BTB Vela: Is More 46 the Answer to the ILB issue?

WoodysGirl

U.N.I.T.Y
Staff member
Messages
79,281
Reaction score
45,652
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
by Rafael Vela on Feb 3, 2009 2:11 PM CST

Recall that in the five and three quarter game stretch from the Commanders win until the safeties cracked against Baltimore, the Cowboys' D allowed 73 points, an average of just over 12 per game. The D also sacked QBs 32 times in that stretch, an amazing 5.2 per-game average.

One vital adjustment in the late-season resurgence was an increase in the Cowboys' use of the 46 package. The Cowboys ILBs had been pushed around in three early season losses to Washington, St. Louis and New York, and the change in scheme was done to maximize the effectiveness of the personnel on hand.

The 46 had several benefits:



-- it isolated NT Jay Ratliff on centers. With tackles covering up opposing teams' guards, opposing OCs could not scheme to double team Dallas' best rushing lineman. This helped Ratliff up his sack total to 7.5, from 3 the season before.

-- it put more beef in the interior of the defensive line. Chris Canty and Marcus Spears moved inside and gave Dallas more ballast against power rushing attacks.

-- it put Bradie James on the line of scrimmage next to Greg Ellis, improving his rushing effectiveness. James was a highly effective blitzer in '08, getting to QBs from the inside in the base 3-4 set and outside in the 46 set. When Dallas played the Bear package the Cowboys have three OLB blitzing options on the line of scrimmage. James' eight matched Ellis' eight. Their 16 combined sacks complemented Demarcus Ware's 20 nicely.

-- most importantly for this piece,the Bear put Kevin Burnett on the field far more often. Burnett lists at 227 lbs., which is awfully light for a 3-4 inside backer. Donnie Edwards played very well at this weight as an ILB in Wade Phillips' Chargers defenses, but he had the 348 lb. brick wall Jamal Williams in front of him.

Burnett played behind the 298 lb. Ratliff, who was not given two-gap responsibilities very often. When Dallas went 46, all three interior offensive linemen were covered, with Burnett stacked behind them. This gave him the freedom to roam laterally and track down rushers and pass catching backs.

Burnett has been healthy the past two seasons, after suffering multiple injuries in '05 and '06. He showed he could be a very effective nickel linebacker in '07 and last year showed he could produce on 1st and 2nd downs -- if put in a scheme which suited his size.

Burnett will enter free agency in just under four weeks and the Cowboys need to decide if they're going to keep him. The rumors started weeks ago that Dallas would pursue a veteran 3-4 plugger like Ray Lewis. They could, but most of the ILB options -- Lewis, Bart Scott, James Farrior, Eric Barton -- will either be expensive, aged or both. Scott is the only LB on this list under 30 and he's 29.

The cheapest, least-disruptive path may be to keep Burnett and find a big, 330 lb. fire hydrant to cover him. This would allow Burnett to get on the field when Dallas operates in the base scheme and when Ratliff slides over the center in the 46.

Burnett and a high NT draftee like Ron Brace, or Burnett, a draftee and a veteran NT, an old one like Grady Jackson or a younger one like Gabe Watson, would probably cost less than a Ray Lewis, and give Dallas longer-term bang for their free agent bucks.
 

AmishCowboy

if you ain't first, you're last
Messages
5,134
Reaction score
569
Gabe Watson is a RFA, I wonder what round he was drafted in?, I don't see the Cardinals matching becuase they have to deal with Boldin and Dansby.
 

Apollo Creed

Stackin and Processin, Well
Messages
9,027
Reaction score
1,223
Great work by Vela as usual.

Fixing our interior is a lot more important IMO than suring up the safety position.
 

TNCowboy

Double Trouble
Messages
10,704
Reaction score
3,213
Apollo Creed;2619248 said:
Great work by Vela as usual.

Fixing our interior is a lot more important IMO than suring up the safety position.
I agree 100%.

And I think getting Ratliff outside is a huge plus also.
 

KingintheNorth

Chris in Arizona
Messages
18,447
Reaction score
25,836
AmishCowboy;2619214 said:
Gabe Watson is a RFA, I wonder what round he was drafted in?, I don't see the Cardinals matching becuase they have to deal with Boldin and Dansby.

