Archer: Dallas Cowboys' projected roster

RS12

Well-Known Member
Messages
32,523
Reaction score
29,863
QUARTERBACKS (2)

Dustin Vaughan's performance against the San Diego Chargers has earned him some discussions about the practice squad. He has not done enough for the 53-man roster yet, but the Cowboys might have something worth developing.

RUNNING BACKS (4)

Randle took a step forward with how he played against the Chargers and not just his work as a runner. He did a decent job in pass protection and on special teams. Williams was OK, but he allowed a sack. I'm still not sold on a fullback. Clutts is the only real choice but injuries at other spots could lead to his demise.

WIDE RECEIVERS (5)
http://espn.go.com/blog/dallas/cowboys/post/_/id/4731287/dallas-cowboys-projected-roster-3
 

Staubacher

Well-Known Member
Messages
12,310
Reaction score
23,739
I agree with almost all of this except RB. Clutts won't make it and Williams will.

And being totally objective - looking at that defensive roster wow it is not good.
 

xwalker

Well-Known Member
Messages
57,193
Reaction score
64,699
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
I agree with almost all of this except RB. Clutts won't make it and Williams will.

And being totally objective - looking at that defensive roster wow it is not good.

Yes, I'm beginning to wonder if they start the season with a FB. They could always bring one of them back at some point.

I don't really see the need for LB Cam Lawrence. I would keep a 6th WR over him.

My preference would be to see Spencer start on the PUP. He's not going to be 100% if he is not already practicing. Might as well keep an extra young guy for the 1st 6 weeks and let Spencer get closer to 100%.

It will be sad to see Hayden take up a spot. I just don't see the point. If they're going to be bad, they might as well do it with a young player that has the possibility to get better.

Scandrick shouldn't count against the 53 while suspended.
 

reddyuta

Well-Known Member
Messages
22,513
Reaction score
17,234
The fullback won't make it,we may bring him back after week 4.
 

cmoney23

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,760
Reaction score
2,262
5 Safetys but only 5 CBs? Nope... I see 3/4 safetys and 6 CBs and one more DL

Also Ryan Williams over Clutts
 

Zimmy Lives

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,165
Reaction score
4,631
I agree with all of his selections except for Spencer and Hayden: I think they should carry youth over age; Spencer can always start on PUP and earn a job.
 

erod

Well-Known Member
Messages
38,705
Reaction score
60,327
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
JC Copeland is the new Adrian Hamilton.

All hype and no actual ability.
 

AKATheRake

Well-Known Member
Messages
6,968
Reaction score
2,963
IMVHO

QUARTERBACKS (2)

We're confident in Romo's health and like what we're seeing in Brandon Weeden. As importantly we don't take a 3rd QB to use on an added roster spot for our defense.


RUNNING BACKS (4)
Ryan Williams makes the team as he is playing well and we have no FB that has blown our socks off to keep a roster spot for. All 4 RB's are showing this team something.


WIDE RECEIVERS (6)
Chris Boyd makes the team after having a solid training camp and showing promise in preseason play. This is a very young unit that has talent. Terrance Williams is apparently much improved from a very good rookie season. Cole Beasley's role is expanded and now has a few years of playing under his belt along with Dwayne Harris who has shown to make plays at WR and is a star on returns. Devin Street and Chris Boyd are the 2 young WR's being developed on this roster now.


TIGHT ENDS (3)

Maybe the strongest position we have at this point on the whole team.


OFFENSIVE LINE (8)
Parnell is not worth the pay as he's shown no improvement during this offseason and is rendered a cap savings. Weems has not practice much during the offseason and Wentzel who is practicing isn't worth keeping a backup spot over a more solid and polished swing tackle vet. Further more, if injury did occur to either of the starting tackles, Zach Martin is considered the legitimate fill in with the trio of guards in Leary, Bernadeau and Nwaneri to start and backup both guard positions if Martin needs to play tackle.

