BTB: Triple Threat Match: Which Quarterback Would You Take?

NewsBot

New Member
Messages
111,281
Reaction score
2,947
usa-today-8927276.0.jpg

The Dallas Cowboys are lucky enough to have Tony Romo as their franchise quarterback for the near future. However, at 36, the time is now to start thinking about who is taking over.

Back in June, our colleague Dawn wrote a column asking the staff who their favorite player to wear the star was and my response was as follows:


Tony Romo - I'm 27 years old, I remember the glory days but not as fondly as I wish I could. I have never rooted or supported a player as much as I have Tony Romo. His story, his ambitions, and his character make him my favorite of all time. I remember the days before he finally got his chance and I would never want to revisit those times. Through Quincy Carter, Drew Henson, Vinny Testaverde, and Drew Bledsoe; it was a revolving door that made it really hard to be a fan sometimes. Tony Romo embodies the underdog and amazing will power to achieve great things. Call me crazy but there is nothing in the world that would make me happier than for him to grab a Lombardi, I would even mortgage the Cowboys' future for guys like him and Jason Witten to get one ring.

I still stand by my sentiments and affinity for the starting quarterback of the Dallas Cowboys, but Tom Ryle's piece on Friday got me thinking. Though this will be the topic of many discussions this offseason, he's right. The Dallas Cowboys shouldn't hesitate to take a chance on landing a quarterback of the future. If Romo stays healthy, when will they ever have the chance to do so again? The idea of just biding your time until you have to take a quarterback, then mortgaging your draft future to do so just doesn't seem smart or a likely option under Stephen Jones. It's the kinds of things that happen in Washington or Cleveland, not Dallas. Still, this upcoming draft could give the Cowboys the opportunity to groom a highly-talented quarterback of the future without feeling the pressure to play him right away. That's something to really wrap our heads around.

As much as the Cowboys have needs elsewhere, it is likely that a 4-12 record isn't going to happen in the rest of Tony Romo's tenure. This is a chance to take a page out of the Green Bay Packers' book while still maintaining a competitive and contending team. With that said, this early into the process, there are three names that continue to surface when discussing this quarterback class. Let's take a look at them.

Paxton Lynch, Memphis


At 6' 6", 230 pounds, there is a lot to like about Lynch's frame and he certainly carries the look of an NFL quarterback. Admittedly, Lynch is not yet a polished passer and still has some work to accomplish with mechanics and footwork. However, all the quarterbacks that are coming out of college these days have some work ahead of them. What talent scouts like about Lynch is his pocket poise, mobility, and his pin-point accuracy. This season, Lynch completed 67% of his passes with 28 touchdowns to only three interceptions. Of course, there are tons of questions surrounding the competition that he faced and he certainly struggled in his bowl game against Auburn. Yet, if you watched him lead the upset against Ole Miss, he was impressive to say the least.

Diving more into what available information there is on Lynch, he's been garnering two very different comparisons. CBS folks have drawn comparisons to Blake Bortles while Rick Gosselin has likened him to Ben Roethlisberger. Either of those is high praise for a kid that currently ranks sixth on Mel Kiper's big board and eighth on Todd McShay's. Again, Lynch would be a passer that would have to grow into the starting role but there is a lot to like about this prospect.

Jared Goff, California


At 6' 4", 210 pounds, Goff has the frame of an NFL quarterback but may be asked to put on some weight at the next level. Goff is widely considered the best quarterback in the nation, and his ability to improve over his time at Cal was impressive. Goff completed 60% of his passes as a true freshman and steadily got better over the next two seasons. In 2014, Goff utterly dismantled his number from the year before having completed 62% of his passes, with 35 touchdowns, almost 4,000 yards, and only seven interceptions.

Goff doesn't have near the cannon for an arm that Lynch does, but don't confuse that for weakness. CBS scouts said he's 'downright surgical' when picking apart defenses. Where Goff outranks all passers in this class is his 'touch'. Both on intermediate and deep throws, he can orchestrate an offense in a truly masterful way. This season, Goff completed 64% passing with 43 touchdowns to 13 interceptions. In his bowl game against Air Force, Goff dropped 593 yards passing with five touchdowns. Nice way to end the year isn't it? Without gushing too hard, Texas defensive coordinator Vance Bedford said of Goff, "This is Aaron Rodgers, he's the real deal." The best part of Goff is that he is aware of his deficiencies and what he has to do to grow at the NFL-level.

Carson Wentz, North Dakota State


At 6' 5", 231 pounds, Wentz follows the mold of Lynch with an NFL-ready frame. He's a quarterback from a small school and has drawn comparisons to Roethlisberger and Joe Flacco. One of his best traits is his ability to extend plays and avoid sacks. Something he shares with the current Cowboys' signal caller. Wentz has good pocket awareness and presence while maintaining an innate ability to throw on the run. Wentz is also very accurate having thrown 16 touchdowns to only two interceptions before suffering a wrist injury that shelved him in the second-half of the season. However, it has been reported that Wentz will be starting for the Bison in the FCS Championship Saturday afternoon.

