Clark Judge ranks the NFL's top 5 players at each position.

[Seven]

Totally stupid. Crumpler is a close one, that could go either way. But Shockey and Winslow just get more hype than Witten.

Winslow........... ...........#4...........:abuseme:

I don't think I've ever seen rankings skewed as bad as this..........ever.

 

[DallasInDC]

Nice number of posts ya got there!

:eekmouse:

that should take care of that.

 

[followthestar]

Adams might make some lists, and how did they neglect our own Matt McBriar, the leading P in the league, I thought...?

 

[ThreeSportStar80]

It's easy to be critical of passing on McNeil now. Yet he is still no sure thing.

If you remember right McNeil had back problems comming out of Auburn.

As well as he played as a rookie let's not get too carried away, he may have a short career do to back problems.

A man who is 6' 8" with back issues at 22 doesn't feel like a ten - fifteen year guy to me.

Stop with the dumb excuses, they blew it.... Enough said.

 

[ThreeSportStar80]

If McNeil didn't have LT running behind him, he most likely wouldn't be in the top 5.

Dude think before you talk... Did you actually watch his games? Keep in mind he was a rookie and played that well.

 

[tomson75]

Adams might make some lists, and how did they neglect our own Matt McBriar, the leading P in the league, I thought...?

Prisco didn't do a top 5 speical teams list. I'm sure McBriar would've made that list if he had.

 

[Seven]

Prisco didn't do a top 5 speical teams list. I'm sure McBriar would've made that list if he had.

Appears to me, Cortez would of made that list.