Defending Kiffin: Week 12 - Gashed On The Ground

jobberone

Kane Ala
Messages
54,219
Reaction score
19,659
Bob's Blog - Live from Lewisville
"Everything we are facing is a competition. How are you going to help us win today?" - Jon Daniels
Daily Commentary on the Dallas Sports Scene - By Bob Sturm - Sportsradio 1310, The Ticket

Wednesday, November 27, 2013
Defending Kiffin: Week 12 - Gashed On The Ground

Often, in sports, after time, people don't want to hear about injuries or "excuses" as to why a team isn't playing very well in certain departments. My response is generally simplistic, but I believe it to be true: There is a reason that different players can demand different salaries, rather than have some flat fee based on service time like some ways to make a living (military, police), and that clearly is that all players are not close to created equal. And, if you lose enough highly compensated players, invariably, their absence should either greatly affect the product you can put on the field, or you are paying the missing players too much money.

That is why, despite the easy target that is available wearing the defensive coordinator title up in the press box, it is difficult for me to blame Monte Kiffin for what is going on against the Cowboys recently on the ground. And, with Oakland landing in Dallas today for the Thanksgiving game, we should prepare for Oakland to attempt to do the same thing the Giants did on Sunday.

And what did the Giants do? Well, they became the 3rd team this season to run for 200 yards in a game against the Cowboys. From 2003-2012, the Cowboys had only allowed 7 200 yard rushing games for the entire decade in 160 games (4%), but in 2013 we have moved that to 3 out of 11 games (27%).

And yet, as we look at many of these plays, we are reminded that the Cowboys are not a team that teams run at over the years. This has not been a festering problem. In fact, it started getting bad last year, and had roared out of control this season. Which is why we must consider the absences of fine run stuffers Anthony Spencer, Jay Ratliff, and Sean Lee - who are all players who have helped make the reputation what it is here - and understand the alternatives who are there in their place.

Most players in the football food chain are not "all situation" players. They are either strong players in passing situations or running situations. Those who are excellent in both are those who get paid a ton of cash and also who you cannot afford to lose to injury and be fine. Because if you have players that are either strong against the pass OR strong against the run, then you get to a spot where your opponent sees what you have decided to try and stop by which players you put on the field. Then, if they are in a standard down and distance, they simply consider who you have put on the field and then call a play accordingly. If they see you have put little defensive ends who are good at pass rushing but not very strong anchors against the run, they simply run right at them and then you see what we saw on Sunday.

Which was a textbook example of running game carnage.

http://sturminator.blogspot.com
 

jobberone

Kane Ala
Messages
54,219
Reaction score
19,659
Here's a tease:


Here are a few of those runs:



Here is a zone play to the right with a simple cutback left from Andre Brown after the Cowboys are collapsed - most notably, Everette Brown and Corvey Irvin are washed away there. Also, the Linebackers can't get off their blocks which is a familiar theme and a reputation that Ernie Sims has had for much of his NFL Career after being a top pick.
 

Corso

Offseason mode... sleepy time
Messages
34,768
Reaction score
63,193
Sims went a wee bit overboard before he recognized what was going on there.

He made the tackle, but that was his only saving grace.
 

cowboys1981

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,524
Reaction score
4,484
If these guys can maintain their lane see should elimante these 200 yard games. In recent memory teams passed on us primarily and with that we changed our entire secondary when we should've built the trenches first.

I'm almost tempted to recommend a 5-2 up front and stack the "A" gap lol.
 

jobberone

Kane Ala
Messages
54,219
Reaction score
19,659
Sims went a wee bit overboard before he recognized what was going on there.

He made the tackle, but that was his only saving grace.

I have only had time to look at a limited amount of film this year but I watched the condensed version of the NY game but not the All-22. What I saw confirmed what I thought was a lot of over pursuit. I mentioned in another thread that the scheme calls for them to shoot the gaps with little gap control. Normally the LBers eat up the inside runs but with Lee out there just isn't anyone who can get to the runner fast enough. That's part of it but the other is Kiffin is apparently not able to run much shoot and hold or other gap control with the guys he has. That's more of an educated guess as I haven't seen enough to say that with any certainty but I'd be surprised if these guys can do that with degree of consistency. Then you add in some poor angles and tackling by the DBs and you can't stop the run. Stopping the run is generally the first order of the day. We ain't doing so good.
 

jobberone

Kane Ala
Messages
54,219
Reaction score
19,659
If these guys can maintain their lane see should elimante these 200 yard games. In recent memory teams passed on us primarily and with that we changed our entire secondary when we should've built the trenches first.

