Wood
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 8,447
- Reaction score
- 5,697
I constructed a formula to compare Cowboys draft the past decade with the other NFL teams.
Points were based on the degree to which each player contributed whether they were All Pros, starter, backup or role player. Then each category was weighted .These points were applied per game played.
For example, An All Pro for that season was worth 7 points per game, regular starters worth 4 points, special teamers 1 point. It didnt matter if they were playing on a different team, ita about the scoutong department recognizing talent.
The Cowboys ranked at #5 overall. Their greatest success was in drafting a large number of perennial All Pros. However, they fell hard to the middle of the pack in drafting role players, backups and special teamers.
I havent posted my findings yet but....Spoiler Alert!.....The top team is Seattle. Worst is the Jets. The real shocker is the high rankings of both Cincinatti and Cleveland.
As far as 1st rounders, yes good job.....completely neutrialized by the results of the pathetic 2nd round.
For me playoff success is biggest indicator of draft/FA projections than All-Pro votes. High profile teams like Cowboys will always get more national TV games & sports media attention. This national attentions will inflate All-Pro votes from fans. This is why every year we seem to hear Cowboys have one of most talented teams in league but ultimately don't even get close to sniffing championship game. There is a disconnect between actual talent and perceived talent.