Breaking Down the Super Bowl Teams All Time

Hostile

The Duke
Messages
119,565
Reaction score
4,544
Cowboys...5 wins, 3 losses...221 points
Giants...3 wins, 1 loss...83 points
Eagles...0 wins, 2 losses...31 points
Commanders...3 wins, 2 losses...122 points

Bears...1 win, 1 loss...63 points
Lions...0 wins, 0 losses
Packers...3 wins, 1 loss...127 points
Vikings...0 wins, 4 losses...34 points

Falcons...0 wins, 1 loss...19 points
Panthers...0 wins, 1 loss...29 points
Saints...0 wins, 0 losses
Buccaneers...1 win, 0 losses...48 points

Cardinals...0 wins, 1 loss...23 points
49ers...5 wins, 0 losses...188 points
Rams...1 win, 2 losses...59 points
Seahawks...0 wins, 1 loss...10 points

Bill...0 wins, 4 losses...73 points
Dolphins...2 wins, 3 losses...74 points
Patriots...3 wins, 3 losses...121 points
Jets...1 win, 0 losses...16 points

Ravens...1 win, 0 losses...34 points
Bengals...0 wins, 2 losses...37 points
Browns...0 wins, 0 losses
Steelers...6 wins, 1 loss...147 points

Texans...0 wins, 0 losses
Colts...2 wins, 1 loss...52 points
Jaguars...0 wins, 0 losses
Titans...0 wins, 1 loss...16 points

Broncos...2 wins, 4 losses...115 points
Chiefs...1 win, 1 loss...33 points
Raiders...3 wins, 2 losses...132 points
Chargers...0 wins, 1 loss...26 points

Giving 5 points for a win and 1 point for a loss here's how it would break down. I'll add points scored as a tie breaker for giggles.

1. Steelers...31 points (147)
2. Cowboys...28 points (221)
3. 49ers...25 points (188)
4. Patriots...18 points (121)
5. Raiders...17 points (132)
6. Commanders...17 points (122)
7. Packers...16 points (127)
8. Giants...16 points (83)
9. Broncos...14 points (115)
10. Dolphins...13 points (74)
11. Colts...11 points (52)
12. Rams...7 points (59)
13. Bear...6 points (63)
14. Chiefs...6 points (33)
15. Buccaneers...5 points (48)
16. Ravens...5 points (34)
17. Jets...5 points (16)
18. Bills...4 points (73)
19. Vikings...4 points (34)
20. Bengals...2 points (37)
21. Eagles...2 points (31)
22. Panthers...1 point (29)
23. Chargers...1 point (26)
24. Cardinals...1 point (23)
25. Falcons...1 point (19)
26. Titans...1 point (16)
27. Seahawks...1 point (10)
T28. Lions...0 points
T28. Saints...0 points
T28. Browns...0 points
T28. Texans...0 points
T28. Jaguars...0 points
 

TheKey

Faster than Felix
Messages
3,216
Reaction score
883
5 points for a win and 1 for a loss? I think 2 and 1 would be better, 3 and 1 tops
 

theebs

Believe!!!!
Messages
27,462
Reaction score
9,207
Bob Sturm did this friday. The steelers are like a point behind us with the win.

The thing to me is, this doesnt mean much.

The steelers are far better run organization and we are dysfunctional mess.

And I dont see the steelers getting worse or the cowboys getting better anytime in the near future, so again all this stuff doesnt mean much.
 

Hostile

The Duke
Messages
119,565
Reaction score
4,544
TheKey;2616556 said:
5 points for a win and 1 for a loss? I think 2 and 1 would be better, 3 and 1 tops
I felt that wasn't enough to give proper credit to the winners.

With 2 points for a win. Steelers would have 13 and so would the Cowboys. They deserve more credit for the extra win.

I also think 1 win is better than 4 losses.
 

phildominator

Active Member
Messages
774
Reaction score
89
Hostile;2616569 said:
I also think 1 win is better than 4 losses.

Precisely.

I wouldn't even give points for SB losses.

I don't think Tom Brady will be wearing last year's AFC Championship ring with his 3 SB rings.
 

burmafrd

Well-Known Member
Messages
43,820
Reaction score
3,379
I would also qualify the wins by dominance as well. Only 1 Steeler win was truly dominant. The other 5 were all pretty close. Meanwhile only 1 Cowboy win was reasonably close. All the others were blowouts. AND who we played also has to be factored in. We BEAT the Dolphins the year before they went undefeated. We beat the Bronco's in what was their best team and year untill late Elway. Even those we lost to are pretty high up there- the Colts were considered a great team. The Bills were considered a great team.
How many great teams did Pitt Beat outside of us?
 

