Awards for top performers from the first half of 2005

Doomsday101

Well-Known Member
Messages
107,762
Reaction score
39,034
Halfway home in the NFL's 2005 regular season. That means it's time for some mid-year superlatives:

• MVP: Indianapolis quarterback Peyton Manning -- No, he's not on a record-setting pace this year. But he's playing well enough to have his team 8-0 and he finally beat Tom Brady/Bill Belichick head to head.

• Offensive Player of the Year: San Diego running back LaDainian Tomlinson -- This is the award that all the fantasy types care about. L.T. has 13 rushing touchdowns, two receiving, and he's thrown for three scores.

• Defensive Player of the Year: Indianapolis defensive end Dwight Freeney -- A nod to Pittsburgh safety Troy Polamula, but Freeney is the game's most feared impact player and has helped the Colts defense to new heights.

• Offensive Rookie of the Year: Chicago quarterback Kyle Orton -- Miami's Ronnie Brown will be the popular choice, but fourth-round pick Orton has played smartly and has his upstart team in first by two games.

• Defensive Rookie of the Year: Cincinnati linebacker Odell Thurman -- San Diego's Shawn Merriman and Dallas' Demarcus Ware are deserving, too. But Thurman leads the surprising Bengals in tackles, has four picks, one touchdown, one sack and one fumble recovery.

• Comeback Player of the Year: Carolina receiver Steve Smith -- With apologies to Mark Brunell, Ty Law, Kyle Vanden Bosch and Tedy Bruschi, Smith has been a premier playmaker week in and week out.

• Coach of the Year: Tom Coughlin, New York Giants -- In an NFC East that has been much more bullish than anyone expected, Coughlin has his Giants in great position to make the playoffs for the first time since 2002.

• Biggest surprise, team: Chicago Bears -- Twenty years after the famed '85 Bears, Chicago is again winning with defense. The first-place Bears are on pace to allow fewer than 200 points, and they can run the ball, too.

• Biggest surprise, individual: Dallas quarterback Drew Bledsoe: Plenty of us thought he was done, but Bledsoe leads the NFC in passer rating (97.4) and has helped make the Cowboys relevant once again.

• Biggest disappointment, team: Minnesota Vikings -- On so many different fronts, how do you begin to measure the underachievement in Minnesota? Baltimore, Arizona, the Jets and Houston also let a lot of people down.

• Biggest disappointment, individual: Minnesota quarterback Daunte Culpepper -- If it weren't for Peyton Manning, Culpepper might have won the MVP last season. But his struggles this year set the tone for the Vikings' disastrous first half.

• Trend of the Year: Two-man backfields -- The list of teams regularly using multiple running backs grows longer all the time. Kansas City, Denver, Pittsburgh, Dallas, Miami and Atlanta have had particular success.

Three guys who have to step it up
1. Chris Simms, Tampa Bay, quarterback -- Here's a sobering stat for fans of Simms: Since the start of 2004, the Bucs are 10-7 in games that Brian Griese plays in, and 0-7 in games he doesn't. Doesn't say much for Tampa Bay's supposed quarterback of the future.

2. Brian Westbrook, Philadelphia, running back -- Time to start earning all that new money, Mr. Westbrook. In his last five games, Westbrook's average run has been 1.7, 2.0, 2.5, 3.7 and 1.4, respectively. He's had 25 yards or less of rushing in four of those games.

3. Pacman Jones, Tennessee, cornerback -- Just call him Flop-man Jones, because the sixth overall pick in the draft has been truly brutal as a rookie. His coverage and tackling has left a lot to be desired, and he even fumbled away a kickoff return at Cleveland.

1. From a team karma standpoint, the Eagles obviously are better off without the energy-sapping Terrell Owens saga to deal with. But this is a team that's in pretty tough shape these days. The Eagles have no running game to speak of and now they're without a No. 1 receiver to challenge defenses. That's going to put an awful strain on Jim Johnson's defense, and sooner or later that overdependence on one side of the ball will catch up with Philadelphia.
I think it's safe to say the curse of the NFC champion -- nobody has
repeated since the 1996-97 Packers -- is alive and well for another year.

2. No more calls, we have a winner. Michael Vick takes the Chad Pennington lecture-the-media award this year for admonishing reporters not to criticize him any more for his lack of accurate pocket passing. Pennington, of course, famously told reporters last year that they were "privileged'' to cover him and the rest of the Jets.

Memo to Mike: Try to crack 200 yards passing for two consecutive games, and get your season passer rating to at least 75.0 (he's currently 70.8, which ranks 26th in the league) before going off on those who point out the obvious room for improvement in your game.

3. Funny, but for a guy who was ubiquitous for being beside Terrell Owens throughout so much of this year's circus act in Philadelphia, agent Drew Rosenhaus was nowhere to be found when things reached their denouement with T.O. and the Eagles? When you've left even Rosenhaus not knowing what else to say, you've really done something.

