Coaching matters

WillieBeamen

BoysfanfromNY
Messages
16,566
Reaction score
48,605
You do know that same elite HC didnt win a SB until he got Patrick Mahomes right?

His last QB, who plays just like Dak, didnt sniff a championship game under Reid either
 

Bagman

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,189
Reaction score
3,265
For some reason , unknown to me, Jerry will usually not invest in top tier coaching.
It's really crazy as their is no salary cap on coaches.
His coaching hires since Jimmy left have overall all been lacking.
One of his major failures as GM.
Top tier coaches usually have very strong personalities and wouldn't be the pushovers that Jerry prefers. He's happy with a yes man. It makes him comfortable. Results are not as important as just being relevant and compliant.
 

JBS

Well-Known Member
Messages
22,457
Reaction score
23,967
You do know that same elite HC didnt win a SB until he got Patrick Mahomes right?

His last QB, who plays just like Dak, didnt sniff a championship game under Reid either
So just don’t bother getting elite coaching. Great idea. What a stupid response.
 

john van brocklin

Captain Comeback
Messages
40,583
Reaction score
45,855
Top tier coaches usually have very strong personalities and wouldn't be the pushovers that Jerry prefers. He's happy with a yes man. It makes him comfortable. Results are not as important as just being relevant and compliant.
Thanks. That's plain sad. :(
 

Rayman70

Well-Known Member
Messages
35,842
Reaction score
34,842
NEVER EVER pick against Reid and Mahomes should be the lesson. Siriani was schooled.
 

WillieBeamen

BoysfanfromNY
Messages
16,566
Reaction score
48,605
So just don’t bother getting elite coaching. Great idea. What a stupid response.
Dont get mad at me because the premise of your thread was a fail


“Elite Coach” Andy Reid before Patrick Mahomes
0 SBs
4 Championship game losses

Why wasnt his elite coaching enough to get those teams over the hump?

He is a better coach than Mike McCarthy but they BOTH won their Super Bowls with a generational talent under center

Sounds to me like we need to get an elite quarterback
 

JBS

Well-Known Member
Messages
22,457
Reaction score
23,967
Dont get mad at me because the premise of your thread was a fail


“Elite Coach” Andy Reid before Patrick Mahomes
0 SBs
4 Championship game losses

Why wasnt his elite coaching enough to get those teams over the hump?

He is a better coach than Mike McCarthy but they BOTH won their Super Bowls with a generational talent under center

Sounds to me like we need to get an elite quarterback
Premise of the thread is not a fail at all. Elite coaching matters. That’s the premise of the thread.
 

JBS

Well-Known Member
Messages
22,457
Reaction score
23,967
Dont get mad at me because the premise of your thread was a fail


“Elite Coach” Andy Reid before Patrick Mahomes
0 SBs
4 Championship game losses

Why wasnt his elite coaching enough to get those teams over the hump?

He is a better coach than Mike McCarthy but they BOTH won their Super Bowls with a generational talent under center

Sounds to me like we need to get an elite quarterback
When did anyone suggest having an elite coach was all that you needed to win? You aren’t understanding the point. And to take mcnabb as far as his did is a testament to how good he is
 

buddahjoe445

Well-Known Member
Messages
505
Reaction score
860
Dont get mad at me because the premise of your thread was a fail


“Elite Coach” Andy Reid before Patrick Mahomes
0 SBs
4 Championship game losses

Why wasnt his elite coaching enough to get those teams over the hump?

He is a better coach than Mike McCarthy but they BOTH won their Super Bowls with a generational talent under center

Sounds to me like we need to get an elite quarterback
some football experts on this board are convinced the Cowboys already have an elite QB and its everyone else's fault why this QB can't process quickly and craps his pants when he faces good defenses. those fans are exactly like Jerry.
 

Ranching

Well-Known Member
Messages
47,144
Reaction score
112,723
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
Yeah, I didn't see CeeDee Lamb walk into the end zone without a defender in sight against the Bucs in the wild card round.

I also didn't see this offense put up 30 plus on this same Eagles defense this year.

Tell me more about what I don't understand.
Lol! Would take a lifetime to tell about what you don't understand! Lol!!!
 

Rayman70

Well-Known Member
Messages
35,842
Reaction score
34,842
Sirianni was schooled, Really? They lost by a last second FG, not exactly schooled.
did u not see the adjustments KC made after Half? Philly never did adjust. U better rewatch the game.
 

EST_1986

Well-Known Member
Messages
10,370
Reaction score
15,032
2023 is the year MM learns to manage the clock. Its a process.
its probably worse this year since he's calling plays, maybe our 2nd head coach will take over those duties while were on offense
 

StarOfGlory

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,825
Reaction score
5,113
Dont get mad at me because the premise of your thread was a fail


“Elite Coach” Andy Reid before Patrick Mahomes
0 SBs
4 Championship game losses

Why wasnt his elite coaching enough to get those teams over the hump?

He is a better coach than Mike McCarthy but they BOTH won their Super Bowls with a generational talent under center

Sounds to me like we need to get an elite quarterback
He did get to a Super Bowl, losing by three to Bellicheat.
 

EST_1986

Well-Known Member
Messages
10,370
Reaction score
15,032
NEVER EVER pick against Reid and Mahomes should be the lesson. Siriani was schooled.
LMAO, I hate the dude but he was far from schooled. If you this he was schooled, our coaching staff would have looked like they had helmets on for reasons other than football ...well bad example they look like that on a normal basis
 

StarOfGlory

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,825
Reaction score
5,113
Sirianni was schooled, Really? They lost by a last second FG, not exactly schooled.
Their D coordinator was schooled in the second half. If Jim Johnson was leading that defense with that talent, the Eagles have another ring. I hope they keep the overrated Gannon.
 

Whirlwin

Cowboy , It’s a way of life.
Messages
27,876
Reaction score
18,572
It’s kind of sad that we even have to discuss this.
 
Top