Dak is a career Top 7 QB

[Yobwocs]

Dak is a career top 12-16 quarterback. Period.

Every list has him Top 7 going into preseason. go away. He's Top 7 case closed

 

[thunderpimp91]

Who really cares about wins and losses as long as your qb makes top 10 lists?

 

[Big D]

What is also consistent is our D sucks.

And has for back to back very good/great QBs.

 

[erod]

Every list has him Top 7 going into preseason. go away. He's Top 7 case closed

Delusional.

The dude craps his pants in every big game he plays against real contenders.

 

[CowboysLakerBamaFan]

Top 7 DALLAS QBs all time?

Hail Yes!

if you subtract "DALLAS" then I think you forgot a couple of zeros *and No, I don't mean Rockpoot and TheMoronContinues when referring to a couple of Zeros"

 

[Bigrandrn]

You said it yourself. This is why he will never be a truly elite quarterback. He is Mr. Inconsistent. He will show up big in some games and be very mediocre in others. He doesn't show up in most of the playoff games. Even today, he had a couple of dimes and also a bunch of overthrown balls that were caught despite the bad throws.

But he plays more good than bad….thats why he’s always near the top at QB stats, league leading in some seasons. U don’t lead the league in TD passes and make top 1-3 offenses by being mediocre.

 

[SteveTheCowboy]

This is what I mean. We can't even enjoy wins around here anymore without people having to dump on Dak or something else. We know what his playoff record is. We're 30 minutes removed from a victory and the negativity can't even wait a day to return.

If you need the innerwebs to enjoy the win your life sucks!

 

[WillieBeamen]

Nonsense.


Hes a .500 QB outside this terrible division.

 

[Rockport]

A good team is coming next week so unfortunately we most likely get to see Dakchoka.

You’re a hoping.

 

[Yobwocs]

Nonsense.


Hes a .500 QB outside this terrible division.

You realize he's leading the league in Touchdowns thru 2 weeks right?

And he leads all QBs all time (in Super Bowl era) in ppg at home for a career right? #2 is Steve Young and #3 is Drew Brees.

Home or road isn't based on division or non division opponents. Or strong or weak. You can get anyone at home. If our record at home isn't as good as it should be, it's because the defense always underperforms.

And there's this:

 

[CowboysQC]

He never had any issue feasting on trash teams like he did today, next week we’ll see the career low IQ deer in the headlights bum he turns into every time he faces a real defense.

 

[DandyDon1722]

Some years he's Top 5..... 2016, 2020, 2023, 2025

Some years he's about 9-11.... 2019, 2021, 2022

Some years he's well outside the top 12.... like 14-16..... 2017, 2018, 2024

But what's consistent is that he's a career Top 7 QB.

Any opinion different is going against the grain.

He's also gonna be in the Top 5 in every list this week. Williams, Lawrence, and Jackson (MVPs in Week 1) all had a bad week, so everyone behind them moves up.

Giants game last week is an aberration. We scored TDs on half our possessions. Allen and Mahomes didn't score TDs on half their possessions and they're a combined 3-0. They just had way way more possessions.

YAWN - it just doesn’t matter. Honestly it just doesn’t matter.

 

[GMO415]

If he can't win DAL it's 6th then who cares?

 

[Chasing6]

He never had any issue feasting on trash teams like he did today, next week we’ll see the career low IQ deer in the headlights bum he turns into every time he faces a real defense.

When do we see our good defense?

 

[plymkr]

A SB would work too

Yeah I’m leaning more towards a Super Bowl too

 

[triplets_93]

You said it yourself. This is why he will never be a truly elite quarterback. He is Mr. Inconsistent. He will show up big in some games and be very mediocre in others. He doesn't show up in most of the playoff games. Even today, he had a couple of dimes and also a bunch of overthrown balls that were caught despite the bad throws.

 

[buybuydandavis]

That 41 QBR in 2024 was quite a bit further outside the 12...

I was really surprised at how well he turned it around in 2025.

 

[G2]

Nonsense.


Hes a .500 QB outside this terrible division.

False. Just simply untrue.

 

[lopey]

Before we anoint him can he play good against a real good defence. Sunday we will see