Also more noteworthy, Wentz is scheduled to play at the Senior Bowl for the North Team, who will be coached by none other than Cowboys' head coach Jason Garrett. A quarterback himself, it will be a huge coup for Garrett and Wade Wilson to get a sneak-peek at the best senior quarterback prospect in the draft. Wentz is already ahead of the other names on this list in one category; pro-style offense. Though Carson would certainly need a redshirt year as well, he's got one of the tighter releases and his football IQ is off the charts. Perhaps his biggest area for concern is his tendency to pre-determine his passes which must be rectified. However, he undoubtedly has a mixture of good arm talent, mobility, athleticism, and field vision. All four of those traits could have him flying up the boards with a good outing in these next two opportunities.

It's not lunacy to think with a bit of health that the Cowboys would be contenders in 2016 with Tony Romo at the helm. This is a true opportunity laying in front of them to finally get the heir-apparent to the Cowboy throne in two or three years. With nine picks total, there will certainly be talented players at other positions for them to fill out their roster. However, the lack of a capable quarterback after Romo's injury was the clear weakness in 2015 and it must be dealt with sooner rather than later. The Cowboys also need to always keep an eye on their future, the NFL landscape can change in an instant.

After the lengthy read, who is your guy? Is it Lynch, Goff or Wentz? Perhaps it's somebody completely different. Let us know.

Poll
If the Cowboys take a quarterback in the first round, who is your choice?

  • Jared Goff
  • Paxton Lynch
  • Carson Wentz
  • Somebody Else

269 votes | Results

Continue reading...
 

DallasBlockersClub

Well-Known Member
Messages
896
Reaction score
818
usa-today-8927276.0.jpg

The Dallas Cowboys are lucky enough to have Tony Romo as their franchise quarterback for the near future. However, at 36, the time is now to start thinking about who is taking over.

Back in June, our colleague Dawn wrote a column asking the staff who their favorite player to wear the star was and my response was as follows:


Tony Romo - I'm 27 years old, I remember the glory days but not as fondly as I wish I could. I have never rooted or supported a player as much as I have Tony Romo. His story, his ambitions, and his character make him my favorite of all time. I remember the days before he finally got his chance and I would never want to revisit those times. Through Quincy Carter, Drew Henson, Vinny Testaverde, and Drew Bledsoe; it was a revolving door that made it really hard to be a fan sometimes. Tony Romo embodies the underdog and amazing will power to achieve great things. Call me crazy but there is nothing in the world that would make me happier than for him to grab a Lombardi, I would even mortgage the Cowboys' future for guys like him and Jason Witten to get one ring.

I still stand by my sentiments and affinity for the starting quarterback of the Dallas Cowboys, but Tom Ryle's piece on Friday got me thinking. Though this will be the topic of many discussions this offseason, he's right. The Dallas Cowboys shouldn't hesitate to take a chance on landing a quarterback of the future. If Romo stays healthy, when will they ever have the chance to do so again? The idea of just biding your time until you have to take a quarterback, then mortgaging your draft future to do so just doesn't seem smart or a likely option under Stephen Jones. It's the kinds of things that happen in Washington or Cleveland, not Dallas. Still, this upcoming draft could give the Cowboys the opportunity to groom a highly-talented quarterback of the future without feeling the pressure to play him right away. That's something to really wrap our heads around.

As much as the Cowboys have needs elsewhere, it is likely that a 4-12 record isn't going to happen in the rest of Tony Romo's tenure. This is a chance to take a page out of the Green Bay Packers' book while still maintaining a competitive and contending team. With that said, this early into the process, there are three names that continue to surface when discussing this quarterback class. Let's take a look at them.

Paxton Lynch, Memphis


At 6' 6", 230 pounds, there is a lot to like about Lynch's frame and he certainly carries the look of an NFL quarterback. Admittedly, Lynch is not yet a polished passer and still has some work to accomplish with mechanics and footwork. However, all the quarterbacks that are coming out of college these days have some work ahead of them. What talent scouts like about Lynch is his pocket poise, mobility, and his pin-point accuracy. This season, Lynch completed 67% of his passes with 28 touchdowns to only three interceptions. Of course, there are tons of questions surrounding the competition that he faced and he certainly struggled in his bowl game against Auburn. Yet, if you watched him lead the upset against Ole Miss, he was impressive to say the least.

Diving more into what available information there is on Lynch, he's been garnering two very different comparisons. CBS folks have drawn comparisons to Blake Bortles while Rick Gosselin has likened him to Ben Roethlisberger. Either of those is high praise for a kid that currently ranks sixth on Mel Kiper's big board and eighth on Todd McShay's. Again, Lynch would be a passer that would have to grow into the starting role but there is a lot to like about this prospect.