AdamJT13

Salary Cap Analyst
Messages
16,583
Reaction score
4,529
phildominator;2616577 said:
I wouldn't even give points for SB losses.

Getting to the Super Bowl is more of an accomplishment than not getting there.

You're rewarding teams for getting there, not for losing. Five wins and three losses in the Super Bowl is better than five wins and two losses, period.
 

Beast_from_East

Well-Known Member
Messages
30,140
Reaction score
27,231
AdamJT13;2616615 said:
Getting to the Super Bowl is more of an accomplishment than not getting there.

You're rewarding teams for getting there, not for losing. Five wins and three losses in the Super Bowl is better than five wins and two losses, period.

Exactly, winning the Conference title is nothing to sneeze at, even if the team chokes away the SB.
 

Hostile

The Duke
Messages
119,565
Reaction score
4,544
AdamJT13;2616615 said:
Getting to the Super Bowl is more of an accomplishment than not getting there.

You're rewarding teams for getting there, not for losing. Five wins and three losses in the Super Bowl is better than five wins and two losses, period.
Yep, and getting there 1 time and losing is better than never making it at all.
 

juck

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,246
Reaction score
244
Why break it down?:bang2: We have 5 and the Stealers have 6.Who cares about losses and points.W's is all that matters.
 

Hostile

The Duke
Messages
119,565
Reaction score
4,544
juckie;2616783 said:
Why break it down?:bang2: We have 5 and the Stealers have 6.Who cares about losses and points.W's is all that matters.
Because I was bored and didn't feel I needed your permission.
 

Hostile

The Duke
Messages
119,565
Reaction score
4,544
SkinsandTerps;2616824 said:
I dont get the point, of the points scored.
Just separating the many ties.

And reminding that the Cowboys still have scored more points than anyone. :D
 

kingwhicker

BCRSA
Messages
3,290
Reaction score
0
theebs;2616561 said:
Bob Sturm did this friday. The steelers are like a point behind us with the win.

The thing to me is, this doesnt mean much.

The steelers are far better run organization and we are dysfunctional mess.

And I dont see the steelers getting worse or the cowboys getting better anytime in the near future, so again all this stuff doesnt mean much.

I said a few weeks ago that Pittsburgh will have 8 before we have 6.
 

SkinsandTerps

Commanders Forever
Messages
7,627
Reaction score
125
Hostile;2616830 said:
Just separating the many ties.

And reminding that the Cowboys still have scored more points than anyone. :D

But beating the Bills twice really amps that up.
 

fanfromvirginia

Inconceivable!
Messages
4,014
Reaction score
164
I'd probably go 4-1 and net points as the TB. But that's just me.

The list looks about right. As much as it pains me to say it, any list that doesn't have the Steelers on top at this stage would be wrong.
 

Hostile

The Duke
Messages
119,565
Reaction score
4,544
SkinsandTerps;2616882 said:
But beating the Bills twice really amps that up.
Actually playing in 8 games is the biggest contributor.

I'll tell you what I am proudest of. Our 3 losses in the Super Bowl are by a combined 11 points.

V...13-16
X...17-21
XIII...31-35

Meanwhile in our wins we have racked up a 100 point gap.

VI...24-3
XII...27-10
XXVII...52-17
XXVIII...30-13
XXX...27-17

When we win, we win big. When we lose we are in the game. All 3 losses are in Miami, Florida. Site of Super Bowl XLIV...Miami, Florida.

Just weird facts.
 

Hostile

The Duke
Messages
119,565
Reaction score
4,544
fanfromvirginia;2616894 said:
I'd probably go 4-1 and net points as the TB. But that's just me.

The list looks about right. As much as it pains me to say it, any list that doesn't have the Steelers on top at this stage would be wrong.
The reason I went 5 points is because 2 teams have 4 losses. I think a team with 1 win is better than a team with 4 losses.
 

SkinsandTerps

Commanders Forever
Messages
7,627
Reaction score
125
I certainly give your guys their props.

I give them a ton of credit for making it to 8 SB's.

But the points thing...you're just messing with me.

EDIT: Are you going to see the Commanders beat the Pats next Superbowl ?
 
Top