Bob Sturm's pre draft thoughts

chicago JK

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,892
Reaction score
1,452
http://sturminator.blogspot.com/2014/05/a-few-final-thoughts-draft-day-morning-1.html


The day has arrived. The hours have either been well spent or completely wasted, but the overdue arrival of the draft weekend is finally here.

Yesterday, I presented the audience with my best version of my Final board. This would imply that it is my final copy, but when I realized I did not place Chris Borland (he belongs at 57th) or Troy Niklas (he should be about 62nd) and then need to move everyone down, I guess it is my final 77. This works with the Cowboys pick in the 3rd round 78th for now.

For the Cowboys, I am reminded of what I wrote on January 15th - some 113 days ago. Thankfully, I am consistent in my views (on these, at least) on how this entire thing breaks both in January and now as the process has been completed.

Let's review the basic objectives as stated in January:

1) -The Cowboys must attempt to fix their defense in the draft at the expense of almost everything else on the agenda. It has been said a number of times already in this short off-season from a number of people that although everyone seems to agree that the best player available is a great starting point, this team needs to really emphasize defense in its selections. As one friend suggested, "I don't care who they take, as long as he tackles well." I think that says it pretty well.
The Cowboys have a historically bad defense that needs help at nearly every spot except the one that they overloaded on (cornerback), but the other is that they have had a historically bad defense for the last few years and in most off seasons have done almost nothing to fix it. Think about it - with the exception of the 2012 offseason of Brandon Carr and Morris Claiborne, they really have not done much of anything after the 2010, 2011, or 2012 seasons except coordinator changes and some very ill-fated scheme alterations. They have never addressed safety with any conviction and it has certainly been said over and over that they haven't spent a top 80 pick on a defensive lineman since Marcus Spears in 2005. Compare that with the New York Giants who take one up there almost every year, and you can see which franchise values which path.​
 

MonsterD

Quota outta absentia
Messages
8,106
Reaction score
5,803
Wow Billy Turner a first round pick? I mean I like him a lot, but 1st round? No way. I do agree that Benjamin is not even close to a first rounder. Maybe a 3rd-4th.
 

Gaede

Well-Known Member
Messages
17,165
Reaction score
14,127
Awesome; I agree with almost everything Sturm said, exception being Sua Filo and Teddy B
 

Smith22

Well-Known Member
Messages
6,698
Reaction score
1,341
Wow Billy Turner a first round pick? I mean I like him a lot, but 1st round? No way. I do agree that Benjamin is not even close to a first rounder. Maybe a 3rd-4th.

I thought he said best OT in the 2nd in a trade back, after choosing between Ealy, Ward, Crichton, Jernigan, or D. Lawrence in the 1st.
 

DFWJC

Well-Known Member
Messages
59,982
Reaction score
48,729
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
Wow Billy Turner a first round pick? I mean I like him a lot, but 1st round? No way. I do agree that Benjamin is not even close to a first rounder. Maybe a 3rd-4th.

He said Turner at 47
 

DFWJC

Well-Known Member
Messages
59,982
Reaction score
48,729
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan

Oh, I was referring to his trade down for Dallas..with us getting Ward, Crichton, and then Turner at 47.
I see what you're saying.

--------------------------------------

If they can trade back, what are we looking at there? Well, this is why I get a bit excited. I think at #26, you could be looking at Ealy, Jimmie Ward, Scott Crichton, Timmy Jernigan, or Demarcus Lawrence. Grab any of the 4 there.

Then at #35, you can grab the best tackle - Morgan Moses/Billy Turner/Jawuan James or the best DT left of Will Sutton/Dominique Easley/Rashade Hageman/Stephen Tuitt.

And, at #47, you can clean up the scraps, go back to the OL/DL well and grab one of the above names that will surely slide or go for the sliding premium QB prospect.

Are you telling me you wouldn't be pumped about Jimmie Ward, Scott Crichton, and Billy Turner?

I would absolutely consider that draft a success as you would have 3 studs ready to roll for years.
 

xwalker

Well-Known Member
Messages
57,202
Reaction score
64,709
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
Wow Billy Turner a first round pick? I mean I like him a lot, but 1st round? No way. I do agree that Benjamin is not even close to a first rounder. Maybe a 3rd-4th.

Billy Turner is my #1 pet cat, but I don't see him as a 1st round pick. He has 1st round type upside, but he's not as much of a "ready now" type player as you expect to get in the 1st.
 

jterrell

Penguinite
Messages
33,874
Reaction score
15,971
with Sturm on Sua-Filo and Joyner and the speedy LBs. --No way I am taking an athlete at Lb from OhST in round 1 after the Carpneter experience, lol.

Think Turner is woefully overrated. Lot of potential (LT potential) but needs grooming which should drive him down in round 3 or 4. Think he is a Doug Free clone. --which is rather a compliment.

Wish Sturm would drop the silliness with the top 80 pick stuff. Crawford was at 81....
Yes, Dallas had a long time between DL picks... especially IF you ignore Ware and Spencer as DL.

Now with the subtractions of Ratliff, Ware, spencer injury, Brent forced retirement.. well yea NOW it might be prudent to draft some DL high.

Might also be fair to note in 2011 and 20012 drafts the Giants pulled only Marvin Austin in the top 3 rounds. But forget top 80 talk altogether. It's borderline absurd.
 
Top