I'm almost tempted to recommend a 5-2 up front and stack the "A" gap lol.

That's old school. While the 5-2 departed in the middle 50s (in large part due to Tom Landry) it sneaks into the current game on a few plays and even entire games. Also the 46 is a variant of the 5-2 IIRC.
 

BAT

Mr. Fixit
Messages
19,443
Reaction score
15,607
Sims went a wee bit overboard before he recognized what was going on there.

He made the tackle, but that was his only saving grace.

Sims had trouble all game long getting off blocks. Not sure why Cowboys do not move Carter inside (like last season) and have the smaller Sims play WILL. Even Wilber looked small and struggled when OL got their hands on him at SAM.

But moving Carter to MLB seems like a no brainer here. Otherwise teams will continue to gash Cowboys by running up the gut. Cowboys front 7 are just getting out physicaled. Nevis, Irvin and Brown were getting buried against the run.
 

jobberone

Kane Ala
Messages
54,219
Reaction score
19,659
Sims had trouble all game long getting off blocks. Not sure why Cowboys do not move Carter inside (like last season) and have the smaller Sims play WILL. Even Wilber looked small and struggled when OL got their hands on him at SAM.

But moving Carter to MLB seems like a no brainer here. Otherwise teams will continue to gash Cowboys by running up the gut. Cowboys front 7 are just getting out physicaled. Nevis, Irvin and Brown were getting buried against the run.

The Mike has more coverage responsibilities and thats' been a problem for Carter. I don't know how Lemon plays in coverage but if he can then he's not bad at getting to the ball in the running game. I suspect that's not a strong point of his game but I don't know.
 

BAT

Mr. Fixit
Messages
19,443
Reaction score
15,607
The Mike has more coverage responsibilities and thats' been a problem for Carter. I don't know how Lemon plays in coverage but if he can then he's not bad at getting to the ball in the running game. I suspect that's not a strong point of his game but I don't know.

Who is Lemon? And the MIKE in this scheme plays mostly zone coverage mostly getting to right depth while the OLBs have more man coverage responsibilities. Carter gets in trouble when he is in man and gets caught in trail position.
 

jobberone

Kane Ala
Messages
54,219
Reaction score
19,659
Who is Lemon? And the MIKE in this scheme plays mostly zone coverage mostly getting to right depth while the OLBs have more man coverage responsibilities. Carter gets in trouble when he is in man and gets caught in trail position.

It doesn't sound as if we are disagreement. Orie Lemon. I didn't even check to see if he was on the roster much less get any snaps.
 

BAT

Mr. Fixit
Messages
19,443
Reaction score
15,607
It doesn't sound as if we are disagreement. Orie Lemon. I didn't even check to see if he was on the roster much less get any snaps.

I thought you meant Orie but not sure since he's not on team. Would rather have Lemon than Lawrence or Bosworth right now. Lemon was surprisingly good in zone for a guy that did not have a lot of speed.
 

TTexasTT

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,930
Reaction score
737
In that particular gif posted above it doesnt look as if Carter played it as badly as it looks initially. He kept the play contained by playing his blockers outside shoulder. However, a LB of Bruces physical abilities should be able to come off that block without much of an issue.

Sims is a gifted talent as well. That saves him quite often but IMO he lacks the instincts and at this point in his career he may never develope them. Here is an example from last year. He is just a step behind Carter.. From when after Lee went down last year.

2mwtgeb.gif
 

jobberone

Kane Ala
Messages
54,219
Reaction score
19,659
I thought you meant Orie but not sure since he's not on team. Would rather have Lemon than Lawrence or Bosworth right now. Lemon was surprisingly good in zone for a guy that did not have a lot of speed.

I thought he was supposed to be signed. Oh, well, that's what I get for not following up. Mox nix anyway.
 
Top