Jared Goff, California


At 6' 4", 210 pounds, Goff has the frame of an NFL quarterback but may be asked to put on some weight at the next level. Goff is widely considered the best quarterback in the nation, and his ability to improve over his time at Cal was impressive. Goff completed 60% of his passes as a true freshman and steadily got better over the next two seasons. In 2014, Goff utterly dismantled his number from the year before having completed 62% of his passes, with 35 touchdowns, almost 4,000 yards, and only seven interceptions.

Goff doesn't have near the cannon for an arm that Lynch does, but don't confuse that for weakness. CBS scouts said he's 'downright surgical' when picking apart defenses. Where Goff outranks all passers in this class is his 'touch'. Both on intermediate and deep throws, he can orchestrate an offense in a truly masterful way. This season, Goff completed 64% passing with 43 touchdowns to 13 interceptions. In his bowl game against Air Force, Goff dropped 593 yards passing with five touchdowns. Nice way to end the year isn't it? Without gushing too hard, Texas defensive coordinator Vance Bedford said of Goff, "This is Aaron Rodgers, he's the real deal." The best part of Goff is that he is aware of his deficiencies and what he has to do to grow at the NFL-level.

Carson Wentz, North Dakota State


At 6' 5", 231 pounds, Wentz follows the mold of Lynch with an NFL-ready frame. He's a quarterback from a small school and has drawn comparisons to Roethlisberger and Joe Flacco. One of his best traits is his ability to extend plays and avoid sacks. Something he shares with the current Cowboys' signal caller. Wentz has good pocket awareness and presence while maintaining an innate ability to throw on the run. Wentz is also very accurate having thrown 16 touchdowns to only two interceptions before suffering a wrist injury that shelved him in the second-half of the season. However, it has been reported that Wentz will be starting for the Bison in the FCS Championship Saturday afternoon.

Also more noteworthy, Wentz is scheduled to play at the Senior Bowl for the North Team, who will be coached by none other than Cowboys' head coach Jason Garrett. A quarterback himself, it will be a huge coup for Garrett and Wade Wilson to get a sneak-peek at the best senior quarterback prospect in the draft. Wentz is already ahead of the other names on this list in one category; pro-style offense. Though Carson would certainly need a redshirt year as well, he's got one of the tighter releases and his football IQ is off the charts. Perhaps his biggest area for concern is his tendency to pre-determine his passes which must be rectified. However, he undoubtedly has a mixture of good arm talent, mobility, athleticism, and field vision. All four of those traits could have him flying up the boards with a good outing in these next two opportunities.

It's not lunacy to think with a bit of health that the Cowboys would be contenders in 2016 with Tony Romo at the helm. This is a true opportunity laying in front of them to finally get the heir-apparent to the Cowboy throne in two or three years. With nine picks total, there will certainly be talented players at other positions for them to fill out their roster. However, the lack of a capable quarterback after Romo's injury was the clear weakness in 2015 and it must be dealt with sooner rather than later. The Cowboys also need to always keep an eye on their future, the NFL landscape can change in an instant.

After the lengthy read, who is your guy? Is it Lynch, Goff or Wentz? Perhaps it's somebody completely different. Let us know.

Poll
If the Cowboys take a quarterback in the first round, who is your choice?

  • Jared Goff
  • Paxton Lynch
  • Carson Wentz
  • Somebody Else

269 votes | Results

Continue reading...

Goff
 

Turf Toe

Active Member
Messages
191
Reaction score
79
!. Goff
2. Wentz
3. Lynch

People will boo but we might have to take Wentz at 4
lets wait and see

if Wentz is their guy, then you get him at 4 and move on to the next round. I have no problem with that at all. a reach? maybe. maybe not. But his stock is deff rising
 

Redball Express

All Aboard!!!
Messages
16,253
Reaction score
12,758
!. Goff
2. Wentz
3. Lynch

People will boo but we might have to take Wentz at 4
lets wait and see

My concern is we get cute and try to trade back to make our pick mean more than just taking things at #4.

And drafting too high at a position of need is a definite no-no.

Personnally..

I don't believe in that.

I think you have to be realistic and take the best player at the position of need.

We may have a top pick next year,too.

There is no guarrantee we will improve much next year..

So I think you go for the QB now and start getting him ready.
 

Biggems

White and Nerdy
Messages
14,327
Reaction score
2,254
Right now, the majority of sites have this rating

1. Goff
2. Lynch
3. Wentz

Our hope is that this remains the same going into the draft, especially if Wentz is our target. It will allow us to trade down a little bit, add some picks, and still get our man.

However, the pre-draft process can, and probably will, shake up the rankings of this QB group.

