Weak arm. Long motion. Inaccurate in college. Only worked from the spread.
But Montana had a weak arm, too, which is why he went later.
Leadership off the charts in Dak.
His arm isn't weak, it's just not a cannon. Teams like QB's with big arms because it opens up the playbook for them. But, you can have a cannon like Wentz and have a long, poor motion that takes more time to get to the receiver and is inaccurate and the cannon really doesn't matter.
His throwing motion in college wasn't 'long.' And now it's a very short, compact overhand motion.
He didn't work from the spread either, that was one of the major misconceptions. He worked in a pro style offense that was very similar to what Linehan runs except it was always from the shotgun.
Now Dak's throwing motion is excellent, his ball placement on short and intermediate passes is excellent (better than Romo), he throws excellent on the run (to his right and his left), he's excellent at setting up screens, using RPO's and was very good at reading defenses and manipulating safeties and linebackers.
I think people that don't believe in Dak think he's a bit too good to be true. Given that he was a 4th round pick and that many think so little of our Front Office (which is really stupid) that they tend to think we could have never gotten this lucky.
And then there's the Romo lemmings who simply dislike Dak because he's not Romo and think a healthy Romo would have been better than Dak this past season, despite Dak putting up a higher QBR in one season than Romo ever has. And anything Romo did well that Dak has yet to prove himself on, they use that against him. There's some great fallacy that Romo was a master at reading defenses while reality was that he was very good, but he made his fair share of mistakes and his slowing down of the offense often worked against us (tough to get other players on the same page with constant audibling right before the snap).
We've got to learn from the mistakes we made during the Romo era, particularly think that a QB is as good as Brady or Peyton and thinking that his game should be played like them. Romo isn't that type of QB...he's a QB that works best when you limit his throws under 36 passes or so, use the run game, set up for the intermediate and deep passes off of play action, have him roll out a few times and get him to climb up the pocket where he was deadly.
Instead, we wanted to make him into a heavy throwing, dink-n-dunk QB who stayed all the way back in the pocket like Brady that over-audibles. Those aren't his strengths.
With Dak, I see a QB that is tremendous on intermediate and short passes, great on screens and has the ball handling for play fakes. That can run and pass effectively on RPO's. I'd like to see him develop his deep passing further and see what comes from that, but we need to tailor a scheme and supporting cast to fit his strengths and that means a better threat at the Z-Receiver than Williams (too small of a catch radius and can't get open enough underneath), always having tailbacks that can pass receive and run out of the pistol/shotgun, having a running game that runs well off the edge so it can open up the bootlegs. And probably more receivers and tight ends that can run pivot routes and get YAC than your Brice Butler or T-Will or Jason Witten types (although Witten's blocking is important).
Don't try to make Dak into what you think a QB should be. Work with Dak's strengths and weaknesses to exploit his strengths and hide his weaknesses.
YR