Brandon Marshall Trade? Yes/NO

Aven8

Well-Known Member
Messages
31,948
Reaction score
52,086
On the 'The Fan' right now Salsbury and the other host are saying that after seeing the Cowboys WR's in training camp that we should trade for Brandon Marshall. They are saying we should do it before the Giants do.

I say forget it. We already made that trade last year at midseason. Play with the hand your dealt. It's also evident that he has some trouble with him, and is not a teamplayer....but if you trade a franchise QB away I can understand his view there.

I say NO!

We need a 1st round pick next year to start drafting OLineman!!!

What do you think?
 
No is the correct answer.

We go with RW11 and hope the development of Hurd and Austin continue.
 
Is he facing potential suspension time? I may be thinking of someone else though.

Personally, I'd pass.

If we're going to spend draft pick(s), my preference would be to pick up a bit more depth on the OL.

I think we're ok with our cast of WRs - as long as our OL plays consistently.
 
No higher than a 3rd. Which wont get it done.
 
Absolutely not.

You don't cut someone like TO and then bring in Brandon Marshall.
 
#1 i don't want a woman beater on my team

#2 i don't want somebody nicknamed "baby t.o"

#3 we have enough playmakers we need linemen on both sides of the ball
 
Woods;2893940 said:
Is he facing potential suspension time? I may be thinking of someone else though.

Personally, I'd pass.

If we're going to spend draft pick(s), my preference would be to pick up a bit more depth on the OL.

I think we're ok with our cast of WRs - as long as our OL plays consistently.

He was aquitted/no suspention..but he wants a trade and has been relegated to 3rd string and now the Scout team.
 
I would have said yes before going to camp. But after seeing camp, I say no.
 
Our WR corps is just fine, everyone will see that once the season gets underway.
 
Aven8;2893934 said:
On the 'The Fan' right now Salsbury and the other host are saying that after seeing the Cowboys WR's in training camp that we should trade for Brandon Marshall. They are saying we should do it before the Giants do.

I say forget it. We already made that trade last year at midseason. Play with the hand your dealt. It's also evident that he has some trouble with him, and is not a teamplayer....but if you trade a franchise QB away I can understand his view there.

I say NO!

We need a 1st round pick next year to start drafting OLineman!!!

What do you think?

Did the bolded part of the statement not clue you in that the answer is an obvious no?
 
Could the Broncos suspend Marshall?

Posted by Gregg Rosenthal on August 20, 2009 12:06 PM ET

Brandon Marshall's rift with the Broncos only appears to be growing with time. Many are starting wonder a natural question: Could this relationship fracture entirely before the regular season?

Bob Glauber of Newsday, writing on Twitter, has an interesting hunch.

"Gut feeling," he writes. "Broncos will eventually suspend Brandon Marshall for conduct detrimental to the team. Reminds me of Year 2 of T.O. In Philly."

While this is couched as speculation, it makes a lot of sense. There are similarities between the Owens and Marshall situations.

If Marshall continues to "disengage" from practice like he did on Wednesday, the Broncos could eventually suspend him for being a distraction to the team.

The Eagles set a precedent that a player can't disrupt the team's objectives while in attendance at practice.

Marshall's situation doesn't seem as poisonous as Owens' in 2005, but we're less than a week removed from Marshall's acquittal on misdemeanor battery charges and the situation has devolved quickly.

The next move is seemingly up to Marshall. He can continue to make noise or he can try to get back in the starting lineup. If he chooses to antagonize the Broncos further, he risks losing part of his 2009 salary.
 
We can only count on Witten and Roy. In that order.

Crayton, Hurd and company couldnt do squat when that other guy was drawying attention away from them. Imagine now?
 
Aven8;2893934 said:
On the 'The Fan' right now Salsbury and the other host are saying that after seeing the Cowboys WR's in training camp that we should trade for Brandon Marshall. They are saying we should do it before the Giants do.

I say forget it. We already made that trade last year at midseason. Play with the hand your dealt. It's also evident that he has some trouble with him, and is not a teamplayer....but if you trade a franchise QB away I can understand his view there.

I say NO!

We need a 1st round pick next year to start drafting OLineman!!!

What do you think?

Noooooo!!!!
 
We should trade Martellus Bennett for Brandon Marshall. We already have a pro-bowl TE. We really don't need Bennett. We can get an explosive receiver that we desperately need.
 
Eddielzn;2893982 said:
We should trade Martellus Bennett for Brandon Marshall. We already have a pro-bowl TE. We really don't need Bennett. We can get an explosive receiver that we desperately need.

You can't be serious right?
 

Staff online

Forum statistics

Threads
474,003
Messages
14,505,691
Members
24,207
Latest member
TomGiantsfan
Back
Top