DEFENSIVE LINE (10)

Spencer makes his first appearance on the 53-man roster, but that doesn't mean he will be ready for Week 1. He could be ready by Week 3, however, so stashing him on PUP for the first six weeks might not be worth it. His rehab has come along well. He takes Ben Gardner's spot. Hayden does not show enough against 1st and 2nd team o-lines in the preseason to keep his spot at his salary and also provides a cap savings. I believe at this point the best 4 man front to start knowing Spencer is not 100% is: Crawford (LDE), Melton (3 tech), McClain (1 tech), Selvie (RDE, even though he is best as LDE but best of RDE's right now). For our speed rusher on obvious passing downs we bring in Martez Wilson at RDE, while Spencer is still getting into playing shape and Lawrence is injured. Josh Brent's meeting with Goodell went well and reinstatement is on it's way. Cowboys get him on the cheap and as Jerry's suggests gives him a roster spot. Ken Bishop is the developmental 1 tech after McClain and Brent who can't play right away while McClain starts. Tyron Crawford backs up Melton at 3 tech when necessary and comes off LDE when necessary.

LINEBACKER (7)

McClain gets back into football shape and starts playing in the preseason games. He is our starting MLB with Durant and Hitchens backing him up. A risky proposition in McClain, which at this point the team has no choice but to take. Bruce Carter remains the starter at SAM and Justin Durant the Will. We're running thin at LB all year and hope we don't have to start the backups.


CORNERBACK (6)

Scandrick who at this point is considered the starter opposite Carr and the teams best slot corner will be suspended the first 4 games of the season. Mo Claiborne was supposedly having a very good training camp but yet again has missed time recently due to injury. He obviously gets his starting job back due to Scandricks suspension. Terrance Mitchell is showing promise and makes the roster. Sterling Moore knows the system but the team needs to pickup an experience and solid 3rd corner especially for the first 4 games to hide what could become a glaring weakness at the 3rd CB spot on game days. Also, should injury occur to either of the starters, which has been the case in the past. This unit would be paper thin on game days. B.W Webb just inst ready for this level yet and doesn't make the cut.



SAFETY (4)

Matt Johnson is again injured and finally cut. Maybe stashed for PS since the FO cant seem to get over this guy. Jeff Heath has to go because Hamilton and Dixon show better upside and play making ability to keep Heath who has to be cut for a much needed 6th CB roster spot. Church and Wilcox are the obvious starters and the FO hopes for good health throughout the season at safety play. Because LB and now CB are so compromised due to the Sean Lee injury and Orlando Scandrick suspension, the safety position takes the depth hit. Because there are so many unknowns about the d-line we have to go heavy there and then again sacrifice safety depth.

SPECIALISTS (3)

No change here unless the new Australian punter can pull a Matt Mcbriar,
 

Rick_Deckard

luvtheboys
Messages
553
Reaction score
210
IMVHO

OFFENSIVE LINE (8)
Parnell is not worth the pay as he's shown no improvement during this offseason and is rendered a cap savings. Weems has not practice much during the offseason and Wentzel who is practicing isn't worth keeping a backup spot over a more solid and polished swing tackle vet. Further more, if injury did occur to either of the starting tackles, Zach Martin is considered the legitimate fill in with the trio of guards in Leary, Bernadeau and Nwaneri to start and backup both guard positions if Martin needs to play tackle.


LINEBACKER (7)

McClain gets back into football shape and starts playing in the preseason games. He is our starting MLB with Durant and Hitchens backing him up. A risky proposition in McClain, which at this point the team has no choice but to take. Bruce Carter remains the starter at SAM and Justin Durant the Will. We're running thin at LB all year and hope we don't have to start the backups.

I think the team is higher on Wetzel than you think. He played well against SD. I also think they value Cam Lawrence for his Special Team Play.

I think both make the team.
 

AKATheRake

Well-Known Member
Messages
6,968
Reaction score
2,963
I think the team is higher on Wetzel than you think. He played well against SD. I also think they value Cam Lawrence for his Special Team Play.

I think both make the team.

I agree that the team thinks highly of Wetzel and they like Cam Lawrences ST's play.

