. I think he had 4 TDs and no turnovers last week
Hopefully, we make him regress some this week
:flagwave:
Click to expand...
Trevor rolls against our 4th rd, less than mediocre QB! Jacksonville will succeed because of all the 3 and outs that Prescot will have a hand in! Look for Parsons to implode after Jacksonville takes it to his defense...................We may witness a first, watching Parsons beating Prescot to a pulp on the sidelines because of his lousy play and more importantly all the interceptions he's going to throw..............LOL!!!!!!
 
DFWJC

DFWJC

Well-Known Member
Messages
59,342
Reaction score
48,190
FVSTONE said:
Trevor rolls against our 4th rd, less than mediocre QB! Jacksonville will succeed because of all the 3 and outs that Prescot will have a hand in! Look for Parsons to implode after Jacksonville takes it to his defense...................We may witness a first, watching Parsons beating Prescot to a pulp on the sidelines because of his lousy play and more importantly all the interceptions he's going to throw..............LOL!!!!!!
Click to expand...
Hard liquor on an empty stomach will do it every time.
Take some aspirin before you crash tonight!
 
DFWJC

DFWJC

Well-Known Member
Messages
59,342
Reaction score
48,190
pansophy said:
You could save yourself the trouble and just look at QBR. Dak is 19th in QBR as well, though the top guys are in a slightly different order
Click to expand...
I hear you.
Still, QBR doesn't work as well than this combo overall, imo.... especially when we're trying to pick the MVP

QBR by itself can "occasionally" spit out some really weird results at times.
I mean, in 2017 QBR had Case Keenum as the best or 2nd best QB in the entire NFL.
:laugh:bizarre
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top