Do we have the worst QB situation in the NFC East?

[ElGatoGrande]

No. The Giants have the worst QB situation in the division. Russell Wilson is washed. Winston is far worse than Hurts, Daniels, and Prescott.

Generally I would much rather be NYG picking up one of this year's top QB prospects though I'll admit those prospects don't really look too good.

 

[Paperbag]

Philly-Superbowl winning QB this past season

Washington- Rookie Phenom, will he be better, worse, or ok in his 2nd season

NY- Just signed 2 veteran Qbs- Winston and Wilson, can one of them win them some games and be better than what they've had in recent years, or will their age be too much?? Will they get a rookie QB with their first pick who could energize that franchise??

Dallas- Prescott who is coming off a serious injury to his leg, can he recover and play like a 60 million dollar QB??


Do we have the worst situation, I know it's too early to tell!! Please give your thoughts

I’m not sure
We definitely are behind Philly and Washington but wouldn’t say New York is in any better shape then us other than they have a backup

 

[leeblair]

No. The Giants have the worst QB situation in the division. Russell Wilson is washed. Winston is far worse than Hurts, Daniels, and Prescott.

Russell Wilson is still better than Dak.
Russell Wilson was better than Dak is when he was twelve.

 

[McKDaddy]

at this point - 60M for an aging injured qb and no real backup on the team to speak of...I would say that puts us in a worse spot than NY (at this point).

they have a room, we have a guy.

 

[OGSixshooter]

was he a proven loser when he got that MVP votes????? lol (sarcasm)

YES! He got votes from some LOSER...and then proceeded to lose in the post-season in epic yet typical CHOKER fashion.

 

[Jipper]

they have a room, we have a guy.

We have an injured loser

 

[Hadenough]

No. The Giants have the worst QB situation in the division. Russell Wilson is washed. Winston is far worse than Hurts, Daniels, and Prescott.

No question Hurts and especially Daniels are better than Dak. The debate is really about Winston and Dak. Winston is a better pure passer but so many mistakes. Dak was an athlete playing QB and never had the arm Winston has. Daks injuries have sent him backwards. His mental state after that GB game is not good. Winston on the cheap is equal to or greater than an overpaid Dak. Wilson may be washed but would offer more than Dak in a playoff game.

 

[Coogiguy03]

YES! He got votes from some LOSER...and then proceeded to lose in the post-season in epic yet typical CHOKER fashion.

Lol lol

 

[JoeKing]

We had a viable QB2

What we "had" does us no good now.

 

[RonWashington]

It’s encouraging if the Cowboys don’t sign one of the scrap heap back ups and actually pick up a McCord or a Dart possibly in the draft to actually have a young back up with upside that might give # 4 pause when drives stall or INT’s sail into the hands of safety’s . Actual accountability for the QB .

 

[BoyzBlaster]

Generally I would much rather be NYG picking up one of this year's top QB prospects though I'll admit those prospects don't really look too good.

Agreed, but like you I'd rather roll the dice with a young 1st rounder than just trot the same ol same ol that we already know is going to end with mediocrity (best case).

 

[fairviewfarmer]

Philly-Superbowl winning QB this past season

Washington- Rookie Phenom, will he be better, worse, or ok in his 2nd season

NY- Just signed 2 veteran Qbs- Winston and Wilson, can one of them win them some games and be better than what they've had in recent years, or will their age be too much?? Will they get a rookie QB with their first pick who could energize that franchise??

Dallas- Prescott who is coming off a serious injury to his leg, can he recover and play like a 60 million dollar QB??


Do we have the worst situation, I know it's too early to tell!! Please give your thoughts

In a word, yes.

 

[ErikWilliamsHeadSlap]

We have two sets of fans, the homers and the realist. Which are you referring to?

Both. There are few realist. There is a third group. The haters. They are extremists as well as the homers. The truth is always somewhere in the middle. That's why there are so few realists.

 

[morat1959]

Both. There are few realist. There is a third group. The haters. They are extremists as well as the homers. The truth is always somewhere in the middle. That's why there are so few realists.

What exactly do they hate?

 

[conner01]

Philly-Superbowl winning QB this past season

Washington- Rookie Phenom, will he be better, worse, or ok in his 2nd season

NY- Just signed 2 veteran Qbs- Winston and Wilson, can one of them win them some games and be better than what they've had in recent years, or will their age be too much?? Will they get a rookie QB with their first pick who could energize that franchise??

Dallas- Prescott who is coming off a serious injury to his leg, can he recover and play like a 60 million dollar QB??


Do we have the worst situation, I know it's too early to tell!! Please give your thoughts

Winston and Wilson aren’t as good as Dak

 

[McKDaddy]

Winston and Wilson aren’t as good as Dak

In what way?

 

[ErikWilliamsHeadSlap]

What exactly do they hate?

Everything. They have nothing good to say about anything that anyone associated with the Cowboys says or does. Tgey see everything in a negative light. Just as the homers defend everything.

 

[Coogiguy03]

Winston and Wilson aren’t as good as Dak

Maybe not but who says they don't go on a hot streak

 

[SquidwardTentacles]

Philly-Superbowl winning QB this past season

Washington- Rookie Phenom, will he be better, worse, or ok in his 2nd season

NY- Just signed 2 veteran Qbs- Winston and Wilson, can one of them win them some games and be better than what they've had in recent years, or will their age be too much?? Will they get a rookie QB with their first pick who could energize that franchise??

Dallas- Prescott who is coming off a serious injury to his leg, can he recover and play like a 60 million dollar QB??


Do we have the worst situation, I know it's too early to tell!! Please give your thoughts

Has he ever played like a $60M quarterback?

 

[SquidwardTentacles]

But are we happy paying him 60 million just to hand the ball off

$60M, and we need to do things to make him look better.