A Little Perspective While Looking at Coaches (fun, not to be taken too seriously)

Chuck 54

Well-Known Member
Messages
22,089
Reaction score
14,387
Jon Gruden's lifetime record in the NFL:
95 wins...81 losses (.540 %)...averages 8.6 wins per year

Playoffs...5 wins, 4 losses

5 seasons with 8-8 or losing records
2 seasons at 9-7
4 seasons at 10-6 or better

11 seasons in Oakland & TB...1 SB Championship


Bill Cowher's lifetime record in the NFL:

149 wins...90 losses (.623%)...averages 9.9 wins per year

Playoffs...12 wins, 9 losses

4 losing seasons + 2 (9-7) seasons
9 significant winning seasons

15 years in Pittsburgh...1 SB Championship (Cowboys fans aren't that patient)

That's 26 years for two NFL Champions (Are Cowboys fans that patient?)

It's not as easy as it seems.


Just for Fun

Wade Phillips Lifetime Record in the NFL:


82 wins...59 losses (.581%)...averages 9.3 wins per season

Playoffs...1 win, 5 losses

1 (8-8) season...Buffalo + 1 losing (7-9) season...Denver
1 winning season (9-7)...Denver
2 winning seasons (10-6, 11-5)...Buffalo
3 winning seasons (13-3, 9-7, 11-5)...Dallas

You have to feel a little sorry for the guy's bad luck sometimes. He went 10-6 in Buffalo and finished 3rd in his division, and the year he took Buffalo to 11-5, that was only good for 2nd in the division...haha.

Not defending Wade Phillips in any way, but it's not an easy job to win anywhere as Gruden's and Cowher's records will attest.

Gruden was a head coach for five years before winning a SB with someone else's team...fired twice.

Cowher was the head coach in Pittsburgh for 14 years before he won a SB, and he followed that great season with 8-8 and retirement the very next season. He missed the playoffs entirely for 5 of his final 9 seasons, yet Tomlin took the same team and won right after him...but people think he's a football god?!

It's a funny game, boys, and winning championships, even with the great defenses and running games, etc. that Cowher had in Pittsburg isn't easy.

14 years before winning despite having one of the most stable and supportive jobs in the NFL. I wouldn't begin to put Wade in either of these guys' shoes because he has struggled in the playoffs and hasn't won anything, but it's a little unfair after 3 winning seasons in Dallas and making the playoffs 2-3 years to call him such an idiot after a poor start this year. While no one was happy with the loss to Minny in the playoffs, most fans around here and in the media were finally giving Wade Phillips mad props after last year's December and two convincing wins over Philly with a playoff loss.

He may not be in the same class as Gruden or Cowher, but if Cowher didn't win a championship in the first 3-4 years and missed the playoffs a couple of times, Cowboys fans would likely be calling him a has-been and looking for another coach...much less waiting with their owner for 14 seasons. :eek:

It's a hard game to play, and a hard game to coach, but mostly it's a hard game in which to win consistently and you only have a 3% chance of winning a championship in any given year.

In Dallas we did it the first time by hiring a smart young coach and being patient with him for many years; the second time we did it by catching lightning in a bottle with a former college coach who found the right players at the right time, but was never able to do it anywhere else.

We all want that lightning in the bottle again, but maybe we should hire a smart young coach and give him some time to get it right.

...just sayin'...

Oh yeah, the Wade stats were just for a fun comparison as he's had short, difficult stints everywhere before coming to Dallas, but his stats will take a big hit with this season. :)
 
Tom Landry:

250 wins, 162 losses, 6 ties...(.607%)

Playoffs: 20 wins, 16 losses...(55%)

29 years as coach of the Cowboys...2 SB champions
 
Jimmy Johnson:

9 seasons, Dallas and Miami

80 wins, 64 losses...(55.6%)

Playoffs: 9-4 (69%)

2 losing seasons, 1 (8-8), 2 (9-7)

Made trips to the playoffs 6 of 9 seasons, but twice did it with 9-7 records.
 
Sorry, you can make your pathetic attempts to defend Wade Phillips all you want, but all you're proving is that he's a pathetic coach when it counts, and Gruden and Cowher weren't. Teams will be lining up to hire Gruden or Cowher this offseason, and none of them will even consider Wade Phiilips after he's fired (this off season, nor any to come).
 
