Do we have the worst QB situation in the NFC East?

Us or the Giants.

If contract wasn't a factor, I'd say the Giants have the worst situation because Wilson is basically washed at this point. But when you factor in the contract, Dallas has the worst QB situation.
 
Dak is better than Wilson and Winston. The question is whether he's $40m better than both combined. He's also a big cap liability for the next couple of years, whereas the Giants can start fresh next season if their guys don't work out. At Best, Dallas is 3rd in the East, and not far from last. They're also paying more than anyone else in the league at QB. Not the ideal position to be in.
 
Coogiguy03 said:
Philly-Superbowl winning QB this past season

Washington- Rookie Phenom, will he be better, worse, or ok in his 2nd season

NY- Just signed 2 veteran Qbs- Winston and Wilson, can one of them win them some games and be better than what they've had in recent years, or will their age be too much?? Will they get a rookie QB with their first pick who could energize that franchise??

Dallas- Prescott who is coming off a serious injury to his leg, can he recover and play like a 60 million dollar QB??


Do we have the worst situation, I know it's too early to tell!! Please give your thoughts
Click to expand...
I'd still say the Giants, but this is nothing new for Dallas and the NFCE... like Romo or not, when he was here at times it was him and 3 1st round QBs starting in the NFCE, and I get that draft position isn't everything, but I think it shows how the team looks at the QB position.
 
Coogiguy03 said:
Philly-Superbowl winning QB this past season

Washington- Rookie Phenom, will he be better, worse, or ok in his 2nd season

NY- Just signed 2 veteran Qbs- Winston and Wilson, can one of them win them some games and be better than what they've had in recent years, or will their age be too much?? Will they get a rookie QB with their first pick who could energize that franchise??

Dallas- Prescott who is coming off a serious injury to his leg, can he recover and play like a 60 million dollar QB??


Do we have the worst situation, I know it's too early to tell!! Please give your thoughts
Click to expand...

Great post!! The Giants have Winston and Wilson.... none of them are better than Dak at this point so I wouldn't say we're in the worst position. We're probably in the worst quarterback DEPTH position.

Now as far as Dak playing like a 60M dollar QB. That remains to be seen. Having actual offensive weapons and a solid offensive line remains to be seen as well.
 
Coogiguy03 said:
Philly-Superbowl winning QB this past season

Washington- Rookie Phenom, will he be better, worse, or ok in his 2nd season

NY- Just signed 2 veteran Qbs- Winston and Wilson, can one of them win them some games and be better than what they've had in recent years, or will their age be too much?? Will they get a rookie QB with their first pick who could energize that franchise??

Dallas- Prescott who is coming off a serious injury to his leg, can he recover and play like a 60 million dollar QB??


Do we have the worst situation, I know it's too early to tell!! Please give your thoughts
Click to expand...
In the East?

Lol

Question should be: in the NFL.

We have an badly injured QB at #1, from whom nobody knows if he can ever get dressed on his own. And even without being badly injury prone is a bad NFL QB.

Just too much "bad" surrounds this bad human being.

After that we dont have a backup nor a backup for him.

Giants at least have 2 QBs.
 
GINeric said:
Great post!! The Giants have Winston and Wilson.... none of them are better than Dak at this point so I wouldn't say we're in the worst position. We're probably in the worst quarterback DEPTH position.

Now as far as Dak playing like a 60M dollar QB. That remains to be seen. Having actual offensive weapons and a solid offensive line remains to be seen as well.
Click to expand...
The question wasnt about Dak.

The question was about the whole quaterbsck position.

and we are worse than the giants just because you have to value the backup we are missing also
 
TwentyOne said:
In the East?

Lol

Question should be: in the NFL.

We have an badly injured QB at #1, from whom nobody knows if he can ever get dressed on his own. And even without being badly injury prone is a bad NFL QB.

Just too much "bad" surrounds this bad human being.

After that we dont have a backup nor a backup for him.

Giants at least have 2 QBs.
Click to expand...
Lol lol lol lol lol lol lol
 
Coogiguy03 said:
Philly-Superbowl winning QB this past season

Washington- Rookie Phenom, will he be better, worse, or ok in his 2nd season

NY- Just signed 2 veteran Qbs- Winston and Wilson, can one of them win them some games and be better than what they've had in recent years, or will their age be too much?? Will they get a rookie QB with their first pick who could energize that franchise??

Dallas- Prescott who is coming off a serious injury to his leg, can he recover and play like a 60 million dollar QB??


Do we have the worst situation, I know it's too early to tell!! Please give your thoughts
Click to expand...
Personally, I can't imagine a worse scenario than Dallas has relative the the NFCE.
 
As of today yes. Maybe the league. A starter that hasn't played in months after an awful injury and a backup that only our team likes.
 
TwentyOne said:
The question wasnt about Dak.

The question was about the whole quaterbsck position.

and we are worse than the giants just because you have to value the backup we are missing also
Click to expand...

That's why I mentioned worst quarterback depth. I understand what you're saying my guy.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Staff online

Members online

... and 76 more.
Total: 4,365 (members: 176, guests: 4,189)

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
464,536
Messages
13,817,077
Members
23,780
Latest member
HoppleSopple
Back
Top