Ideally, what I would love to happen is to trade down from 4 to spots 10-14 and add about 3 picks (cause the team trading up is pining for a stud OT, CB, WR, or even one of the top 2 QBs). #4 for that 10-14 pick, 2nd, 4th, 7th, and 2017 2nd. Then, possibly trading down to the late teens and adding another pick or two ........and at that pick, take Wentz. #10-14 for 18-20, 3rd, and 5th. Now, we have our future QB and 13 more picks to add depth on both sides of the ball......hopefully 1 RB, 2 WR, 1 OT, 1 OG, 2 DL, 2 LB, 2 CB, 1 FS, 1 SS.....

1t - QB Wentz - NDSU
2 -
2t -
3 -
3t -
4 -
4t -
4c -
5t -
6 -
6c -
6c -
6c -
7t -
 

Fredd

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,995
Reaction score
2,238
I fear that any trade-down, if completed by the wrong hands (ie: anyone OTHER than will mcclay), will mean that this once in a decade change gets destroyed to get a truly impact player

that being said, to answer the OP, if I am taking a QB in round 1 @ #4, it is Goff, and I would be really happy with that. I don't think I want Lynch @ #4 and certainly no one else...I see Cook as a draftee with the 2nd or 3rd rd pick (possibly moving up from our 3rd rounder into the 2nd to get cook)...if we don't go QB, I would love to see an impact player like a certain player that got bounced from the ND game for an illegal hit....if that is the case, then they likely move on from Hardy (although, I would like to see Hardy back and stick him at DT on some/more snaps)...I would NOT be upset with a draft that had the first 3 picks be Bosa, Jaylon Smith (could fall to our range based on injury) and then Cook...then use the next two picks (4th rd and comp) on WR/RB (BPA amongst them)
 

egn22

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,884
Reaction score
2,102
I know the thread is about who you would pick and if you forced my hand if take Goff. But I truly believe we won't pick a QB in the 1st rd. Probably not the 2nd either.

Think we go RGIII OR Johnny for the 2nd string QB spot and fill the rest of our holes in the draft.

I personally prefer that method as well. I'd take RGIII
 

Redball Express

All Aboard!!!
Messages
16,253
Reaction score
12,758
I know the thread is about who you would pick and if you forced my hand if take Goff. But I truly believe we won't pick a QB in the 1st rd. Probably not the 2nd either.

Think we go RGIII OR Johnny for the 2nd string QB spot and fill the rest of our holes in the draft.

I personally prefer that method as well. I'd take RGIII

My question becomes..

given your scenario of either RG3 or Manziel..

which I personally favor since it should leave us our draft picks..

when would you do this?

Would you wait until they are released?

Let's assume nobody is going to let either guy just walk.

If it takes a draft pick to make the trade..

what is the right amount?

And..when do you do it?

Draft Day?

Before?

How important is it to bring them in early and get them going?

I realize not much can be done in the way of practice until after the draft.

But does it make a difference in our draft to know we have a QB in-house before the draft?

Or can we do things on the fly not knowing what is happening at QB?

I think this off-season is probably the most important one since we let Landry go and ended Danny White's run with the Franchise.

I'm really curious about what everybody thinks on this.
 

texbumthelife

Well-Known Member
Messages
22,738
Reaction score
23,273
Right now, the majority of sites have this rating

1. Goff
2. Lynch
3. Wentz

Our hope is that this remains the same going into the draft, especially if Wentz is our target. It will allow us to trade down a little bit, add some picks, and still get our man.

However, the pre-draft process can, and probably will, shake up the rankings of this QB group.

Ideally, what I would love to happen is to trade down from 4 to spots 10-14 and add about 3 picks (cause the team trading up is pining for a stud OT, CB, WR, or even one of the top 2 QBs). #4 for that 10-14 pick, 2nd, 4th, 7th, and 2017 2nd. Then, possibly trading down to the late teens and adding another pick or two ........and at that pick, take Wentz. #10-14 for 18-20, 3rd, and 5th. Now, we have our future QB and 13 more picks to add depth on both sides of the ball......hopefully 1 RB, 2 WR, 1 OT, 1 OG, 2 DL, 2 LB, 2 CB, 1 FS, 1 SS.....

1t - QB Wentz - NDSU
2 -
2t -
3 -
3t -
4 -
4t -
4c -
5t -
6 -
6c -
6c -
6c -
7t -

Where are you getting your pick values from? I have a hard time seeing us getting two second round picks from someone and staying anywhere in the top 15. Also, even by the most pessimistic viewpoints, there aren't that many open positions. We already have a lot of young guys at the bottom of the roster, many of whom deserve at least a shot.

As per the original topic, if my hand was forced and they're all there, I would take Goff. I think Wentz has the most upside and Lynch is the wildcard boom/bust guy, but I trust Goff to not bust the most... which scares the **** out of me as a #4 pick.
 
Top