Bengals Move A & M's McNeal to WR

Hostile

The Duke
Messages
119,565
Reaction score
4,544
Link

McNeal moves to WR
Speedster looks good to Lewis in first test

BY MARK CURNUTTE | ENQUIRER STAFF WRITER
Saturday morning, in his first NFL practice, Reggie McNeal wore wide receivers' gloves for the first time since 1998 - when he was a high school freshman.

The Bengals' sixth-round pick in the draft two weeks ago, McNeal was a college quarterback at Texas A&M. He's making the transition to receiver on the highest level of football. The first step of the process was a productive one.

"He looked comfortable," coach Marvin Lewis said after the second of two Saturday practices. "He did a good job."

McNeal flashed his 4.32-second, 40-yard-dash speed. He ran right past cornerback DeMarcus Rideaux on a fly pattern. McNeal showed excellent cutting ability, turning the corner on routes across the middle and on out patterns.

"I think I did pretty (well) for my first go-round at receiver," he said. "I want to continue to get better. It's a big challenge, but I'm up for it. You do a lot more competing than just sitting back and throwing. You get to go against some of the best (defensive backs) one-on-one and see what you've got."

"I think it's going to work out for the best," McNeal added.

McNeal was one of the focal points of the Bengals' rookie minicamp. Wide receivers coach Hue Jackson paid close attention to McNeal through two practices. McNeal, Lewis said, would get no work at quarterback through the remaining three practices.

The Bengals want to help him turn into a receiver as quickly as possible.
McNeal could make the team as the sixth wide receiver and provide them with a versatile quarterback/receiver threat that they haven't had. The comparison is to former Steelers receiver Antwaan Randle El, a former college quarterback.

McNeal could provide some roster options. He could be the third quarterback as a wide receiver. On the field, he could throw passes on wide receiver options and end-around plays.

He would welcome any opportunity in the offensive package to run and catch the ball and throw it.

But for now, the concentration is on learning to play receiver.

"He has to get himself in receiver shape, but he has the ability to go catch the ball," Jackson said. "He's got some work to do, and I think he's willing to do it.

"He's a very smart football player. Obviously the background as a quarterback helps. He did a great job today. He understands (defensive) coverages (and) progressions, how to see things sooner than most guys, because he has had to do it his whole career."

McNeal took note of the additional running that he didn't have to do in college as a quarterback.

Though he had no work as a wide receiver at the scouting combine in February in Indianapolis - McNeal worked out strictly as a quarterback - he was considered one of the finest overall athletes in the draft.

"Then talking to my agent, we had certain teams that we worked out for at quarterback and receiver for," he said.

Former Eastern Washington quarterback Erik Meyer, who threw all day, was impressed by McNeal.

"I talked to him at the combine," said Meyer, a college free agent. "You saw his 40 time, run a 4.3, I knew he was an athlete. I saw him at the Shrine Game a little bit, and I knew he would be able to make the adjustment.

"A guy like that is just a tremendous athlete. He made some good catches. He looked comfortable out there. He looked like he was getting it pretty good."
 

BlueStar22

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,192
Reaction score
3,938
I guess he finally realized that if he wants to play in the league, he needs to play wherever they want him. It's truly unfortunate that he refused to work at WR at the Combine. He more than likely would've went before the 6th round if he had.
 

J-DOG

Active Member
Messages
2,135
Reaction score
0
As far as athletic ability goes McNeal is a great prospect.
I too thought that he was wrong by not working out at wr before the draft.
Dude cost himself a lot of money by not doing that.
Look at where Matt Jones was drafted.
Not saying McNeal would have been drafted that high, but verified 4.32 forty gets everyone's attention.
I think the Bengals made a shrewd move by drafting this guy.
I think he can make the transition.
 

Hostile

The Duke
Messages
119,565
Reaction score
4,544
BlueStar22 said:
I guess he finally realized that if he wants to play in the league, he needs to play wherever they want him. It's truly unfortunate that he refused to work at WR at the Combine. He more than likely would've went before the 6th round if he had.
He might have but I do understand why guys like him and Eric Crouch want to prove themselves at QB. Not many embrace these changes like Matt Jones or Hines Ward have. It's gotta be tough to play at the college level so well, only to be told your skills don't translate to what NFL teams are looking for.
 

jay cee

Active Member
Messages
2,906
Reaction score
3
Does anyone know how much money a backup QB makes compared to a backup Wide receiver?
 

burmafrd

Well-Known Member
Messages
43,820
Reaction score
3,379
Its called reality. Sooner or later all must bow to it. The SMART ones see it sooner.
 