4. It isn't my call to make, but given Priest Holmes' health and Larry Johnson's production, how do you not make getting Johnson the ball the top priority in the Kansas City game plan?

5. Tell me again why some people don't include Seattle's Shaun Alexander among the game's elite running backs? The guy's a touchdown machine. With his two at Arizona on Sunday, Alexander has 86 career touchdowns in 88 career games (68 starts). I'll take him, and I don't even play fantasy football.

http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/2005/writers/don_banks/11/08/midseason.awards/index.html?cnn=yes
 

Alexander

What's it going to be then, eh?
Messages
62,482
Reaction score
67,294
Comeback Player of the Year: Carolina receiver Steve Smith -- With apologies to Mark Brunell, Ty Law, Kyle Vanden Bosch and Tedy Bruschi, Smith has been a premier playmaker week in and week out.

How is Steve Smith a better comeback story than Bledsoe? He was injured.
Ty Law was injured. So was Bruschi. I fail to see how that is a "comeback".

I guess my definition is different. For me, it is not recovering from an injury, but going from what people consider done in the league to successful.
 

Doomsday101

Well-Known Member
Messages
107,762
Reaction score
39,034
I thought this was a bit funny!!!

2. No more calls, we have a winner. Michael Vick takes the Chad Pennington lecture-the-media award this year for admonishing reporters not to criticize him any more for his lack of accurate pocket passing. Pennington, of course, famously told reporters last year that they were "privileged'' to cover him and the rest of the Jets.

Memo to Mike: Try to crack 200 yards passing for two consecutive games, and get your season passer rating to at least 75.0 (he's currently 70.8, which ranks 26th in the league) before going off on those who point out the obvious room for improvement in your game.
 

joseephuss

Well-Known Member
Messages
28,041
Reaction score
6,920
Alexander said:
How is Steve Smith a better comeback story than Bledsoe? He was injured.
Ty Law was injured. So was Bruschi. I fail to see how that is a "comeback".

I guess my definition is different. For me, it is not recovering from an injury, but going from what people consider done in the league to successful.

To me it is playing at a high level, then playing at a low level and coming back to play at a high level again. The change can be due to injury or whatever. Smith, Bledsoe and Brunell are all good candidates. They each have a different reason for their set backs and now are playing well again.

I think Tommy Maddox won this award a few years ago. I don't understand how. What did he come back from? He never was anything before. That isn't making a come back.
 

AbeBeta

Well-Known Member
Messages
35,680
Reaction score
12,392
Alexander said:
How is Steve Smith a better comeback story than Bledsoe? He was injured.
Ty Law was injured. So was Bruschi. I fail to see how that is a "comeback".

I guess my definition is different. For me, it is not recovering from an injury, but going from what people consider done in the league to successful.

Regardless of how maligned Drew was, the stats show that last year he performed right at his career average. His passer rating for the year was 76.6 -- his career rating before that season was ... 76.7.

He led his team to a 9-7 record after an awful start to the season.

You can't call it a comeback if he didn't have a real drop in his play.
 

big_neil

Benched
Messages
902
Reaction score
0
True, it was only a "comback" based on Buffalo "fans" reduced mentality.
 

AbeBeta

Well-Known Member
Messages
35,680
Reaction score
12,392
big_neil said:
True, it was only a "comback" based on Buffalo "fans" reduced mentality.

The reactions of their fans is kind of overblown. I know some smart Buff fans and some stupid ones. Unfortunately, the stupid fans are usually the loudest.

Much like on this board, the stupid ones are going to go for the easiest explanation -- must be Drew -- he's the QB. He's getting sacked too often.

The smart fans always told me that the O-line in Buff sucked. They were especially disappointed with Jonas Jennings and Mike Williams -- esp. Williams. When the line play was better (Bledsoe's first year), everyone thought they got a major steal when they traded for him.
 

ghst187

Well-Known Member
Messages
15,722
Reaction score
11,572
Doomsday101 said:
I thought this was a bit funny!!!

2. No more calls, we have a winner. Michael Vick takes the Chad Pennington lecture-the-media award this year for admonishing reporters not to criticize him any more for his lack of accurate pocket passing. Pennington, of course, famously told reporters last year that they were "privileged'' to cover him and the rest of the Jets.

Memo to Mike: Try to crack 200 yards passing for two consecutive games, and get your season passer rating to at least 75.0 (he's currently 70.8, which ranks 26th in the league) before going off on those who point out the obvious room for improvement in your game.

me too, if you can't handle some media criticism by laughing all the way to the bank, then find a different profession babies.
Ole Mexico can work at a health center in exchange for penicilin shots.
 
Top