Double Trouble;3657082 said:
Sorry, you can make your pathetic attempts to defend Wade Phillips all you want, but all you're proving is that he's a pathetic coach when it counts, and Gruden and Cowher weren't. Teams will be lining up to hire Gruden or Cowher this offseason, and none of them will even consider Wade Phiilips after he's fired (this off season, nor any to come).

Guess you didn't read very carefully...Wade will go...Wade should go...Gruden and Cowher, however, have done nothing exceptional that indicates they'd be an answer in Dallas where we are not willing to endure mediocrity even from a HOF coach.

Try reading it again, especially the part where Wade is not in the same category as Gruden or Cowher because he's never won anything and has a lousy playoff record. This thread is NOT about Wade Phillips...it IS about the need to be realistic when hiring his replacement next offseason and about being patient with a smart, young coach...not firing him if he is up and down for a few years. No one's been rushing to hire Gruden...look at his record...he's pedestrian at best. Cowher had a lot of winning seasons, even though he struggled to win 1 championship in all those years, so he will be in demand.

We won't wait 14 years like Pittsburgh did for Cowher to win a title, but we shouldn't expect it to happen overnight either.

Personally, I'm not in favor of hiring any old retreads...didn't work with Parcells and probably won't work with Cowher either. I'd prefer a smart, young coach with some fire in his belly...don't be shocked if Singletary gets an interview after he gets fired...that would scare me, but Jerry might look for a guy who can be a figurehead and instill a work ethic, even though he'd have to hire other coaches to actually run the offense and defense.
 
CATCH17;3657089 said:
Dave Campo for 2011 season.

Funny...like most other fans, I like Campo, but I'm ready to see him OUT of Dallas. It's time to get some new blood at most of the positions as well as at the head.
 
wayne motley;3657006 said:
Bill Cowher's lifetime record in the NFL:

149 wins...90 losses (.623%)...averages 9.9 wins per year

Playoffs...12 wins, 9 losses

4 losing seasons + 2 (9-7) seasons
9 significant winning seasons

15 years in Pittsburgh...1 SB Championship (Cowboys fans aren't that patient)

wayne motley;3657063 said:
Tom Landry:

250 wins, 162 losses, 6 ties...(.607%)

Playoffs: 20 wins, 16 losses...(55%)

29 years as coach of the Cowboys...2 SB champions


Well, Everyone loves Landry. And he has the same Yr/SB Win ratio as Cowher yet everyone is so against Cowher.... I know its because he Coached the Stealers but still....

Ill take 9.9 wins per year on AVG with the chance to go to the Superbowl over some ones OC/DC or a College coach who wont do crap in the NFL
 
I could live with Cowher as head coach, but frankly I'm not sure this team really needs another guy like him. It's not like this team wasn't tough last year when it turned on the jets through December and twice against the Eagles.

Personally, I'd love to take a young college coach with NFL experience...a guy who's won at a school where you shouldn't win, a guy who's taken a prestigious academic university and made them a big, strong, tough team that can run the ball in their conference, a guy with NFL background as a QB.

That's right...him...I'd like to grow with a young coach who can relate to the new generation of players.

Jim Harbaugh
 
Holmgren

157-100-0 (Regular Season)
13-11 (Postseason)
170-111-0 (Overall)

Won one superbowl. Has been to three. Shouldve won the third sb with seattle had the refs not given it to pitt.
 
locked&loaded;3665285 said:
Holmgren

157-100-0 (Regular Season)
13-11 (Postseason)
170-111-0 (Overall)

Won one superbowl. Has been to three. Shouldve won the third sb with seattle had the refs not given it to pitt.

He runs the Cleveland operation. He won't give up a position like that to come here and just be a head coach.

We'd have to give him something more or at least laterally with Cleveland's blessing for him to come here.

Your signature is absolutely hilarious!
 
AKATheRake;3665464 said:
He runs the Cleveland operation. He won't give up a position like that to come here and just be a head coach.

We'd have to give him something more or at least laterally with Cleveland's blessing for him to come here.

Your signature is absolutely hilarious!

A kid can dream.
 

Staff online

Forum statistics

Threads
474,555
Messages
14,545,411
Members
24,212
Latest member
JerryJonesSupporter
Back
Top