Archer article 5 biggest problems in his eyes

RS12

Well-Known Member
Messages
32,523
Reaction score
29,863
Cant say I disagree. Team has not been able to pick up the blitz in years.:starspin

The dark side: All is not swell at Dallas Cowboys camp

Here are five concerns that the Dallas Cowboys need to address before the season begins

01:09 PM CDT on Thursday, August 20, 2009

Column by TODD ARCHER / The Dallas Morning News | tarcher@***BANNED-URL***



IRVING – The Cowboys are home after spending some three weeks inside the Alamodome for training camp.

Having seen every practice, charted almost every seven-on-seven and team period and putting it against camps of the past, the 2009 Cowboys' training camp was a success.

No major injuries. Tony Romo and Roy Williams have gotten better together. The defense looks to be more active, especially new safety Gerald Sensabaugh. There is a more serious approach by everyone involved, especially compared to last year.

But – and there had to be one of those – there are some concerns.

Here's a look at five:

1. Picking up the blitz

I asked Wade Phillips about the trouble the offense was having in picking up the blitz the last 10 days or so of training camp. He said the defense doesn't blitz and what they do is pretty exotic. I understand the offense doesn't game plan for practices. I get it, but too many times the quarterbacks would have been sacked, drilled into turf or forced into early throws.
At the mini-camp in June, the offense had the same problems. Last season they had trouble, too. When teams do exotic things – Philly, Baltimore, Pittsburgh, the NY Giants – the Cowboys don't seem to have an answer. Or if they do, not enough of the players know the right answer. Late in camp, the offense had three repeats in one practice to make sure they knew how to pick up a blitz.

Thinking of the Sept. 13 opener at Tampa Bay, Bucs coordinator Jim Bates is not a big blitz guy. But at some point during the season, the Cowboys better figure out how to handle the blitz.

2. Young LBs need time and they don't have a lot of it

Third-round pick Jason Williams is a tremendous athlete. He can run like a safety and hit like a linebacker. The talent is there. But he needs a ton of time to be able to be counted on. As Bill Parcells would say, he's like a ball in tall grass – lost. He is making a big jump from Western Illinois and switching positions, but he's not ready to contribute in the sub packages just yet. He has to be one of the best special teams players, or else.

Outside linebackers Victor Butler and Brandon Williams showed flashes. Butler did a better job in the last few practices inside the dome, especially against the run. Williams has been bothered by sore shoulders. He might be a more natural pass rusher. Phillips' defense is predicated on pressuring the quarterback, and the Cowboys are going to need one or both to help DeMarcus Ware and Anthony Spencer.

Speaking of Spencer ...

3. Anthony Spencer as a pass rusher

Every time Phillips talks about Spencer's development, he mentions how dominant Spencer is against the run. That's a good thing, but the Cowboys drafted Spencer because of his pass rushing skills.

In camp, I can't remember a "wow" moment from Spencer as a pass rusher. For as much as Greg Ellis complained, he could roll out of bed and get eight sacks a season. Without that security blanket, the Cowboys need Spencer to do something or Ware will be suffocated by the opposition.

4. I'm not sure the backup nose tackle is on the roster

Junior Siavii was among the final cuts last year, and Phillips thought he would hook on with another team. He didn't, and the Cowboys re-signed him in January. He has not been as consistent in this camp as he was last year. The Cowboys also cut Tim Anderson and have Jonas Seawright as the third-team nose tackle. The Cowboys have a Pro Bowler on the nose in Jay Ratliff , but they will be looking closely at the waiver wire to find a guy who can give him 10-15 plays of rest a game.

Siavii still has a chance to play his way onto the roster with his performances in the next three preseason games.

5. It's not a snap

Unofficially, I had Jon Kitna and either Cory Procter or Montrae Holland with nine poor snap exchanges in training camp. That's way too many. And Kitna and Procter had the same problem in the off-season workouts.

The good news is that if nothing goes wrong with Romo and Andre Gurode, then this isn't really an issue. I only remember Romo and Gurode having one poor snap.

Kitna has a strong arm, is pretty accurate and can move around. But if he can't get a snap, then what's the use? He says it's not a big deal and they have figured out the issue. We'll see.
 

speedkilz88

Well-Known Member
Messages
36,947
Reaction score
23,096
Holliday is no NT.

Blaming Kitna for the snap exchange is unfair since Holland is obviously doing it for the first time so those are expected. So then the ones with Procter are the ones to examine and we know it was his fault on the shotgun snap.
 

BAT

Mr. Fixit
Messages
19,443
Reaction score
15,607
miamicowboy21;2894384 said:
speedkilz88;2894376 said:
Holliday is no NT.

Yes he is. He played NT in Miami the last 3 years in their 3-4 defense.


I could have swore he played 3-4 DE, not NT. Isn't that why Parcells' traded w/Dallas for Jason Ferguson?
 

speedkilz88

Well-Known Member
Messages
36,947
Reaction score
23,096
miamicowboy21;2894384 said:
speedkilz88;2894376 said:
Holliday is no NT.

Yes he is. He played NT in Miami the last 3 years in their 3-4 defense.
No, Jason Ferguson played NT for Miami. Holliday played DE. He's also 6-5 285.
 

28 Joker

28 Joker
Messages
7,878
Reaction score
1
Every team in the NFL is going to have trouble picking up pressure from the Giants, Eagles, Ravens, and Steelers when they fall behind, especially.

Dallas has handled the Eagles' and Giant's blitz. They have beat the blitz plenty. I don't think that is going to be an issue. They had trouble with the delayed blitz at the end of the year last year (Ravens and Eagles). I think having Proctor in there, really put Gurode in a bind. He couldn't help Davis as much, I don't think.

