Dolphins release john beck qb, should we sign him?

[Hostile]

Interesting. How would you compare Beck to McGee?

I like him more.

I will say this, I think Beck could beat out Leinart in Zona.

 

[Dawgs0916]

I like him more.

I will say this, I think Beck could beat out Leinart in Zona.

:laugh2:

One thing about Hos is, once he likes you, he'll go to bat for you no matter what anyone else thinks

 

[Hostile]

:laugh2:

One thing about Hos is, once he likes you, he'll go to bat for you no matter what anyone else thinks

Loyal as a dog.

 

[dbair1967]

some fans in here liked john beck so shouild the cowboys sign him?
John Beck-QB- Dolphins Apr. 27 - 7:28 pm et


Dolphins waived QB John Beck.

Beck, on the trade block since Bill Parcells took over as Fins VP of football operations, was the 40th overall pick in 2007. A Randy Mueller/Cam Cameron era holdover, Beck appeared in five games as a rookie. He literally looked scared in the pocket and produced two touchdowns to eight turnovers, including five lost fumbles. Some team will probably claim Beck off waivers, but he was already old coming out of BYU and his NFL future is bleak at best.

The boats already sailed for us in regards to Beck I'd think. Once we spent a decent draft pick on a QB, there's no chance they give up on him this quick.

He'll get a shot elsewhere, but I'm not real high on him ever being much mroe than a #2.

 

[BAT]

I like him more.

I will say this, I think Beck could beat out Leinart in Zona.

I hate to tell you this Hos, but that's not exactly a ringing endorsement. Leinert has very little passion for the pro game these days, and it shows on the field.


But the fact that you like Beck's potential over McGee's is intriguing. I thought McGee would be a good developmental option, but not with the first pick in the 4th. I would be surprised if McGee is ready to contribute in 3 years. He is that far behind the curve.


I know you like Beck, but have the Cowboys seriously shown interest in him in the past? And why would they back off if the Dolphins were on the verge of giving him up? The questions are rhetorical, unless you actually have those answers of course.

 

[Hostile]

I hate to tell you this Hos, but that's not exactly a ringing endorsement. Leinert has very little passion for the pro game these days, and it shows on the field.


But the fact that you like Beck's potential over McGee's is intriguing. I thought McGee would be a good developmental option, but not with the first pick in the 4th. I would be surprised if McGee is ready to contribute in 3 years. He is that far behind the curve.


I know you like Beck, but have the Cowboys seriously shown interest in him in the past? And why would they back off if the Dolphins were on the verge of giving him up? The questions are rhetorical, unless you actually have those answers of course.

We had a trade on the table with the Dolphins last year before the Deadline. They wanted Anthony Henry and because Newman got hurt and Pacman got stupid we passed on the trade.

He is a perfect fit behind Romo. Very similar player.

I'm not crazy about McGee, but I am so happy we drafted a QB. I can't even tell you.

 

[BAT]

We had a trade on the table with the Dolphins last year before the Deadline. They wanted Anthony Henry and because Newman got hurt and Pacman got stupid we passed on the trade.

He is a perfect fit behind Romo. Very similar player.

I'm not crazy about McGee, but I am so happy we drafted a QB. I can't even tell you.

Wow. Thanks for the lowdown, had not heard that story before. Goes to show I've got to check this forum more during the regular season. Mahalo much!

 

[Chocolate Lab]

We had a trade on the table with the Dolphins last year before the Deadline. They wanted Anthony Henry and because Newman got hurt and Pacman got stupid we passed on the trade.

Wow, so if Pacman hadn't been suspended, we'd likely have Beck instead of Kitna.

Thank Gawd Pacman is an idiot.

 

[Hostile]

Wow, so if Pacman hadn't been suspended, we'd likely have Beck instead of Kitna.

Thank Gawd Pacman is an idiot.

Actually we'd have had Beck instead of Bollinger.

 

[Chocolate Lab]

Actually we'd have had Beck instead of Bollinger.

Except surely we'd still have Beck this year, right?

So we'd have had to get a capable vet QB some other way.

 

[RS12]

I like him more.

I will say this, I think Beck could beat out Leinart in Zona.

Strange the tuna never even gave him a shot to beat out Pennington, and that guy could not break a pain of glass at 20 yards.:laugh2:

 

[Hostile]

Except surely we'd still have Beck this year, right?

So we'd have had to get a capable vet QB some other way.

I think we probably would, but we'd be excited about it. The kid can play.

JMO

 

[Dawgs0916]

Loyal as a dog.

Im just glad im on the right side of that

 

[Biggems]

IMO, there are some teams who could definitely sign Beck.....SF, Denver, Houston

 

[Nexx]

If only this happened a year ago.....

or last week. :bang2:

 

[jobberone]

Is Beck a better prospect than McGee is right now considering age yada. Surely McGee is more raw but which one has the best upside over the next few years?

 

[Bob Sacamano]

Send him to Arizona so he can be close to his biggest fan.

 

[JPM]

I like him more.

I will say this, I think Beck could beat out Leinart in Zona.

I think I could beat out Leinart.

I hate to tell you this Hos, but that's not exactly a ringing endorsement. Leinert has very little passion for the pro game these days, and it shows on the field.

Really ? I just think Leinart sucks and his 'tude doesn't help either.

 

[Apollo Creed]

Beck is better than Kitna and McGee, which isn't saying much.

 

[YosemiteSam]

I like McGee better.