They also have a lot of questions on the d-line, LB and now 1 at CB for the 1st 4 weeks of the season.

Players like Wetzel and Lawrence on the fringe are the ones that will have to be expendable.

Furthermore, because our o-line has so many young and flexible players on the interior line and 1 that can move out to tackle if need be. The teem is probably going to go 7-8 o-lineman this time around so we can load up a bit more on the defensive side.
 

Rick_Deckard

luvtheboys
Messages
553
Reaction score
210
I agree that the team thinks highly of Wetzel and they like Cam Lawrences ST's play.

They also have a lot of questions on the d-line, LB and now 1 at CB for the 1st 4 weeks of the season.

Players like Wetzel and Lawrence on the fringe are the ones that will have to be expendable.

Furthermore, because our o-line has so many young and flexible players on the interior line and 1 that can move out to tackle if need be. The teem is probably going to go 7-8 o-lineman this time around so we can load up a bit more on the defensive side.

I could understand the argument of making Wetzel expendable by going light at OL to load up on the DL, but in your projection you list a FA being brought in instead of keeping Wetzel. I just don't see that happening. I'm also not sure they will sacrifice Special Teams to replace Lawrence with another defensive player. That's just my guess.
 

Galian Beast

Well-Known Member
Messages
14,735
Reaction score
7,457
As mentioned you have to go deeper at corner, and I almost think you have to bring in a veteran here in the time beind since Scandrick will be gone for 4 games, and who knows if Claiborne cans tay healthy...Carr might also not be in proper shape.

They need to do something here at corner, even if it means trading away draft picks.

I also agree that Williams makes it over Clutts. The team will want Williams assuming they aren't planning to resign Murray at the end of the year.

I think Spencer is a lock for the PUP list. I also think our lack of depth at Defensive End is a bit disturbing. Another position where we may have to do something. Garnder ends up on the practice squad with maybe one other end.
 

AKATheRake

Well-Known Member
Messages
6,968
Reaction score
2,963
I could understand the argument of making Wetzel expendable by going light at OL to load up on the DL, but in your projection you list a FA being brought in instead of keeping Wetzel. I just don't see that happening. I'm also not sure they will sacrifice Special Teams to replace Lawrence with another defensive player. That's just my guess.

Yes I did project a FA. That's to replace Parnell with a more cost effective yet experienced FA backup tackle. Chances are Parnell stays on the team but we always have a player or 2 we cut to save more money and bring in younger or as skilled for less. Parnell and Hayden are my 2 guys on the bubble in that regard. Wetzel and Weem's are totally expendable regardless inmho at this point.

When we're full of questions on the d-line, so thin at LB and now have to get a solid 3rd corner for game days the 1st 4 weeks of the season due to Scandrick's suspension a bubble guy like Lawrence becomes more expendable especially if we think he'll make waivers. Once again my opinion.

I'm really enjoying your response and respect your insight.
 

Galian Beast

Well-Known Member
Messages
14,735
Reaction score
7,457
And of course after I write this I read that the brilliant Jerry Jones says he will be active... Makes little sense...
 

AKATheRake

Well-Known Member
Messages
6,968
Reaction score
2,963
As mentioned you have to go deeper at corner, and I almost think you have to bring in a veteran here in the time beind since Scandrick will be gone for 4 games, and who knows if Claiborne cans tay healthy...Carr might also not be in proper shape.

They need to do something here at corner, even if it means trading away draft picks.

I also agree that Williams makes it over Clutts. The team will want Williams assuming they aren't planning to resign Murray at the end of the year.

I think Spencer is a lock for the PUP list. I also think our lack of depth at Defensive End is a bit disturbing. Another position where we may have to do something. Garnder ends up on the practice squad with maybe one other end.

I agree here with everything you said except for Spencer being a lock for PUP.

I know Jerry knows how to blow smoke but even Spencer said he has a good chance being ready for week 1. Probably not in a starting and/or large snap count role but in a position to play.

I say by week 3 if that's the case and there are no more set backs. So if what is being said is the truth I don't put Spencer on PUP.
 
Top