4th round.

They also have to re-sign Bertrand Berry, Antonio Smith, JJ Arrington, and Kurt Warner.
 

DuaneThomas71

Benched
Messages
175
Reaction score
0
It's just a situational defense, and it's a misnomer because it was nothing like Buddy Ryan's 46.
 

ABQCOWBOY

Regular Joe....
Messages
58,929
Reaction score
27,716
AmishCowboy;2619214 said:
Gabe Watson is a RFA, I wonder what round he was drafted in?, I don't see the Cardinals matching becuase they have to deal with Boldin and Dansby.


I would try to sign Dansby if he were available. He's a very good player IMO.
 

khiladi

Well-Known Member
Messages
36,965
Reaction score
37,488
I wonder why Wade chose not to employ Zach in those 4-6 sets. There is no better pass coverage LB than Zach.
 

KingintheNorth

Chris in Arizona
Messages
18,447
Reaction score
25,836
ABQCOWBOY;2619306 said:
I would try to sign Dansby if he were available. He's a very good player IMO.

Dansby wants big time money. I have always liked him and I have no idea how he was ever drafted in the 2nd round but he will get paid this off-season.
 

NextGenBoys

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,252
Reaction score
1,964
AmishCowboy;2619214 said:
Gabe Watson is a RFA, I wonder what round he was drafted in?, I don't see the Cardinals matching becuase they have to deal with Boldin and Dansby.

IIRC I want to say the 3rd. I remember everyone liked his physical measureables, but he had questionable work ethic and character.

Not sure if I've changed my mind on him. I'd like to draft a NT
 

Chocolate Lab

Run-loving Dino
Messages
37,114
Reaction score
11,466
Watson always had work ethic questions at Michigan... Has he eliminated those?

I doubt it. I wouldn't give a guy like that a lot of money.

BTW, the 46 (please don't call it a 4-6) was great this year. One of the best parts about Wade taking over was running that more and the confusion it caused for offensive lines.
 

SLATEmosphere

Benched
Messages
9,633
Reaction score
2
Chris in SoCal;2619275 said:
4th round.

They also have to re-sign Bertrand Berry, Antonio Smith, JJ Arrington, and Kurt Warner.

I think they let Berry go, but Watson would be a really good signing. I've seen him play in the playoffs and he's a monster clogging up the middle. He should be relatively cheap.
 

28 Joker

28 Joker
Messages
7,878
Reaction score
1
I hope the Cowboys resign Kevin Burnett. He is a very valuable player, and he is a good player. Ware and Burnett are about the only two front seven players who can cover the TE in one on one situations. Zach Thomas can drop into the deep middle. The Cowboys were ranked # 4 against the pass in 2008 and Burnett contributed to that statistic by blanketing players like Chris Cooley. With a weak inside linebacker class and the Cowboys needing to address the offensive line and defensive line and safety in the draft, keeping Kevin Burnett would be a smart move. Replacing his skill set and his experience in the defense will be very difficult to do. Burnett can fly, and he will knock your head off. I loved the 46 stuff.

I'm all for drafting Ron Brace, the big 6-3, 329 NT out of Boston College. His value would be perfect with the fifth pick of the third round. The Dolphins might be a threat to take him in round two, towards the end. The Cowboys have the ammunition to leap them if they choose.

This is a great article. Nice job, R. Vela.
 

SLATEmosphere

Benched
Messages
9,633
Reaction score
2
41gy#;2619414 said:
I hope the Cowboys resign Kevin Burnett. He is a very valuable player, and he is a good player. Ware and Burnett are about the only two front seven players who can cover the TE in one on one situations. Zach Thomas can drop into the deep middle. The Cowboys were ranked # 4 against the pass in 2008 and Burnett contributed to that statistic by blanketing players like Chris Cooley. With a weak inside linebacker class, and the Cowboys needing to address the offensive line and defensive line and safety in the draft, keeping Kevin Burnett would be a smart move. Replacing his skill set and his experience in the defense will be very difficult to do. Burnett can fly, and he will knock your head off. I loved the 46 stuff.