Hostile

The Duke
Messages
119,565
Reaction score
4,544
jay cee said:
Does anyone know how much money a backup QB makes compared to a backup Wide receiver?
That's a good question. Ireally don't know, but that WR corps in Cincy will be tough to break into. His job won't be easy.
 

jay cee

Active Member
Messages
2,906
Reaction score
3
Hostile said:
He might have but I do understand why guys like him and Eric Crouch want to prove themselves at QB. Not many embrace these changes like Matt Jones or Hines Ward have. It's gotta be tough to play at the college level so well, only to be told your skills don't translate to what NFL teams are looking for.
Right on point Hos.
 

jay cee

Active Member
Messages
2,906
Reaction score
3
Hostile said:
That's a good question. Ireally don't know, but that WR corps in Cincy will be tough to break into. His job won't be easy.
I just don't see how the guy does not project to be as good as the average backup QB.

And I don't see how he could project to be anything more than a backup WR. So I can see why he would want to stay at QB.
 

Hostile

The Duke
Messages
119,565
Reaction score
4,544
jay cee said:
Right on point Hos.
You know what's weird jay cee is that this happens at just about every position, but QB always gets the publicity.

A couple of examples, Tedy Bruschi tied the NCAA career sack record as a DE here at Arizona. When he went to the NFL all he heard was that he was too small to play DE and too slow to play LB. A bunch of us told Tedy to let that be his motivation to prove people wrong. He's got a great "fooball motor" and that is why he has made the transition.

Mike Hass won the 2005 Fred Biletnikoff award as the nation's top WR, yet he wasn't drafted until the 5th round by New Orleans and 21 WRs went before his name was called. Now his case is a bit different because if he makes the NFL it will beat the position he has always played, but now he may have to compete with guys who were college QBs some day.

The dynamics of all of this stuff is amazing when you think about it. This is why I think intelligence and heart are so under rated in a player. Eric Crouch was a superior athlete but he let notbeing a QB frustrate him so much that he couldn't stand it. The goal should be to make it anyway you can, some only want to make it on their terms. It neverworks outforthose players regardless of their talent level.
 

BlueStar22

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,192
Reaction score
3,938
Hostile said:
He might have but I do understand why guys like him and Eric Crouch want to prove themselves at QB. Not many embrace these changes like Matt Jones or Hines Ward have. It's gotta be tough to play at the college level so well, only to be told your skills don't translate to what NFL teams are looking for.
Thing is, McNeal never lived up to the hype at A&M.
 

stealth

Benched
Messages
4,882
Reaction score
0
Hostile said:
Mike Hass won the 2005 Fred Biletnikoff award as the nation's top WR, yet he wasn't drafted until the 5th round by New Orleans and 21 WRs went before his name was called. Now his case is a bit different because if he makes the NFL it will beat the position he has always played, but now he may have to compete with guys who were college QBs some day.


I really liked hass in college too, I hope that guy turns into something.
 

skinsscalper

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,146
Reaction score
5,693
And, don't forget Frost who was converted to FS with the NY Jets. Not a HOF career by any measure, but the kid earned a living for a while making a hell of a lot more than he would have made in "the real world".

SS
 

Pooz

New Member
Messages
259
Reaction score
0
I wish him the best. The kid can play he's had injuries and was on an average at best team in college.
 

LeonDixson

Illegitimi non carborundum
Messages
12,299
Reaction score
6,808
It sounds like he's got the right attitude now. Marvin Lewis must have said all the right things. His family and friends probably did too. I hope he is successful.
 

arglebargle

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,373
Reaction score
409
If these type o' guys seriously want to stay playing QB they really need to opt out of the NFL and spend a few years at the Arena, NFLe or CFL levels. Do well enough there, and you will get some sort of look or trial in the NFL. This is an issue where their agents should really give them 'real world' speech.

Personally, I would just play WR/Safety/whatever. But if you just had to....
 

jay cee

Active Member
Messages
2,906
Reaction score
3
Who really thinks McNeal will be anything more than a number 3 or 4 WR, and why?

I know he's fast, but so was Alexander Wright, I just can't see him as anything more than a back up. He's not a tough guy like Hines Ward, and he does not have the size speed ratio of Matt Jones.

The only thing special about him is his speed. He may prove me wrong, but I don't see him as a special WR.
 

Hostile

The Duke
Messages
119,565
Reaction score
4,544
jay cee said:
Who really thinks McNeal will be anything more than a number 3 or 4 WR, and why?

I know he's fast, but so was Alexander Wright, I just can't see him as anything more than a back up. He's not a tough guy like Hines Ward, and he does not have the size speed ratio of Matt Jones.

The only thing special about him is his speed. He may prove me wrong, but I don't see him as a special WR.
I said before, that WR corps will be hard to break into. Unless Chris Henry continues to mess up. If Reggie M. makes it he'll need to rely on brains and his speed.
 

jimmy40

Well-Known Member
Messages
16,866
Reaction score
1,888
Hostile said:
I said before, that WR corps will be hard to break into. Unless Chris Henry continues to mess up. If Reggie M. makes it he'll need to rely on brains and his speed.
Someone seems to be missing from this thread.:laugh2:
 
Top