Bryant Gumbel admits to rough season on NFL Network

WoodysGirl

U.N.I.T.Y
Staff member
Messages
79,281
Reaction score
45,652
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
Neil Best
November 13, 2007
Article tools
E-mail Share

It is a SportsWatch tradition as rich and colorful as autumn itself: returning from an early November vacation to bore readers with the latest news on the NFL Network.

This time the stakes are higher than ever. Sunday's victories by the Cowboys and Packers were giant steps toward a Nov. 29 battle of once-beaten mega-brands with national followings - a game that would cause shut-out fans to bang their heads on cable boxes from San Antonio to Sag Harbor.

Friday, I will update you on the NFL vs. the cable industry, so prepare to turn that page if you have a low tolerance for disingenuous gazillionaires. (The network's first game is Thanksgiving night.)

For today, let's keep it simple and check in on play-by-play man/lightning rod Bryant Gumbel, the NFL Network's odd choice for the job and the weakest part of its game telecasts in '06.

"I thought we did a lot of things well last year," he said yesterday. "I'd be the first to admit I wasn't one of them."

Give the notoriously less-than-humble Gumbel credit for honesty, both over lunch a week ago and on a conference call yesterday.

He admitted on the former occasion he was unsure in January whether he would return, and that he was "disappointed" in his performance.

"On the other hand, I did feel that Game 8 was a far cry from Game 1 and I didn't want to walk away from something saying, 'Hey, you know what, I really didn't do it very well,"' he said.

Gumbel, a play-by-play novice, fell into the trap of obsessing over details and vowed to take a step back. "The reality is the way games are done today with the amount of graphics," he said, "it's less of a concern than storytelling and having a conversation."

We'll see what happens this season - those of us who actually can see the games, that is.

Gumbel is smart enough to improve, but he is decades behind his counterparts on other networks. Plus, he lacks their traditional vocal "pipes."

"Whatever my voice is or isn't, it's the only one I've got," he said. "I can't bring it back to God now and say, 'Trade me in."'

Giants dance Fox trot

The Cowboys-Giants game attracted a solid 17.1 percent of homes in the 56 largest markets, confirming the ratings power of those teams (especially the former).

The problem for Fox is it must share America's Team with other networks - Dallas is set for six prime-time games and two on CBS - so it might as well load up on Big Blue.

In three of the first four weeks of flex scheduling, Fox opted to protect Giants games - at the Lions, Bears and Eagles - from moves to prime time.

Fox made those decisions after only four games, when the Giants were 2-2.

FAN out of the Blue?

The Giants have had their feuds with WFAN's Mike Francesa and Chris Russo over the years - notably including Michael Strahan, Jeremy Shockey and Tiki Barber. And Tom Coughlin gave up his old Monday spot, preferring one later in the week that the station declined.

Could something now be brewing between the Giants and the new morning show of Craig Carton and Boomer Esiason? Is Big Blue shutting out the morning crew?

A few Cowboys joined Esiason and Carton last week, but no Giants. Hmm.

Carton's goofy, irreverent chats with the Jets' Thomas Jones - as well as other football figures - likely have not helped the cause.

"We have had a couple requests from them, and due to our schedule and other circumstances, we simply haven't been able to accommodate those requests to date," said Pat Hanlon, VP of communications for the Giants. "But I did enjoy all the Cowboys interviews last week."

Sound bites

The latest from HBO Sports' documentary mill, "Michigan vs. Ohio State: The Rivalry," debuts tonight at 10:30. Two highlights: film of the 1950 game in a snowstorm and a chat with Bo Schembechler the day before he died ... Earlier, at 8, ESPN Classic debuts "Triumph and Tragedy: The Ray Mancini Story," 25 years to the day since Duk-Koo Kim suffered fatal injuries in a fight against him. The show interviews friends of Kim in Korea and has footage of the fateful rounds not seen in a quarter century ... Ch. 9 has re-signed to show 21 Yankees games in 2008 ... Julie Donaldson, an original member of SNY's news team, will not have her contract renewed when it expires in January ... Give Gary Bettman points for bravery: He will become a rare sports talk radio host/league commissioner when he debuts Nov. 27 on the "NHL Hour" on XM. Cool. But David Stern is funnier.

LINK
 

Chocolate Lab

Run-loving Dino
Messages
37,116
Reaction score
11,468
Good for Bryant...

Although I still don't think the NFLN presentation was as awful as some people do. If anything, it was just boring, which I can live with. It's talking over the game, celebrity interviews, idiot commentators who think they are the show, and pretty much everything ESPN does that takes away from the game itself that drives me nuts.
 

theogt

Surrealist
Messages
45,846
Reaction score
5,912
Can he work on lowering his voice? And not sounding nasally?

TYIA.
 

Dcowboy84

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,186
Reaction score
169
to me it didn't have to do with his voice on the broadcasts as much as it was just his inability to do his job correctly...

he didn't seem to know what down it was, what the players' names were, or what football was half the time

i could deal with his voice, it was the stupidity i couldn't stand
 

speedkilz88

Well-Known Member
Messages
36,952
Reaction score
23,100
I don't think there are very many good play-by-play commentators on tv right now(nfl coverage). Gumbel though was just outright terrible last season imo. I can't believe that the Cowboys have kept a guy like Brad Sham on their radio telecast because he is way better than a lot of these guys. I'm sure other teams and colleges have some pretty good guys that should be getting some looks also.
 

LeonDixson

Illegitimi non carborundum
Messages
12,299
Reaction score
6,808
Chocolate Lab;1763606 said:
Good for Bryant...

Although I still don't think the NFLN presentation was as awful as some people do. If anything, it was just boring, which I can live with. It's talking over the game, celebrity interviews, idiot commentators who think they are the show, and pretty much everything ESPN does that takes away from the game itself that drives me nuts.

I agree with your comments re: ESPN.

I would rather see Gumble's brother, Greg, on the broadcast.
 

ddh33

Active Member
Messages
4,934
Reaction score
2
I wasn't crazy about Gumbel, but I didn't dislike the NFLN's presentation either. Like someone else alluded to, they just had a football game on. They didn't do all of the fluff, and that's fine with me.
 

TheSkaven

Last Man Standing
Messages
7,021
Reaction score
5,775
Chocolate Lab;1763606 said:
Although I still don't think the NFLN presentation was as awful as some people do. If anything, it was just boring, which I can live with. It's talking over the game, celebrity interviews, idiot commentators who think they are the show, and pretty much everything ESPN does that takes away from the game itself that drives me nuts.
I agree. When I think back to the NFLN telecasts from last year I remember... the games. The broadcasters/commentators were very invisible and didn't offer might insight. But that's OK. It's certainly better than having to deal with that horrible MNF crew this year.

For my money, Madden and Michaels are the best. And in three weeks, I will be longing for Madden-Summeral when we play the Packers.
 
Top