I'm all for drafting Ron Brace, the big 6-3, 329 NT out of Boston College. His value would be perfect with the fifth pick of the third round. The Dolphins might be a threat to take him in round two, towards the end. The Cowboys have the amunition to leap them if they choose.

This is a great article. Nice job, R. Vela.

Mckillop from Pitt is highly underrated. He's big, a tackling machine (led the nation in tackles) and can drop back in coverage. I really like him, and should be their with the first pick in the 4th. Burnett is going to want to get paid, and I just dont trust him lasting the whole season.
 

28 Joker

28 Joker
Messages
7,878
Reaction score
1
SLATEmosphere;2619428 said:
Mckillop from Pitt is highly underrated. He's big, a tackling machine (led the nation in tackles) and can drop back in coverage. I really like him, and should be their with the first pick in the 4th. Burnett is going to want to get paid, and I just dont trust him lasting the whole season.

Yeah. That guy out of Pitt is good, but he can't run like Burnett can. Some guys have some bad injury luck, and then, their careers settle down as far as the injuries go. Burnett hasn't missed many games, and he has done everything they have asked him to do during the past 2 years.

I get the money part. It could be a problem. Other teams know he can run.
 

SLATEmosphere

Benched
Messages
9,633
Reaction score
2
41gy#;2619448 said:
Yeah. That guy out of Pitt is good, but he can't run like Burnett can. Some guys have some bad injury luck, and then, their careers settle down as far as the injuries go. Burnett hasn't missed many games, and he has done everything they have asked him to do during the past 2 years.

I get the money part. It could be a problem. Other teams know he can run.

ya you know there's other teams out there that see what you see, and are going to give him starter money. I'm not saying I dont like Burnett, but it's simply because of the money. I would love to keep him if we could.
 

ddh33

Active Member
Messages
4,934
Reaction score
2
I was just talking about this in a different thread, but this is where Jay Ratliff's versatility is a huge help.

I would very seriously consider adding a mammoth NT and sliding Ratliff over to Canty's spot if and when Chris prices himself above the Cowboys' range. Now, you've protected your LBs better, and you've improved your base defense.
 

28 Joker

28 Joker
Messages
7,878
Reaction score
1
ddh33;2619501 said:
I was just talking about this in a different thread, but this is where Jay Ratliff's versatility is a huge help.

I would very seriously consider adding a mammoth NT and sliding Ratliff over to Canty's spot if and when Chris prices himself above the Cowboys' range. Now, you've protected your LBs better, and you've improved your base defense.


I was reading Vela, and he pointed out that a player like Ron Brace would take about 20 plays a game. That would help Burnett. Plus, you run your 46 stuff. Vela says Rex Ryan runs some 46 like Phillips ran last year. It's kind of a hybrid 3-4/46. That's what Vela called it. Plus, half the time, you are in nickel defense or a su-package defense.

I wouldn't move Ratliff, imo. Burnett and Ratliff benefit from the 46.

For the Cowboys, Burnett can be accomodated. It's probably about the money. Giving Owens that money was stupid. If they lose Burnett because of that move, it's going to hurt, big time. Finding guys who can run like him is not easy.
 

BAT

Mr. Fixit
Messages
19,443
Reaction score
15,607
Burnett is not a starter. He is a dime/nickel LBer. There are lots of guys who are more durable and can run, in each and every draft.

Jerry would be foolish to pay big money to 2nd or 3rd tier player. Just replace him with the draft.

If anything, trade Greg Ellis to Kansas City for Derrick Johnson. Throw in Bradie James for a first day pick to boot. Sign Zach to another 1M 1 year contract and draft his replacement. Or package the first day draft picks / player(s) and move up to take a blue chip ILB (Curry, Maualuga, Laurainitis).

Burnett is a decent player, but he is not the answer.
 

theebs

Believe!!!!
Messages
27,462
Reaction score
9,207
burnett was banged up again this year. How does he always miss this stuff?

I honestly wouldnt pay burnett, he is always hurt and i cant imagine anything changes, the guy just has bad luck.

I love what he brings to special teams and he is a good guy but his injury situation has to be a major red flag.
 
Top