dbair1967;3012510 said:
I guess we'd have to agree to disagree, he doesnt appear to have much left.
Plus if you activate him you are basically wasting another spot on a one dimensional guy who gives you nothing else. He is too old and slow to play DB anymore, and he isnt a good enough PR to warrant the wated active spot.
Other than yesterday, Crayton has always been rock solid catching the ball, and Newman makes plays when he gets his chances here and there. We havent lost any games because of the punt return position.
IMO that's fine wasting a spot on him. If we're using Buehler for other ST team roles, that free's one up anyway. And I dont care how old he is, he could play our 5th corner role in a pinch.
And yes other than yesterday Crayton hasn't dropped the ball. But I would like more out of our punt return game than not dropping a ball. Newman may have more explosiveness but he doesnt look natural doing it. It was obvious he didnt have any confidence to field a punt at the 20 yard line Sunday, let it go over his head, and it died inside the 5. Not to mention as injury prone as the guy is, I dont want him back there (which I usually dont believe in)
Our punt return game was awful yesterday, and it has been bad for quite some time. We made an effort to improve hidden yardage and field position in the offseason by drafting a kickoff specialist. Yet we leave ourself year after year with sub-par punt returning.
*Edit* Crayton has a career punt return average of 8.3, and his average this year is 9.4, good for 34th in the league.