Dak ranked 8 on final PFF QB rankings

[Yobwocs]

I disagree.

I think Dak should be above Allen, Murray, and Herbert.

Mahomes at #10, Carr at #17. Big Ben at #31.

 

[Swagger]

I disagree.

I think Dak should be above Allen, Murray, and Herbert.

Mahomes at #10, Carr at #17. Big Ben at #31.

I disagree...Big Ben is too high at 31

 

[DoctorChicken]

I can agree with that.

I definitely wouldn’t put him above Allen and Herbert. Mahomes being that low is laughable. He’s had his worst season as a pro and still threw 37 TDs and helped his team make the playoffs.

 

[Yobwocs]

I disagree...Big Ben is too high at 31

You didn't see the Baltimore and Cleveland game? Dude's clutch. And while his defensive line deserves credit for Cleveland, it was his last hurrah at Heinz Field and he answered by giving the fans one last stab at the playoffs. You can argue that he doesn't deserve to be in the Top 20, but you truly think someone who willed a down Pittsburgh roster to the playoffs is the 32nd QB in the NFL?

 

[CowboyinMD]

I disagree.

I think Dak should be above Allen, Murray, and Herbert.

Mahomes at #10, Carr at #17. Big Ben at #31.

That's right where I'd expect him to be, near the bottom of the T10. That's. Where. Dak. Is. Folks! He's not top 5, even Dak supporters agree with that. He doesn't 'suck' either.

Fortunately for Dallas, Dak has a better supporting cast than most, though it all comes down to the running game.

Also notice that Dak in '21 came in 2 spots higher than his career rank. Perhaps not great by some people's standards, but on par or better than Dak's career average. I'll take it.

 

[glimmerman]

So he is top 8..

 

[Mr_437]

Take your wins where you can get them...he has Mahomes behind Dak, and we know that's false. Dak can shoot up these list with some Playoff wins.

 

[Swagger]

I can agree with that.

I definitely wouldn’t put him above Allen and Herbert. Mahomes being that low is laughable. He’s had his worst season as a pro and still threw 37 TDs and helped his team make the playoffs.

Agree. Cousins above Mahomes...yeah right. Derek Carr is too low imo. He hasn't had a good o line yet still generally been very good. No way he's that much lower than Cousins.

 

[JJHLH1]

Fair.

There is a gap separating the top-3 from everyone else.

As an aside, if Herbert is your QB and you fail to make the playoffs the head coach needs to be fired.

 

[Swagger]

You didn't see the Baltimore and Cleveland game? Dude's clutch. And while his defensive line deserves credit for Cleveland, it was his last hurrah at Heinz Field and he answered by giving the fans one last stab at the playoffs. You can argue that he doesn't deserve to be in the Top 20, but you truly think someone who willed a down Pittsburgh roster to the playoffs is the 32nd QB in the NFL?

I did. To be fair I was kind of half joking. I agree he did well in those games but it's just a bit sad to see a former excellent QB being unable to make good throws over 15-20 yards.

 

[Crown Royal]

Yeah any given year that 5-10 are all probably right next to each other depending on the week.

 

[MountaineerCowboy]

I disagree.

I think Dak should be above Allen, Murray, and Herbert.

Mahomes at #10, Carr at #17. Big Ben at #31.

Why should he be ahead of Murray, Herbert, and Allen?

 

[Portnoy1]

I disagree...Big Ben is too high at 31

Yeah that Monday night game was telling. 35 pass attempts at the half and only 90yards. In other news Joe Burrow is a beast

 

[stiletto]

Overall coming back from a pretty devastating injury he had a good season, that ranking is pretty good. He had some troubles after that calf injury even though I don't think they want to admit it.

I am hoping that it is finally healed up and he can rock it during the playoffs. Those calf injuries seem like a pia to get over for all players.

 

[BigD_95]

I disagree.

I think Dak should be above Allen, Murray, and Herbert.

Mahomes at #10, Carr at #17. Big Ben at #31.

so he racks u 5 TD and high comp % against Eagles 4th string Defense. Where was he before last week?

 

[pansophy]

Also explains why I’m happy at the number 3 seed. At the 4th seed we would likely see 3 QBs higher than Dak and at the 3rd seed we can only see 2 of them.

Let LA and the Cards eliminate each other.

 

[Yobwocs]

Why should he be ahead of Murray, Herbert, and Allen?

I know you're just a Dak hating troll.

But Murray threw 7 TDS in the last 7 games and went 2-5. The outlier game was the Cowboys. 1 TD per game is exactly why his team isn't winning.

Josh had Jacksonville, Indy, NE 1, and Atlanta. Not easy turds to flush. Dak was only bad against KC and Denver. He wasn't horrible against Arizona... not great, but 3 holding calls in 9 drives is the reason why we lost. I can point to maybe 2 drives that was his fault.

Herbert is only above Dak in yards. Dak beats him in rating, completion %, less INT. And 1 less TD but that's only because he played in 1 less game. Plus Herbert is 9-8, but you'll find a way to say the Texans loss wasn't his fault where if Dak had the same type of performance in a loss you'll say it's his fault.

 

[darthseinfeld]

I disagree.

I think Dak should be above Allen, Murray, and Herbert.

Mahomes at #10, Carr at #17. Big Ben at #31.

Iirc PFF puts some emphasis on running, and Allen has 700 rushing yards and 6 TD's. I dont agree with it, but thats likely why he is ahead

 

[mattjames2010]

It wasn't a great year overall for QBs.

 

[darthseinfeld]

Agree. Cousins above Mahomes...yeah right. Derek Carr is too low imo. He hasn't had a good o line yet still generally been very good. No way he's that much lower than Cousins.

Cousins limitions never show up in a stat sheet. You look at his stats and you may think he is elite. I mean, its hard to argue with 30+ TD's, under 10 INT's and a QB rating over 100.

Its when you watch him play, especially when it matters, that you'll see he really just an average QB