Al Michaels Micro Analysis again!

aikemirv

Well-Known Member
Messages
16,405
Reaction score
9,999
What is up with that. Last week on the Eli over the line of scrimmage and last night on the downing the ball incident. He seemed to be looking for a way to justify spotting the ball at the 1!
 

links18

Well-Known Member
Messages
24,323
Reaction score
20,092
aikemirv;2425535 said:
What is up with that. Last week on the Eli over the line of scrimmage and last night on the downing the ball incident. He seemed to be looking for a way to justify spotting the ball at the 1!

He just didn't understand the rule and believed the ball was dead when Cartwright first touched it.

That said, Cartwright is a hell of a special teams player. We could use somebody like that......
 

joseephuss

Well-Known Member
Messages
28,041
Reaction score
6,920
He gets so fixated on one thing that he misses some important points.

He focused so much on Eli with respect to the red line that he failed to notice that the red line indicating the line of scrimmage was off about a 1/2 yard to a yard from the actual line of scrimmage.

He focused so much on Cartright first touching the ball down that he failed to realize that that is not the rule for downing a ball on a punt.
 

xWraithx

Benched
Messages
3,449
Reaction score
1
and BOTH times, Madden was making him look stupid

The Eli over the line of scrimmage penalty - Al Michaels kept referring to the heel of Eli's foot touching the line of scrimmage thereby making it a legal throw while Madden was saying it doesn't matter because the ball had not been released yet until AFTER his heel was off and in front of the line. Al Michaels for some reason didn't understand that and kept going back to the heel. idiot.

Last night downing the ball incident - Al Michaels kept saying that it didn't appear that any part of the Commander player's body touched the goal line before the threw the ball into play... while Madden was trying to explain to him that the refs were not looking at that part of the play but rather at the part afterwards when the ball hit his body while he was on the goal line

LOL Al Michaels... wow
 

Hostile

The Duke
Messages
119,565
Reaction score
4,544
links18;2425541 said:
He just didn't understand the rule and believed the ball was dead when Cartwright first touched it.

That said, Cartwright is a hell of a special teams player. We could use somebody like that......
I agree with both comments.
 

superpunk

Well-Known Member
Messages
26,330
Reaction score
75
Eventually they explained why it was correct. Al just displayed some ignorance, but eventually they got it right.
 

FCBarca

New Member
Messages
2,475
Reaction score
0
While I watched those incessant reviews on that touchback play, I kept thinking 'Why?'...Why are they continually reviewing this play?...You could see it from the first take that it hit him on the rear as he was already on the goal line...They repeated that replay over and over again, it was totally unnecessary

Speaking of which, hearing the ref saying it 'Hit him on the rear' was pretty comical...Couldn't he have simply said 'It touched the player while he was in the endzone'??
 

Royal Laegotti

Dyin' ain't much of a livin', boy!
Messages
4,971
Reaction score
0
I can't stand Al Michaels, i'd rather see Summeral, who doesn't know players names anymore, over Al!!!
 

aikemirv

Well-Known Member
Messages
16,405
Reaction score
9,999
FCBarca;2425676 said:
While I watched those incessant reviews on that touchback play, I kept thinking 'Why?'...Why are they continually reviewing this play?...You could see it from the first take that it hit him on the rear as he was already on the goal line...They repeated that replay over and over again, it was totally unnecessary

Speaking of which, hearing the ref saying it 'Hit him on the rear' was pretty comical...Couldn't he have simply said 'It touched the player while he was in the endzone'??

Yeah, he could have just said it hit him in the "Al Michaels" !
 

bbgun

Benched
Messages
27,869
Reaction score
6
http://img380.*************/img380/3122/ch51sunnov162008b085806pe3.jpg
 

dback

Member
Messages
814
Reaction score
13
It sort of reminds me of the Cowboys-Seahawks game back in '04 when Keyshawn dragged his toes before going out the back.

Do you remember how he kept saying "Dubious"?
 
Top