An unsaid thought

Venger

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,661
Reaction score
788
That I can't leave unsaid anymore. From a win a Super Bowl this year perspective, I believe we have mishandled the Romo/Dak situation.

It is my opinion that in the exuberance of our great start, and our amazement at finding our quarterback of the future on the scene so unexpectedly soon, we lost sight of this season's goal - to win the Super Bowl. I believe of the QB's on the roster - Romo is the only one with the NFL experience likely to achieve that goal. I believe that, with that goal in mind, you start playing Romo in the second half of games late in the season to get him to game speed, you let him start the finale, and he starts in the playoffs. Dak remains a proven backup in case of injury, he has seen the Cowboys future in the mirror, and I believe Dak is not the kind to have seen this move as anything but the way of things.

This is not Aikman/Walsh, or Brees/Rivers - Romo knows his time starting here is nearing the end, and Dak knows his time starting here is just getting started. And I don't think this gets into Dak's head one bit.

I've been reluctant to venture into this realm, because it will seem like Romo cheerleading or Dak hating, and while I could be guilty of the former, I will not brook consideration of the latter, which is nonsense. Finding Dak means this team has a decade of good QB'ing in front of them. He's actually restored my interest in this team past the end of the Romo era, something Jones/Goodell/NFL rules committee had put in serious doubt.

I will be happy for Dak to prove me incorrect, that he as a rookie has what it takes to navigate NFL playoff football to a successful conclusion. But there is a reason the Pantheon of Super Bowl winning QB's is an empty one. And I am afraid we will find out why if not today, then next week versus Atlanta. Let us hope Dak's successful run has three more games and my thoughts about needing a steady hand at the wheel around Cape Horn are overwrought. Our future is bright - but we may not be taking the most successful path into it.
 

haleyrules

Well-Known Member
Messages
16,060
Reaction score
42,877
Forget Tony Romo. The Cowboys will go with Prescott until the end. There is no option. Tony will not see the field again for the Cowboys barring a serious injury...and maybe not then. Prescott is the future for the next 10+ years. The management and FO can not afford with to tamper with this reality. Prescott is the starting QB no matter what happens in the Playoffs. Tony will not be back in Dallas after this season.
 

cajuncocoa

✮ ✮ ✮ ✮ ✮
Messages
4,236
Reaction score
1,638
26ueYUlPAmUkTBAM8.gif
 

Kevinicus

Well-Known Member
Messages
19,886
Reaction score
12,670
Forget Tony Romo. The Cowboys will go with Prescott until the end. There is no option. Tony will not see the field again for the Cowboys barring a serious injury...and maybe not then. Prescott is the future for the next 10+ years. The management and FO can not afford with to tamper with this reality. Prescott is the starting QB no matter what happens in the Playoffs. Tony will not be back in Dallas after this season.

They wouldn'y play Romo after Dak has a serious injury? It's official, the Dak train has gone full blown delusional.
 

Rockdoc

Well-Known Member
Messages
677
Reaction score
371
in Romo's defense, this is probably the best Cowboy team he has been part of.
there maybe a small chance in the right circumstance that he could play outside of injury
the reason, because you play this game and the playoffs like you may never get back
now or never, whatever it takes. win!
 

big dog cowboy

THE BIG DOG
Staff member
Messages
101,919
Reaction score
112,953
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
It is my opinion that in the exuberance of our great start, and our amazement at finding our quarterback of the future on the scene so unexpectedly soon, we lost sight of this season's goal - to win the Super Bowl.
Seriously?
 

Venger

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,661
Reaction score
788
Can't even wait until todays game is over and you're hating already. Enjoy the ride instead of whining.

The ride is over. Enjoy it?

Forget Tony Romo. The Cowboys will go with Prescott until the end.

At this point I agree - I would not have started Romo today. My point was that 6 weeks ago, I would have taken a different path.

Facepalm all you want, but people act like starting Romo is a guarenteed SB win. He doesnt have the playoff success to elicit such confidence

Dak is now 0-1. Winless. Should we have zero confidence in him? No. Which is why posting Romo's record was pointless.

