Dak Top 5. Let's talk argument against it

[Gambit]

Dak's been playing 4 years longer.

Statistically speaking Dak is better here too.

Accounting for injuries for both players Daks come from behind % is 16.08% vs Hurts 15.62%

As a comparison only Mahomes tops Dak at 16.94% of comebacks in games played.

 

[Relayer]

Statistically speaking Dak is better here too.

Accounting for injuries for both players Daks come from behind % is 16.08% vs Hurts 15.62%

As a comparison only Mahomes tops Dak at 16.94% of comebacks in games played.

That's nice. That and $5 will get you a cheap cup of coffee. But it won't make gross stats for 6 years and 10 years equivalent.

 

[thunderpimp91]

And the established standard is, you're wrong.

Based on what?

 

[starfan1]

This fanbase is so starved for success I think it’s caused brain rot to some of you

QBs don’t win championships teams do. It takes multiple units and complimentary play.

If the offense sputters it’s not always because the QB makes 60 mil and it’s his fault that just stupid. And when the offense is successful it’s isn’t because the qb it’s because of the team

I think there’s a faction of this fanbase that want the team to fail so they can push their narrative

Yesterday was a huge win despite their now 0-4 record the Texans have a pretty good defense and they have been a playoff team the last 3 years anyhow.

This team has a lot to overcome. Defense is bad, the OLine is up and down with a turnstile at RT. Coaching leaves alot to be desired at times. We don’t run the ball particularly well and don’t stick with it enough to see if it will get better.But they have a top WR corps and that’s the strength of the team and a top 10 most likely 5 QB play at the moment. They went into reliant and got the dub. Enjoy the win. The amount of people that get triggered on this qbs success and failures are astounding.

My MVP yesterday was my boy CeeDee!! And can we leave Ferguson in houston

Time to be ready for the Bucs they will bring additional challenges.

 

[Gambit]

That's nice. That and $5 will get you a cheap cup of coffee. But it won't make gross stats for 6 years and 10 years equivalent.

Its exactly what it does, lol.

 

[kskboys]

After Mahomes/Burrows/Purdy/Allen/Stafford, there's a clusterfudge from 6-15. Put Dak in there anywhere you like, does it really matter?

Maye is also edging up the board, and well then there's Jackson. Caleb Williams has shown signs. Lawrence is starting to look really solid. Jayden can play when he's not hurt. Bo Nix might be a stud, hard to say at this point. Even Bryce Young is starting to really put up some numbers. And how about Darnold? Has looked great for 2 seasons now. And where do we put Goff? Cousins is tearing it up in LV.

Put Dak in top 5, put him in next 5, or the next 5, whatever floats your boat.

 

[kskboys]

Valid question. Are we rating them this season only, or career? Purdy is easy top 5 this season, prolly top 3. Barbie playing very well. Maye also. Bryce Young is too.

If it's career, then Rodgers and Mahomes and Allen top the list, followed by Stafford and Goff or Dak or Burrow or Purdy or Barbie or Nix.