Dak vs Brady

[Irvin88_4life]

Without Belichek i would take Dak and it's no question. Dak can bring stuff that Brady can not.

 

[Cowboysfan917]

I'd take Brady, Rodgers, Brees, Stafford, Ryan, Rivers, Big Ben, Carr, over Dak.

I'd also take a healthy Luck over him.

Maybe even Mariota,Winston, and Alex Smith.

That puts Dak around 13th in the league which is where I think he ranks.

 

[PJTHEDOORS]

I'd take Brady, Rodgers, Brees, Stafford, Ryan, Rivers, Big Ben, Carr, over Dak.

I'd also take a healthy Luck over him.

Maybe even Mariota,Winston, and Alex Smith.

That puts Dak around 13th in the league which is where I think he ranks.

lol. Whatever...i'm guessing you'd take a healthy Romo over everyone but Brady and maybe Rodgers. Big shock.

 

[Toruk_Makto]

Wut

 

[noshame]

I'd take Brady, Rodgers, Brees, Stafford, Ryan, Rivers, Big Ben, Carr, over Dak.

I'd also take a healthy Luck over him.

Maybe even Mariota,Winston, and Alex Smith.

That puts Dak around 13th in the league which is where I think he ranks.

Well, we're all thankful you don't think.

 

[Sarge]

 

[Ultra Warrior]

You'd have to take Brady. Proven winner. 7 Super Bowl appearances & 5 titles. Dak hasn't even gotten a Playoff win yet.

 

[Pants]

Does this assume Brady with his current coaching staff and a pre-season to get acclimated to the current team? Then yes, otherwise, no...just dropping Brady in doesn't guarantee anything

(I can't believe this is a topic)

kinda like, with all of the man-love for Rico, would you trade him for one season of Gronk if it....blah, blah, blah???

 

[landroverking]

Brady=Goat.

 

[aria]

Is this the Twilight Zone?

 

[1972COWBOY]

I would take a QB that can do well exclusively throwing in the pocket.

 

[JBond]

Got to wonder how far Brady's play would fall under the red headed genius. He has managed to make Dez irrelevant and is trying to do the same with Beasley. That being said, I would still take Brady for this season and two more over Dak. I like Dak, but he is clearly a work in progress. It would be nuts to take him over Brady.

 

[PJTHEDOORS]

You'd have to take Brady. Proven winner. 7 Super Bowl appearances & 5 titles. Dak hasn't even gotten a Playoff win yet.

lol. And Dak has played a total of 18 regular season games. Go look at Brady's qb ratings his early years, when he was in mid-high 80%.

 

[erod]

For one season, I'd take several quarterbacks over Dak.

 

[visionary]

Mods can we sticky this thread? It is too important

 

[Ultra Warrior]

lol. And Dak has played a total of 18 regular season games. Go look at Brady's qb ratings his early years, when he was in mid-high 80%.

The OP asked for this season. 1 QB just won his 5th Super Bowl & 1 didn't. Pretty easy answer. Brady also won a Super Bowl in his "early years" so those stats don't mean much. Championship trumps all that nonsense.

 

[CalPolyTechnique]

Oh, just for this season?

Yeah, I can see why you wouldn't take Tom Brady. His level of play has plummeted this season:

1,092 yards
64.5% comp.
8 TDs, 0 INTs
121.5 QB rating.