Seriously?

Dead serious - did you really think you were going to storm into the Super Bowl with a rookie? It doesn't happen. The next time it does, it will be the first time. Someone with vision should have said "hey it's great this Dak kid is great guns and is clearly our future, but is he going to be ready for playoff football?" You saw what veteran experience does at QB today. Enjoy the off season.
 

darthseinfeld

Groupthink Guru
Messages
33,555
Reaction score
38,183
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
The ride is over. Enjoy it?



At this point I agree - I would not have started Romo today. My point was that 6 weeks ago, I would have taken a different path.



Dak is now 0-1. Winless. Should we have zero confidence in him? No. Which is why posting Romo's record was pointless.



Dead serious - did you really think you were going to storm into the Super Bowl with a rookie? It doesn't happen. The next time it does, it will be the first time. Someone with vision should have said "hey it's great this Dak kid is great guns and is clearly our future, but is he going to be ready for playoff football?" You saw what veteran experience does at QB today. Enjoy the off season.
How did Prescott lose the game exactly
 

sean10mm

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,024
Reaction score
3,000
Romo never threw for 300 yards in a playoff game, never threw for 3 TDs in a playoff game, and we just saw Dak do both. He had a passer rating of like 103.

The narrative that Romo would have won this game needs to die. It's pure mythology.
 

KB1122

Well-Known Member
Messages
3,328
Reaction score
1,629
Dak is better than Tony. But Aaron Rodgers is better than either of them. At the end of the day, a team led by an overachieving fourth-round talent who might be elite ran into a team led by a high-achieving first-round talent who is definitely elite. The latter is going to win those playoff games more often than not. As wonderful as Dak has been, I still want to draft a qb high in the first round and run an A-B test at the position. If Dak is the real thing, he'll win that battle. If not, he's great to trade.
 

Venger

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,661
Reaction score
788
How did Prescott lose the game exactly

Who proclaimed he did? The point of this thread was, in my belief, your playoff success rate would be higher with a veteran quarterback. Today's loss did nothing to dissuade that belief. It also did nothing to dissuade me from thinking this team has a bright future with Dak at QB.

Romo never threw for 300 yards in a playoff game, never threw for 3 TDs in a playoff game, and we just saw Dak do both. He had a passer rating of like 103.

Romo may not have won this game, and having him start it wasn't a realistic option. But we do know that Dak lost this game. We just saw Dak do that.

The narrative that Romo would have won this game needs to die. It's pure mythology

It does have the merits of plausibility, whereas our loss is established fact.
 

Animosity

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,183
Reaction score
1,029
If Romo was the better QB on the team, he would have started the moment he came back. End of story. Tom Brady isnt going to get benched no matter how well a rookie QB plays. Same goes for Aaron Rodgers.
 

Old'Boyfan

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,254
Reaction score
1,450
Can't even wait until todays game is over and you're hating already. Enjoy the ride instead of whining.

Good Lord. I've said it in another thread and I'll say it again. How is that "Hating"? The slightest hint that Romo just MIGHT be the better option in a Super Bowl run is HATING Dak? Really? People that throw around the word hate in such a casual manor don't have a good grasp of the English language. Are you so defensive of Dak that he is beyond reproach?
 

Rockport

AmberBeer
Messages
46,580
Reaction score
46,004
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
The ride is over. Enjoy it?



At this point I agree - I would not have started Romo today. My point was that 6 weeks ago, I would have taken a different path.



Dak is now 0-1. Winless. Should we have zero confidence in him? No. Which is why posting Romo's record was pointless.



Dead serious - did you really think you were going to storm into the Super Bowl with a rookie? It doesn't happen. The next time it does, it will be the first time. Someone with vision should have said "hey it's great this Dak kid is great guns and is clearly our future, but is he going to be ready for playoff football?" You saw what veteran experience does at QB today. Enjoy the off season.

So how did Prescott lose the game smart ***?
 
Top