Handling the Steelers' blitz wasn't the issue last year, either. It was throwing 40 yard bombs on 4th and 2 and running Deon Anderson on 4th and 1 or inches.

Dallas lit the Eagles up last year and hung 41 on them in game two. They backed off. Romo took a beating against the Giants, but he beat them.

I have your blitz buster:

He wears # 28!!
 

Bluefin

Well-Known Member
Messages
8,209
Reaction score
9,677
Todd Archer said:
He has to be one of the best special teams players, or else.

:laugh2:

Or what?

The front office was perfectly aware of the big jump they would be asking Jason Williams to make, I can't believe his roster spot is in any jeopardy.

It will be great if Williams can help right away on special teams, but I don't think it's an either/or situation. He's expected to become a starter in a year or two, playing specials in the short term would just be a bonus, IMO.


Todd Archer said:
The Cowboys have a Pro Bowler on the nose in Jay Ratliff , but they will be looking closely at the waiver wire to find a guy who can give him 10-15 plays of rest a game.

I hope Junior Siavii is ready to be Rat's caddy.

But would it be that hard to use Igor Olshansky and Marcus Spears to spell Rat during games if Siavii gets axed? Both starting ends are two down players and capable of taking spot snaps on the nose, if needed.
 

Bluefin

Well-Known Member
Messages
8,209
Reaction score
9,677
41gy#;2894396 said:
Handling the Steelers' blitz wasn't the issue last year, either. It was throwing 40 yard bombs on 4th and 2 and running Deon Anderson on 4th and 1 or inches.

And we asked Tony Romo to throw 36 times in the game and basically win it from start to finish.

Tashard Choice was effective running the ball and only got 23 totes.

I think we would've won that game if Choice had 30+ carries and Romo was kept under 25 attempts.
 

zrinkill

Cowboy Fan
Messages
49,040
Reaction score
32,541
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
RS12;2894330 said:
For as much as Greg Ellis complained, he could roll out of bed and get eight sacks a season.

Yet he only did it 5 times in his 11 year career.
 

NextGenBoys

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,252
Reaction score
1,964
Bluefin;2894411 said:
And we asked Tony Romo to throw 36 times in the game and basically win it from start to finish.

Tashard Choice was effective running the ball and only got 23 totes.

I think we would've won that game if Choice had 30+ carries and Romo was kept under 25 attempts.

I dont think running the ball against the Steelers 30+ is going to bode well IMO. You're going to get way too many 3rd and longs.

IMO our gameplan for that game was perfect. We beat them every way possible, and ended up gift wrapping the game for them in the 4th quarter.

That game was about execution, not coaching IMO
 

Bluefin

Well-Known Member
Messages
8,209
Reaction score
9,677
NextGenBoys;2894488 said:
I dont think running the ball against the Steelers 30+ is going to bode well IMO. You're going to get way too many 3rd and longs.

IMO our gameplan for that game was perfect. We beat them every way possible, and ended up gift wrapping the game for them in the 4th quarter.

That game was about execution, not coaching IMO

Tony Romo had no business throwing the ball that often in a cold weather game. We were 3 of 14 on 3rd downs for a 21% clip, so the pansy passing attack didn't exactly set a standard for excellence.

We had 95 net rushing yards and a 3.7 average.

Sexy?

No.

Good enough?

I think so.

We came out and tried to throw the ball just like the Steelers thought we would. And for a team that wasn't executing well to try that on the road in those conditions was simply bad form.

We almost won it anyway.

IMO, a commitment to the running game would've resulted in a victory.
 

Jay

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,689
Reaction score
98
At 6-5 285 lbs, Vonnie Holliday is NOT a 3-4 NT. No way in hell. He definitely played DE for them.
 

jterrell

Penguinite
Messages
33,871
Reaction score
15,969
zrinkill;2894422 said:
Yet he only did it 5 times in his 11 year career.

He has done it 5 of the last 6 seasons and 7 seasons ago he had 7.5.

Spencer's pass rush skills are a huge concern. A one-legged mule should get 6 sacks opposite Ware but Spencer hasn't shown anything other than more burst than slow Greg Ellis. Maybe like Greg he'll be a good pass rusher after 5 years....
 

jterrell

Penguinite
Messages
33,871
Reaction score
15,969
good article about true issues.

for me top 5 are:

1) Depth on OL and at LB. The OL rather determines how the offense goes and the LB corps determines the fate of the defense by and large. Starters are good but key backups are few and far between.

2) December. The team has to get December swoons out of their head and it would help if they didn't face top 10 teams all month. I love their new focus in TC but this will be a test of their mental fortitude.

3) NFC East. This division is just so tough. While I think the Giants are hugely overrated right now and the Eagles peaked at the right time last year bottom line is they were two of the best teams in football in 2008 and any falloff wasn't extreme.

4) Marion Barber. If Barber is back to his pre-injury form then the team will be really good. His power running mixed in with Felix's quickness and a few scampers from Choice using his vision will be really nasty for defense and keep them back on their heels at all times. But remove Barber and this team struggles to get short yardage pickups.

5) Coaching. Jason Garrett is a really bright guy and extremely likable but he also failed to adapt last year quickly enough to the talents of Marty B and Felix and offered game plans that were too vanilla for the injured Cowboys to pull off. Asking really banged up OL to stand up to fierce pass rushers with a "here's what we do.. stop us mentality" is super fail. This isn't 1990 where teams could stockpile astonishing depth.
 

jterrell

Penguinite
Messages
33,871
Reaction score
15,969
Jay;2894524 said:
At 6-5 285 lbs, Vonnie Holliday is NOT a 3-4 NT. No way in hell. He definitely played DE for them.

He played alot of 3-4 NT for them on pass rush downs but he wouldn't touch that role here and he can't handle the run as the NT so he isn't a fit at all.
 
Top