Can I get some input from everyone?

[BHendri5]

It seems to me that tonight Feely and last season Garcia, for the eagles, Schaub when he played for the falcons, and the game that the titans played against the texans.

The guys I named they seem to run the offense better than McNabb, Vick, and Young.

I mean the offense just clicked better when they started, the WRs looked like they were good, has anyone else noticed this?

 

[Royal Laegotti]

Well you've got one guy who sucks and is getting old and immobile in McNabb. See Steve McNair.

You've got one guy who was probably concentrating more on dog fighting than football in Vick, not to mention just overall poor judgement!

And Vince is still as his name suggests...Young! I like Vince and think he'll be great eventually but I'm a horns fan and a little biased toward him.

 

[viman96]

Feely looks good. He is hungry. IMO McNabb is burntout on the game.

Talent - desire = McNabb

 

[djtavo]

lets just hope this is not another Romo coming off the bench.

 

[SibannacRex]

Well you've got one guy who sucks and is getting old and immobile in McNabb. See Steve McNair.

You've got one guy who was probably concentrating more on dog fighting than football in Vick, not to mention just overall poor judgement!

And Vince is still as his name suggests...Young! I like Vince and think he'll be great eventually but I'm a horns fan and a little biased toward him.

Vince is playing exactly the way I expected him to play in the NFL. I don't see VY being good enough to warrant a starting QB position after next season.

 

[BHendri5]

Vince is playing exactly the way I expected him to play in the NFL. I don't see VY being good enough to warrant a starting QB position after next season.

I agree with you, but they will have him as their starter, believing he will take them to the SB, and just like teams do they wait to long, before they finally say we need a real QB.

 

[lzppjb]

If you watched the Titans play, you'd realize it's not all Vince's fault. When it comes to his receivers, I've seen better hands on a snake. He has absolutely NOTHING to help him. His OLine is getting beat and Lendale White is a fat tub of goo.

Now his defense is giving up huge plays and tons of points.

 

[dbair1967]

If you watched the Titans play, you'd realize it's not all Vince's fault. When it comes to his receivers, I've seen better hands on a snake. He has absolutely NOTHING to help him. His OLine is getting beat and Lendale White is a fat tub of goo.

Now his defense is giving up huge plays and tons of points.

they came into the day 4th in the league in rush offense, had given up only 19 sacks and had one of the best defenses in the league, not to mention one of th best kickers

but thanks for Vince-apologist input

David

 

[StylisticS]

I was about to say that. Vince looked good the last two weeks his receivers keep dropping the football. There's a reason they signed Mike Williams over the weekend.

 

[playmakers]

Give Vince some recievers and then see if he has it or not. He played awesome last season and I think hes playing hurt this sason. They need a stud running back. I dont think Lendale White is good enough to be a 20 carry a week guy.

Back to the point about the QB;s. All of those players you mentioned are athletes. They rely on their abilty to run where guys like Feely rely on accuracy and pocket prescence. Being such good athletes I think the players you mention neglect that aspect of the game because all of their careers if they had gotten into trouble they could use their athletiscm. Where the other guys need to have everything else down because the lack of athletiscm. So they have to excel in that aspect to stay into the league. Thats why it seems better, it has more structure with the Feelys, etc, where before many plays would resemble school yard plays with Mcnabb, etc. It all comes down to your abilities. In one game it might seem better but over 16 games the creame of the crop will eventually rise and the pretenders would drop off. Thats why they say the backup QB is always the most popluar.